HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | sanid's commentslogin

I mean they are entitled to it in a way. You pay Apple 99 Dollars a year to be able to distribute your apps on the store. Why should apple care if it is design spam or a duplicate of an existing app? Most of the apps available in the store would check those boxes too.

Apple has been famously strict about App Store submissions since it started… these comments confused about it make me feel old!

This is going to be fun. There are already replica phones for the flagship phones that are running a shitty android version that has been customized to look like iOS. People need to tripple check now when buying older used iPhone models.


>Does not work (yet):

>App Store content and Apple ID sign-in (no Secure Enclave; FairPlay daemon exits)

That seems like a huge roadblock, even if were able to resolve all the driver/OS issues.


Sounds like a huge win to me. Neither of those should be required. Replace Apple's walled garden with open login and open stores.


Just use the jailbroken store and you get all apps from free from there


also,

>Does not work (yet)

>- Cellular, Bluetooth

>- Charging under our kernel (the phone only discharges)


That's quite blocking for a phone ;-) But this sounds so cool if it's going to work!


I imagine official support for 3rd party app stores might open up some options for easily installing apps. However, that might require the store adding support for this type of iOS install or a newer version of iOS with 3rd party app store support.


>I imagine official support for 3rd party app stores might open up some options for easily installing apps

Given you own the OS, that's not an issue. You can make it pre-jailbroken and load whatever third party app store if you want. The bigger issue is that no app store = no "normie" apps like uber or google maps. I suspect most of the stock apps won't work either because they enforce device attestation on the backend endpoints, so it'll be miserable to use. Note in the maps screenshot, there's nothing behind the modal. It's just blank, suggesting it can't load the map tiles. You'd be better off using an android skinned as ios (possibly vibedcoded) than using this mess.


There's several PoCs showcasing Apple Maps loading just fine on X


Someone is going to set up an unofficial app store for this and fill it with pirated and malware-ridden apps. Then some companies will be convinced into releasing .ipsw files for "debug and research" purposes and starts taking subscription through those installs. Then Apple will lose choices but to support randomly downloaded .ipsw files on regular iOS devices to avoid becoming the lesser option against those, and we could slowly crawl back to the code freedom we had in 2006. Or this gets DMCA'd in 3 hours and nothing will come of it.


I doubt it, tbh. How many people will install such a HackIOS in the best case, 1000? 10000? There have to be a billion or more iOS users out there, so the pressure on app vendors or Apple will be negligible.


They could implement Grapple Store and then clone most popular apps.


I mean in theory Apple are a company of humans using services offered by other humans to make hardware used by other humans.

What I mean by that is if someone can create a near perfect replica with all the software keys needed and then clone a known serial number or range of serial numbers, when it comes to apple pushing out an OS update, how are they to know which the real devices are and which aren't?


> "[..] if someone can create a near perfect replica with all the software keys needed and then clone a known serial number or range of serial numbers [..]"

I think you would need to hack and emulate the whole security enclave, which contains quite a bit of factory-provisioned data IIRC.


Didn't the legal battle between Apple and Samsung show that Apple would not be very open to a iPhone clone?


Are you trying to say that phone clone companies are beholden to laws? Because I can assure you that they are not.

Just like you can still buy fakes rolexes etc lmao.


It is definitely not legal to sell counterfeit goods, including imitation Rolex watches: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark_Counterfeiting_Act_o...

Even if you disclose to the buyer that it's counterfeit, it's _still_ illegal. You can't just use someone else's name, logo, or protected designs without authorization.

In fact, it's so severe, you can face >= 10 yrs in Federal PMIA prison and owe fines up to $2M — just for the first offense.


I'd venture the legal forces that Apple can bring to bear are not in the same ballpark as Rolex. I'd expect Apple to use their influence with US govt to get Customs to stop shipments from coming in. It's not like these devices would be made in the US.


But they also don't have to be bought exclusively in the US.


Clones/knock offs are already illegal. Doesn't really stop em. Only technology solutions can, until they're broken as well.


I can't disagree more. A lot of shops in our city have done this and I actually miss the shitty photoshopped images that did not even look like the real life dish anyway. AI signs are way worse.


I thought that was parents point, that currently they're using so shitty AI generated logos, that even if we despise that as a concept, at least better models output slightly less sloppy shit. But re-reading it, I'm not sure that was the right initial reading.


I am wondering if in 2-3 years AI will be heads and shoulders above us in both images and text. Then will we continue to see the slop accusations? Maybe its slop is better than most of our work.


> Then will we continue to see the slop accusations?

If it doesn't look like the food you're about to purchase, yes? Why is this even a question in this context.


Yes, even though fast food places would previously use every food photography trick in the book to make the food look good, there was at least some relation between the menu and what you actually get, which people just seem completely fine with dispensing because the affordances of image generators work against including product photography

(Have also heard about people - not just scammers/spam operations - using generated pictures and descriptions for dating profiles and real estate ads, and I cannot understand what outcome they expect when someone follows up and immediately realizes what's up)


"Here is a picture of the dish, make it look nicer and use that as a reference"


> "Here is a picture of the dish, make it look nicer and use that as a reference"

That's not a function of improvement in models, though, which was the question. You could literally do that today, no need to wait for models in "2-3 years".


"Users will voluntarily prompt better to avoid misleading people" will be the "people can simply write memory safe C" of the late 2020s


“Stop calling it slop you guys, I’ll have you know I am even sloppier”


It might be a sub-comment on a tweet that was fairly viral last week. Or it might be serious. We’ll never know.


we will never know.


Your comment adds literally nothing to this discussion. You can't form an opinion on the topic discussed because of your opinion on someones politics. Great, don't comment.


What judicial system are you talking about? The fist incident in the list is something that happened in Australia. This is a technology used worldwide so I don't see how applying US standards works out here. Especially when there are countries out there that don't require intent and will look at the negligence presented.


>This is a technology used worldwide so I don't see how applying US standards works out here.

all three companies mentioned are headquartered in the usa, and im familiar with the CFAA in the us, so i am applying those standards. i should have noted that, sorry.

>will look at the negligence presented.

as far as i am aware, no evidence of criminal negligence has been brought to the public. has australia brought a case against openai or accused openai of acting negligently?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: