HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | skzo's commentslogin

The idea is interesting, but its too USA centric


What makes you say that? I'm in the USA and I don't think I've ever seen a meerkat, wombat, or a newborn panda cub in person. I think that was partially the point of the game though, wasn't it?


I don't understand that at all.

There's the Statue of Liberty, and I guess a basketball hoop..?

Meanwhile there's a meerkat, egg, power plant turbine, Big Ben, wombat, panda, Chichen Itza and the Pyramid of the Sun, none of which are remotely USA centric.


Some of the other games on this site use the metric system and I struggled so you could be off the mark on USA. I'd guess Australian centric based upon the animals and metric system


I felt that too honestly. The concepts, the objects somehow hinted at this


I'm currently looking into https://greenpt.com/ for my company,it has european data residency,no training on data and green footprint for energy.

Only thing is they aren't clear on the SOC2 certification. Am I being naive?


why not?


The onus is on you to describe some mechanism by which abolishing almost all taxation will magically fix wealth discrepancy.


I don't know what degree "fixing" means.

You can tax certain things a certain amount and you get diminishing returns. For example, if you had a 50% wealth tax, it would stop collecting anything pretty quickly and would cause pretty big economic disruption.

Land value tax has the potential to collect a lot of money with less disruption.

There's like $20 trillion worth of capitalized land value in the USA. That could mean like $1 trillion a year on-going assuming 5% discounting. Land rent is a perpetual stream of wealth.

There's only $8 trillion billionaire wealth. So already 5%/year would be less. And there's a huge incentive and ability to avoid it by moving.

And I rarely ever even hear suggestions for wealth tax rates around 5%. So then if you had a wealth tax, well land is wealth, and you'd be leaving a ton on the table as you could still have the land value tax at 5% of the capitalized value.

That money could be spent on public services that poorer people will benefit from more like transit, schools, or even local hospitals and subsidized healthcare. A typical point by LVT supporters here is that these services have the impact of raising land rents.

Most taxes have this dynamic:

tax -> invest in public services poor people use -> land rents go up -> land owners benefit

LVT has this dynamic:

Tax land -> invest in public services poor people use -> land rent goes up -> tax land more so land owners don't benefit

Landlords, developers, builders etc. should earn the return on the constructed housing, not the land.


> There's like $20 trillion worth of capitalized land value in the USA. That could mean like $1 trillion a year on-going assuming 5% discounting. Land rent is a perpetual stream of wealth.

Leasing the land of the US? That's your big revelation?

listen to the other commenter, fixing it means reducing wealth disparity.


"Fixing" means reducing economic disparity to some reasomable level.


And what is a reasonable level? And what evidence do you have that LVT can't achieve that? Maybe LVT creates such an increase in productivity it creates a virtuous cycle where land values increase so LVT increases and we can pay for so many public services and subsidies for the poor.

Idk but saying it's fixed when it's reasonable is really not answering the question.


I don't have exact numbers for what "a reasonable level" is off hand, but "a heck of a lot lower than now" would be a great start.

Again, the onus is on you to describe a mechanism by which abolishing most forms of taxes will drastically reduce wealth discrepancy. I'm not arguing against LVT, you're the one who's arguing against everything that's not LVT.


Tell me where I argued against everything that's not LVT lol

Again strawman and false dichotomy.

I can't help if you think LVT wouldn't reduce the disparity sufficiently. I'm saying that it's possible it does. I outlined the process how. You don't accept it that's fine. But I do think a big LVT would make a heck of a difference.

Again, that doesn't mean I'm against every and any other tax that could also make a difference.


You were trying to argue in favour of Georgeism weren't you? If not .... what point are you trying to make exactly?


Stonehenge is always mentioned as reference but you have much much older ones:

Göbekli Tepe (Turkey) ~9600 BCE Almendres Cromlech (Portugal) ~5900 BCE


ROTFL


What I understand is that by doing this it seems like profit will shift to chip makers,as we'll run more models locally, and currently American companies have the advantage here.

So what would the long game be for chinese companies?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: