HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | samstokes's commentslogin

I love the idea of helping people learn good debugging habits and understand their code. But this seems like it is still just giving the answers, and would still create the same dependence on AI to do your thinking:

  You: I'm not sure, it seems random

  Nietzschian: "Random" is the word we use when we haven't looked
  hard enough. What do the server logs say for the 403
  responses? Go look. I'll wait.
That move from "I don't know" to "where could I look to find out" is one of the key habits that makes someone good at debugging, and here "Nietzsche" is just doing it for you.

It might seem obvious to look at the logs, but in my experience 90% of being stuck debugging something is just not yet having looked at all the available evidence.

It's true you could learn these habits by exposure to them, and this could be a neat alternative to pairing with a more senior engineer for that. But it looks like you could easily just keep saying "it's random", "I don't know", and the model would keep telling you what to do next, without you actually having to think.

I wonder if making it even more Socratic would fix this? E.g. "how do you know it's returning 403s? Oh, logs you say? Is there anything else they could tell you?"


What you are saying is true to a degree and debugging was 90% of the work in my career. Finding the smoking gun IS the key as you said.

It depends on where the developer is at in their journey too.

For some, "look in the logs" is a challenge just to find out what they are and where to find them and what they are saying. A great piece of advice for a person in this position.

For others, "There are files that hide in the caves of your computer's consciousness. Find what causes the shadows on the walls." is a valid call to dig deeper :)


... in 2023. (Thanks to whoever updated the submission title to include a year tag since I wrote this comment.)

This is a little misleading as written (with a 2026 timestamp but citing only 2023 data) given there is a wealth tax on the California ballot and wealth migration is cited as a reason to oppose it. This article looks like it supports that argument, but it doesn't.


  The best lack all conviction, while the worst
  Are full of passionate intensity.
- W.B. Yeats


Is that "difficult" quote from a separate source? I can't find it in the text of the linked report.

Also, the report says that both red and blue states had both overcounts and undercounts, which is a different picture than "over counts in blue states". It is accurate that more blue states had overcounts and more red states had undercounts.

I realise your question is rhetorical, but the report does offer a possible answer: "The 2020 Census faced many challenges such as conducting fieldwork during the COVID-19 pandemic. Other challenges to the 2020 Census included con- troversy around a proposed citizenship question and changes in the duration of the Nonresponse Followup operation." It's plausible that those "challenges" could have been experienced unevenly by state, particularly with how politicised the pandemic and its mitigations were in the US.


Also worth pointing out that when the census can't collect individualized data, they estimate it based on existing government data. The quality of data varies significantly depending on the local government, and pretty much all governments were struggling to figure out the current state of things during the pandemic.


Yeah, good catch. Meant to link to two sources, the census bureau admission and an article describing it. I forgot to paste one of them: https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/3504546-census-blunder-...


Opinion.


So what? The article describes the political implications of the Census Bureau errors. I cited the Census Bureau release itself so you can cross-check whether the factual assertions in the article are accurate.


The article describes political implications, and also implies political causes.

So it's useful to identify this as not something a journalist or credible outlet would actually put their name to.


> and also implies political causes. > So it's useful to identify this as not something a journalist or credible outlet would actually put their name to.

Why? And is the bottom line point wrong?

Gemini, citing a Pew Research study, seems to agree that Republicans lost 3-5 seats due to apportionment errors: https://share.google/aimode/9yPrkEU1U08abPWzF

> An independent analysis by the Pew Research Center and election data experts calculated exactly how those specific errors altered the final map. If the census had perfectly matched the PES estimates, the seats would have shifted as follows: [table showing apportionment errors cost Texas and Florida 1 seat each, and gave Minnesota, Rhode Island, and New York 1 undeserved seat each.

Fucking up 5 House seats for a decade seems like a firing-worthy offense.


Is your understanding that they found "the person responsible" for this "error" (of people not self-reporting to Census workers?) and then fired them?

That seems to be what you believe happened, but it's not.


This is misleading. It's true that you get a ballot, but it's a provisional ballot. Your eligibility to vote gets checked during the counting process.

The process is described on the same website you linked to: https://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/voter-registration/same-day...


1. Why send ballots until verified. 2. There's no document verification. Anybody can enter someone's name and social security number and get a ballot delivered anywhere. 3. I still don't trust the ballot gets thrown out if there's a mismatch.

In order to be 100% safe, there should be only in person voting with a voter id. Anything else is open to abuse.


Oh, I see, you are posting the same misleading comment on multiple threads here. I'm sure you are doing so in good faith, so here is a link to my other comment explaining why it is misleading: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49546715


1. Why send ballots until verified.

2. There's no document verification. Anybody can enter someone's name and social security number and get a ballot delivered anywhere.

3. I still don't trust the ballot gets thrown out if there's a mismatch.

In order to be 100% safe, there should be only in person voting with a voter id. Anything else is open to abuse.


You might enjoy Spirit Island, a cooperative game designed explicitly to make that "quarterbacking" strategy infeasible and encourage more interesting player interaction. Players have asymmetrical abilities and power progression, so it's hard to micromanage everyone, and everyone has enough choices to make that even the "I think we can win this turn if..." conversation generally depends on each person making their own reasonable choices rather than one person planning out the whole turn.


However, companies have been using AI as an excuse for layoffs since well before January 2026, which corroborates the study's conclusion. (Source: https://layoffs.fyi/ai-layoffs/) There is certainly an uptick starting 2026, but that could be explained either by AI actually causing more layoffs, or by AI becoming an even better excuse for layoffs.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: