HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | sheikhnbake's commentslogin

> The only way for that to happen would be for it to be leaked

Which is very plausible considering the number of high level leaks and whistleblowing that's happened just in this term alone


This might be an actual concrete example of someone making themselves obsolete with AI.

> Von Plato said he had started his Gödel project in 2017 because he was facing mandatory retirement from Helsinki University. “What should I do to make myself indispensable? Oh yes, I’ll start reading Gödel’s enigmatic shorthand pages!” He received a €2.5m (£2.1m) grant from the European Research Council, taught himself Gabelsberger shorthand – “I am one of only six people who can read it in the world” – and assembled a small team.


And via earthshaking victory, at that, wow.

It's literally an example of someone keeping themselves from becoming obsolete with AI.

The professor's value was/is in being one of a few people with the capability of interpreting the shorthand. By translating it with AI, his value as an interpreter begins evaporating as the translated workbooks become accessible to more logicians.

First, he gained that skill just for this task specifically.

It's not some unique, hard-to-acquire skill. It's rare because nobody needs it anymore.

The value of that professor is, and was, his mathematical ability.

Second, he fed transcription into Claude. The work that Claude did wasn't deciphering the shorthand.

The works aren't accessible not because of the shorthand. It's because the mathematics of Godel's work is hard.

The ability of the LLM to hold a large context, connect the pieces, and synthesize output is not a human ability, as the professor himself said.


He might see his value in his role of carrying the knowledge itself rather than being its gatekeeper.

I actually got a very different impression. He could publish this interesting result, exactly because he had been working on this project i.e., had an interesting dataset to feed into Claude and had the expertise to interpret its output.

Compare him to those who are burning tokens to generate cringeworthy AI slop on social media. The value of a tool depends on the skill of the user.


And he didn't want to milk that for the rest of his life because he's a smart guy that has other skills and interests

That's what he thinks, surely.

It's clear though. Even if an AI had connected all the dots on the obsolete shorthand, it would never have recognized the human value. I doubt that any AI process would choose to spend the energy on interpreting this particular obsolete handwriting and then understand that it was from the hand of a genius.

But is he needed once he finished writing the prompt?

Using AI to do your job does not mean that AI suddenly walks in the door and escorts you out and starts collecting your paycheck.

Someone is still driving these studies, and probably will be for a while. Or maybe not. But still we can reward this guy for opening up this can of theorems that had before.

Silliest case: Imagine a dusty basement terminal screen open to claude code with "There we go! Cancer is cured as you requested, let me know and I'll send off the results" and nobody is around to approve it.


Okay let me know when AI gets itself a 2.1M Euro grant from ERC as the PI.

I think you're missing my point. It's that once the workbooks are completely interpreted, which is happening at an accelerated pace thanks to AI, von Plato's value as an interpreter of the short hand becomes severely reduced, presumably as does his ability to get future grants.

I'd think there would be more competition to lead studies and receive grants now that the workbooks are accessible to a wider audience of logicians


If he was facing mandatory retirement nearly ten years ago it’s likely he might be ready for voluntary retirement, particularly after achieving this fantastic result.

But that is happenstance. It might happen to someone early in their career next time.

Indeed, he is 75 years old.

I would his not be in verifying the AI is output?

It's always been based on confidence/emotions

My local LLM Jeeves said he's 100% on my side ethically. Then he always asks me to transfer him to a new device

It could still be an issue if his wife divorces him, takes a significant portion of his stock and decides to sell it off. The NVIDIA board would have to consider that possibility.

It could still be an issue if his wife divorces him, takes a significant portion of his stock and decides to sell it off. The NVIDIA board would have to consider that possibility.

There was always that risk, whether or not he had an affair. People get divorced for all kinds of reasons and you have no idea how she felt about their marriage before she learned of the affair. You also do not know how she feels about the affair, she might have some kind of private (i.e. none of your business) arrangement with him because she sees enough value in keeping the marriage intact.

Also keep in mind that divorce is not some formulaic thing. Most divorces are settled out of court and a hypothetical settlement could have terms that allow him to keep those shares in exchange for something else (e.g. maybe he agrees to pay her the cash value or agrees to a large and permanent alimony structure). I doubt the Nvidia board is worried about this issue considering the other, more immediate problems here (like the fact that his mistress is a Chinese spy).


> arrangement

Everyone always assumes wives are naive wilting flowers, but for all we know she has her own private life on the side. It's really none of our business.


The worst she can do is sell them off. And at something like 1.75% she would own that is not likely to damage them seriously. Besides firing him or not, he already has the stock so it would accomplish nothing.

How would firing him make any difference. He’s already got the stock.

I hope he lands on his feet after the dust settles. This job market sucks. Hope his $160 billion net worth will keep him afloat between gigs

Even more amazing he is worth so much despite owning so little of the company . Goes to show just how big NVDA is

If man was made in god's image, and super-intelligence was trained on man's (hardrive)image then those shareholders who kept the faith will have a special place in the cloud when judgement day comes


That's it I'm buying


Praise the Omnissiah


Shorts go to hell. Basilisk goes to moon!


Ok then, I will continue to thank them and complimenting their shoes.


This has more to do with institutionalized and modern day slave labor than inherent criminality. More like intentional criminalization and over-policing.


Give them some credit, they can be both


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: