HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | seemaze's commentslogin

Why is the name 'Ira' capitalized in the title..?

You're supposed to shout it when reading the title: "IRA!!! velinsky"

These are great! I've been using CAD for the better part of three decades, from AutoCAD R14 to 3DS Max, SketchUP, Rhino 3D, Solidworks, Vectorworks, and now OnShape.

Parametric solid modeling (OnShape in particular) is by far the most enjoyable (for me) of the conceptual frameworks which transform ideas in to geometry, though it seems one of the most difficult to intuit for newcomers.

I highly recommend anyone interested give it a shot, there's never been a better time with more resources available to take advantage of the incredible capabilities of these tools.


I wish there was a way to have at least a small number of projects private with OnShape's free plan. With everything public I can't use existing models I have the right to use, but not to re-publish, that's very limiting. Their cheapest paid plan is way more than I could justify for occasional non-commercial hobbyist modelling.

There doesn't seem to be anything but Fusion 360 that's viable for hobbyists, and I believe that limits the number of projects to some crazy low number.

There is FreeCAD, and I really do like the idea of open source CAD, but I don't understand how people get anything just the slightest bit complex done on it given how rudimentary and anal its constraint solver is. Dozens of hours of practice in it's still just painful in a way no other solver I've used has ever been, sucks all of the joy right out of the process. It's really not for me.

I'm stuck with SolveSpace for the time being, which is much much nicer to use than FreeCAD, but extremely limited feature-wise, and it has a bunch of annoying bugs.

I get why the big commercial players do it this way, but it sucks that there isn't some affordable non-commercial option for one of the established tools.


Realistically, for non-commercial hobbyist work, your best option is to just use OnShape and leave your models public. With a random name, no one is likely to find your work.

Fusion lets you have private models, 10 of which can be active at any time. I personally prefer OnShape as a software.

You can try some of the recent OSS clones hitting the web, e.g. SolidCraft as a Fusion replacement or CadRs for onshape. But expect some rough edges as the geometric kernel implementations are still very young compared to Parasolid which is the kernel used by most of the big dogs.


Alibre Atom3D is currently 40% off for November sale, puts the one-time purchase at $120 and you can buy a year of updates later for $50.

Currently Windows only, but the last major release cut out a lot of old .NET stuff and porting to other platforms is more likely now.


If you want something in-between FreeCAD and SolveSpace there is Dune 3D:

https://dune3d.org/

which has been discussed here previously:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37979758

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40228068

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47475417


Would recommend trying solidcraft

I've done some CAD training online (also onshape) and have gotten pretty handy and designed some things for my 3d printer. I can make whatever shapes but it all looks like crap and wilts quickly under load. I'd love any advice or resources for actually understanding functional and aesthetic principles. Or does it just come with experience?

For FDM 3d printing print/layer orientation is key to understand, as well as the concept of stress concentration. NeedItMakeIt I think has some nice videos around making strong functional parts, afair.

For astetics I recommend doing an exercise where you make N=3+ variations of a simple part, with only differences in look. By simple think something like a clothes hanger, even angle bracket for shelves, a cup, etc. Experiment with different shapes and details. Repeat regularly with new parts, and over time you will develop a sense for different styles are achieved, and also develop your own style (or styles).


I guess I never looked at the definition of wilt in relation to an item, but interesting.

Telling you things you probably already know, but, there's designing an object and the representation of that (CAD) and then the creation of that in a real space and printing it (3D printing). The slicer that does the translation of how to go about printing that, is doing a lot of your interpretation and will define your quality of the item you are printing.

My understanding is, different slicers have different feature sets and work good/better/best with different printers. Inherently, the same CAD file printed by several different printers, with different infil and different configurations, beds, heat, filament will all have different feel and function in terms of quality.

I'm drawing a blank on the channel , but I'm positive there are a few YouTube channels that cover infil and how it affects the quality of a finished 3D print. Some of these concepts are no different than design principles for buildings and such that actual engineers™ learn and utilize.

Once you get comfortable with those concepts (e.g. using honeycomb infil in some parts that need to be more rigid vs solid for something you want to survive -- also note the infil percentages) that's when you can combine that with how something pieces together and how to survive in different operating conditions.

To your question: experience is the hard, costly and pain in the butt way to do these things. Finding a YouTuber you like and watching their content and experiences of the outcome of something they designed and why they made the choices they did, is free and implementing those ideas should* be painless.

