Point 1 is extremely debatable. Our current time has new problems that we're still learning to contend with for sure, but for the rest of human history life has been best summarized as most often being painful, violent, and short. Nowadays violence continues to trend downwards and happiness upwards even though things could still very much be better.
Point 2 is again going to vary a lot from person to person. There are people out there today who would prefer to never retire, going back into minimum wage customer service jobs in their elder age just because they want to, and I'd wager they would agree with you. On the other hand, there are swathes of people who can't wait to be free of responsibility, and countless more that are crushed by poverty and hunger when they can't meet it. Those people certainly care much less about "purpose," or in many cases are certain they won't find purpose in something as mundane as a job.
Yes it’s been trending downwards for decades. Like, a lot.
The world is much, much safer than the 70s, 80s, or 90s. It doesn’t seem that way because everyone is trying to convince you it’s not. But statistics don’t lie. This is the best time ever to not die or get robbed.
One set of arguments I found compelling is “The Better Angels of our Nature” by Steven Pinker, although I'll admit I've only watched his talks on YouTube on the matter and not read the book.
Really surprised to see you get downvoted. This has been known for years and for a long time was more or less a pillar of thought in hacker spaces, at least since Aaron Swartz was killed by it. Copyright has basically only been used to keep society down.
If someone writes a really great Harry Potter (or whatever other character) book that you wind up really liking and you give them a buck for it, but then some faceless corporation yanks it out of your hands and throws them into prison because they weren't the original Harry Potter author, what has society really gained by doing that? Seems like we just put a guy in prison and burned that book that you liked for basically no reason.
We have the sum of all human knowledge at our fingertips thanks to the digitization of academia. Great! Huge positive for society, we should be in a golden age where anyone can learn anything they want to, but we're not because some guy in a suit says you owe him a million dollars to get access to the journal some paper was published in (a paper which was made by someone unrelated to the suit on your tax payer dime). Unbelievable, debatably apocalyptic net negative for society.
Nintendo doing this is just more of the same again. It won't ever stop until the law is fixed to fight for you and me instead of being used to kill people like Aaron.
By definition they do not. Some poor family out there NEEDS money, as in money to live, and Nintendo does not. If a kid in that family decides to play Zelda for free, Nintendo does not suddenly deserve claim over that family's money, because Nintendo doesn't need it and that family does.
Money is a tool to exchange one commodity for another and not some divine arbiter of goodness, where the more you have the more good you are. To say some corporation deserves money when they have all the money they could ever use is so ridiculous to me. "Yes, we have made hundreds of millions, but poor little old us deserved billions!"
Agree and disagree. The OoT remake that just came out is basically all-in on banking on nostalgia, and it's sold out basically everywhere, so obviously what they're doing works even today. Them taking stuff down like this though is just obviously out of line, for much the same reason. If your stuff is flying off the shelves and selling out the world over, it should not matter to you that some people are ripping stuff for free on the internet somewhere. You made your money already, what more do you want?
Not even sooner or later, it's already happened. Friend of mine has already beat the new Ocarina of Time remake through a native PC recompilation as of two days ago and that game only released five days prior.
Could not disagree more. Ask anyone art inclined, anyone at all, and they will lay upon you their passionate hatred for Adobe and all it stands for. That Adobe continues to exist is only thanks to the billions it accrued from past good will that they have long since burned.
Notably they were able to, in one update, essentially double performance and cut load times to a quarter of what they were while also maintaining both backwards and forwards compatibility for save files and without breaking 99% of the mods on the workshop. Genuinely impressive feat.
Mod compatibility is remarkable and much appreciated!
I happen to know a bit about the game's guts because I've been working on a RimWorld-based IDE [1] for the last few months. The C# side has grown to 75k lines of production code, much of it depending on Unity/Verse.
So when I saw the Waylith news, my first thought was "well, now it's either a complete rewrite or legacy forever". Migration took one night and introduced only a dozen regressions, mostly in low-level interfaces that no "sane" RimWorld modder would ever touch.
Along the way, these pains and hacks went away:
- Ancient net472 instead of cute net10.0.
- Mono-specific networking workarounds.
- Mouse wheel-event queue stuff.
- Unity font and atlas stuff.
- Semicolon key handling. Don’t ask.
- Unity/Mono WebSocket bugs. Probably gone. I still use a custom implementation; haven’t tested the new built-in yet.
- Harmony is in NuGet now.
Some weird bugs have migrated to the new engine. Like the game freezing forever on Alt+Tab in "Borderless window" mode, on both X11 and Wayland. Fortunately, Unity hacks still work.
Now to the headliner: performance. I haven't measured round-trip terminal latency yet, and loading times (X11 window to interface) actually got worse in my case.
But before the Waylith migration, an idle, focused SlopWorld window in Eco mode (colony sim stopped, some resources unloaded, map hidden, rendering in 60 FPS VSync) ate 50-60% of one CPU thread. After migration it's 15-18%. So roughly 70% less load for free, before any gameplay or mod optimizations.
Wait, I want to know which text editor they used! Now that you mention it, this is an important factor in purchasing any software. This information needs to be tagged at point of sale.
You're right - after all, just like LLM usage, the text editor you use will have an impact deep in the project and affect the quality of the end product, right?
They appear to have a pretty well-defined modding interface that didn't rely no unity's custom data structures. I'd suspect this project was started some time back, not just a one-shot port. Can't say whether or not any LLM's were used on tested in this project, but I get the feeling they set themselves up for making it portable from the start via some good old fashion thinking.
LLM's are still kinda shit at porting large in-house game projects. They can quickly and easily mangle codebases.
That's an odd thing to say given that there hasn't been any word on if they even used LLMs. Presumably this update has been in the works for some time.
I believe it to be very likely. AI is a development tool that allows you to implement things that simply weren't possible before due to time constraints.
You don't need a plane to get from America to Europe, but there are constraints if you don't use one.
I think most people are angry about the artistic portion like images and dialogue of games being AI generated more than the code. Code can be art as well in my opinion, but it still can be even if you AI just ported a large part of your code base to another target engine for example.
i'm pretty convinced that if you look at the cadence and tempo of updates on Steam among actively developed games that one could probably make pretty good guesses about which groups are using LLMs internally.
Doesn't prove anything, lots of stuff changes development house tempo, but to anyone watching things as a whole updates across steam games in active development are 1) quickening 2) narrowing 3) becoming predictably scheduled ; all of these point to more than just a single group refocusing on the work at hand.
I think builds are getting pushed out a lot quicker, and personally I know of a lot of anecdotes where groups' entire build and output chain are handled by LLMs invoked by cron (or a clone). That alone will add a lot of regularness to things.
This is true in general, but how does that apply to this game? Their release schedule has followed a pattern for years, this release included - a major version every 1-2 years, followed by a flurry of hotfixes that then slow down until the next major release. Wouldn't you see that schedule tighten post-LLMs if they became as AI-pilled as this comment thread wants them to be?
Tynan has been pretty positive about LLMs on his twitter. I obviously don't have any inside information, but I think it would be very surprising to me if there was zero usage of a frontier model in doing something like this.
There is a big range of understanding what "AI" even is, even among the most fervent haters. Some people will claim "Any visible AI is bad AI", others will claim "Gen AI is the job stealing one, others are OK" and some will direct their hate towards LLMs, but only running on other's servers.
I don't think you can say clearly there is a one "community" collectively "hating" the same thing here, it's just a lot of people with a lot of different strengths and directions of dislike basically.
I just heard the giantbomb guys describe how to block Claude code on Github so you don't have to play any filthy AI helped decompilations. It's a new kind of social benchmark among some people to be the most against AI.
I don’t like calling ppl stupid but it was a benchmark of “stupidity” if I ever seen one.
Why? Because people with well developed frontal cortex predicted the increase in capabilities easily while people with underdeveloped frontal cortex couldn’t extrapolate today’s improving slop to tomorrow competence.
Hence I have learned a lot about my fellow humans of many political tribes and how the distribution of those more “naturally talented at predicting patterns” look.
I stopped paying heed to certain kind of emotional, outcry driven people that thrive on your attention and take morality as a hostage.
For they aren’t what they want to appear to be usually.
If we all stopped giving them our time they would dry up and wither without audience and the world would be a more pleasant place.
I think that's a bit mean to the people (in my experience most people) who didn't and still don't see it. What's happening right now is really akin to magic. We're throwing incantations at sand and it's doing work for us. The rate of change is such that nobody can keep up with it all, even the people like me who use it daily.
What people DO see is having to use or be monitored by ABYSMAL types of AI at work or when they try to call x company for support or whatever. The outcry against data centers when the same people building them were moaning about how electric vehicles would crash our electric grid completely is quite justified. As is the outcry about creative and intellectual theft. Add deepfakes, scams, spam, misinformation, etc. and the negative externalities of AI for most people seem to far outweigh the "benefits". And everything beneficial seems to just be training the AI to do your job in disguise. Add in that the billionaires behind most of this tech come off as completely out of touch with the real world and I totally see the perspective of "screw AI and everything it stands for" even if I don't share it myself.
I think you are too lenient. Everyone has the same access to the information nowadays. Everyone can ask, even an LLM, about how it works, what does this and this mean.
There are no excuses in this day and age. I am also sometimes lazy but I never pat myself on the back for it.
Why would I hold other people to lower standards than myself? I think that, would be offensive.
I refuse to treat other people as less than myself. If I can investigate this topic without experience or phd then I assume anyone can obtain such knowledge before unleashing scathing critique.
Do not defend people who hate on things without due diligence and who generally are quick to hate.
My guess is there's a whole plethora of important information you're ignorant about that you could just look up and have full knowledge of if you cared. But nobody has time to care about everything. People only have so much time in a day. After 8 hours of working and 2 hours commuting because nobody can afford to live in a city anymore people just want to eat dinner, relax for a bit, and go to bed. Maybe spend time with their kids instead of sitting around reading about how AI is going to make them obsolete.
Example I would give is I'm totally ignorant of local politics. I just don't have any time at all to parse it, and I probably wouldn't bother even if I were magically given the time. There's people out there that would be just as upset at me as you are at people ignorant about AI. And it's not that I'm lesser than the person focused on local politics, I just spend my time elsewhere.
Not really? It happens in code too, just most the time its sight unseen unless a team explicitly mentions it.
I mean we've even been seeing gamer outrage over LLMs being used in decompilation projects. How "decomps have lost their soul" now that it doesnt take a small team several years.
Point 2 is again going to vary a lot from person to person. There are people out there today who would prefer to never retire, going back into minimum wage customer service jobs in their elder age just because they want to, and I'd wager they would agree with you. On the other hand, there are swathes of people who can't wait to be free of responsibility, and countless more that are crushed by poverty and hunger when they can't meet it. Those people certainly care much less about "purpose," or in many cases are certain they won't find purpose in something as mundane as a job.
reply