I agree with the idea that license plates are the biggest part of the problem and that they've had a huge kind of scope creep in terms of what they're used for.
Whenever I've thought about this problem, the challenge with a more high-tech and privacy-friendly alternative is the intuition that it's good if witnesses to a crime or accident can memorize or write down the plate of an involved vehicle in order to make that specific vehicle identifiable. If the vehicles were providing only a cryptographic identity that wasn't memorable or that required special equipment to query, we would lose the "the robbers got away in a car with this plate" or "the pedestrian was run over by a car with this plate" scenario, which feels like a surprising cost somehow.
If it weren't for that, it might be feasible to use some more modern cryptographic approach to ensure that cars are licensed or insured without also making it easy in general to track them or people's activities or whereabouts. But allowing the public to quickly see any car's identity with their eyes and memorize it with their minds is quite a harsh constraint.
Maybe -- it helps the case for plates that often that reporting is almost always about accidents which means the fact that it's easy to remove or swap a plate and people frequently do doesn't undermine some of the plate advantages.
I have sympathy for the reporting running from accidents case, but I'm wary that this isn't just an artifact of the normalization of intrusions that predated me.
Imagine by an accident of history we didn't have plates so far and they were proposed today in our world of surveillance automation. I think it would be quite controversial. Perhaps it would be adopted in some places but not others, I think it's easier to imagine adopting mandatory identifying plates today in NY than in SD, WY, MT, for example.
Yes, that's an interesting thought. It's also possible that there are more car accidents, and more cars used in crimes, in urban than in rural regions. Maybe people's intuition in urban regions would be more comfortable overall with at least some forms of surveillance-facilitating technologies, because people are somewhat more afraid of accidental or deliberate harms coming out of interactions with other people?
Right. The preferred tradeoff for some things depends on ambient conditions, density, etc. ... on top of personal values, culture, etc. ... and a lot of path dependence.
They do have such a limitation, because of things like UDRP. It's just that there are maybe some forms of restriction on the processes by which domain names can be involuntarily transferred or seized. But it's a real possibility!
but it's tricky because the domain name registries and registrars have a kind of thicket of contracts nowadays that subordinates registrants' property interests to other rules and considerations. So I don't think a court would think that a modern-day domain name registrant has property rights in a domain name that supersede all of those contractual terms.
Edit: my recollection is that Kremen v. Cohen interpreted the legal defaults that applied because Kremen registered the domain name in an era when Network Solutions didn't require registrants to agree to a contract that limited Network Solutions's liability and gave it various explicit rights and powers.
I'm not a huge ICANN expert, but I think ICANN broadly thinks the status quo is preferable to one in which registrants had stronger, less equivocal property interests in names.
The Wikipedia summary of the case suggests that the ruling was much more than it was. Courts tend to rule on narrow issues, as it did here.
The question before the Court was not whether a domain name is a form of property. Both parties agreed that a domain name is a form of property; that wasn't in dispute. The Court did affirm their shared position in black letter law, though.
Rather, the question before the Court was whether, as intangible property, a tort of conversion claim relating to the domain name could be made under California law. Previously, cases disagreed as to whether it could be recognized. The Court found that it could be.
Real property is 'owned' but contingent on property taxes and sometimes other obligations being fulfilled every year.
Except for domains it doesn't make sense to record the ledger at the local courthouse, since there need to be a primary authority.
But a local (or other) govt ledger of ownership and xfer might not be a bad idea as a source of legitimate ownership, whether subservient, adjacent, or superior to the ICANN blessed registrars.
And no, it wouldn't require every domain purchase or transfer to be filed at a courthouse, but you could to bolster your proof of ownership or secure state backed property rights, like many states do with property leases (and even sometimes sales).
reply