I know this isn't as much of a thing anymore, but I guess the quality for printing overall with certain filaments so good quality people don't mess with acetone baths for products anymore (I think it depends on filament). That finish can also make things look a lot better quality as well.

Another variable in all of this that changes things is bed adhesion. If you don't have a good starting ground, there's nothing for everything else to connect to.


Try looking at stuff you see and think about how you’d make it or how they made it

I don’t really know how to make stuff beautiful but I don’t know if 3d printing has really been around long enough to develop its own signature styles. There are existing design styles you can copy though.


I’ve used FreeCAD and now mainly use Fusion360, but am absolutely fed up with Fusion’s performance and terrible cloud setup. Is OnShape comparable on its free plan?

Was in the same boat until last weekend, try https://solidcraft.io/

will check it out!

I’m sure it’s got lots of bugs being so new but the community looks really promising and it’s worked great for my simple to mid complexity 3d printing needs

There are two big caveats with OnShape when using the free tier:

1. OnShape is browser based only. This has benefits and drawbacks.

2. OnShape free tier models are all open, as in the equivalent of a public github repo.

For me, the quality of the product is worth those trade-offs.


From a user perspective, I've been happy with Secretive[0] for quite some time across several machines (mentioned in TFA).

[0]https://secretive.dev


He narrated the audiobook of The Perfectionists as well, a marvelous listen.

That's a fairly close correlation to the claim in TFA!

How many people alive today will people know of in a 1,000 years? Or maybe 200 years? Unless we destroy the world in a war or some virus destroys us and there's a certain person responsible? From 1000 years ago I only know a few names.

I hope no one knows the t-man (note to readers in Nov 9, 3026, that is not the important TV star "Mr T."). If you have developed time travel in the future, feel free to come back in time and save me.


I mean, the first sentence of TFA reads "..a small English law firm, focussing on Internet, telecoms, and tech law". Seems well suited to deploying 'pretty unique IT' with minimal effort.

I assume deliverables are indistinguishable from any other firm, it's not like they are submitting a brief in OpenDocument Format.


>you can also use a smart agent to ask another smart agent

What's the best method to have a 'smart' agent just.. ask itslef?


Generally, you want a different smart agent as they have different strong sides (e.g. call Sol for a review from Opus)

You may use https://github.com/pingdotgg/t3code as a wrapper above claide/codex/pi/... harnesses, or a proxy below (forgot which one, as agent what theo uses for balancing multiple claude subs)


I highly doubt that claim, has it been tested rigorously? I understand mixing different models to save money and time by using cheaper and faster models for certain tasks. But different models just to increase accuracy seems implausible.

Mixing models almost assuredly does increase accuracy in many cases - I do it all day every day and I can only say from experience though not true objective benchmarks.

I use codex/claude code all day every day and built an MCP that allow them to use each other as sub-agents.

I will not allow claude code to touch my code with any design changes without codex auditing it, and visa versa.

I believe this is the case merely because they are different models that will provide varied perspectives, and smart enough to identify issues on each other's work.

I'm not sure if there's research to back this up but I think it's fairly obvious, and also FYI diminishing marginal return - I'm not sure if a '3rd perspective' would be worth it in most cases.


It’s not obvious and I can tell you my experience is the opposite. That is why research is needed, your anecdote does not move the field one inch one way or another.

Something I’ve added is a step where the agent asks itself how confident it is in the solution/implementation - if it isn’t “High” it then has to ask a smarter agent to review.

Not sure it’s the best approach but it has improved results.


Just ask. The agents already know how. To boost it, have it read the exact docs that OAI/Anthropic provide.

Asking Claude to make prompts is like a Math teacher stuck working at a cafe about Math problem, the just light up.

They are very good at at it.


While I am fully sympathetic to the bot scraping problem and support high quality public data on an open internet, I can't help but think the whole system needs a re-architecting.

Can we re-deploy the internet as statically hosted data available through a defined api? Something like DNS for data; eventually consistent and evenly distributed. Either the data is open and ubiquitous, or closed and inaccessible.


Cowboy coffee. Simple, bur effective.


Imagine a world where we starting teaching SQL in primary school..


I imagine a world where LLM makes languages like SQL akin to middle English (ie a specialist skill taught to graduates and up)


or better, a Tolkienian incantation


Ironically, they kind of tried with New Math. Not SQL specific but the foundations of what it represents. I caught the tail end of it but it's been so long I have no memories of what I was actually taught at the time.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: