Voice interfaces have been decent for a while now, and the majority of people still use a GUI for the vast majority of interactions. They have their place but they're not going to become the dominant mode of interaction for a bunch of non-technical reasons (primarily because people don't generally want to loudly announce their work at all times).
I think one counterpoint is that sometimes something tailored to you might outweigh something that is thoughtfully designed, but designed for everyone.
I do think people quickly vibe coding apps that they expect to get any real amount of market penetration is a flash in the pan that will fizzle out pretty quickly - after all, if it took you a few prompts to write it would take me the same to do that, so why exactly am I paying for your version?
But I've built a lot of apps with LLMs that I intend to use just for me - I don't think I'd fool anyone into thinking they're not coded almost entirely with an agent, but I don't really care - they match all of the quirks and ideosyncracies that I personally have for apps, so it feels much better than something that's one-size fits all, even if that one-size fits all thing had a lot of effort put into it.
I have a bunch of little utilities like that that work the way I want to work - a pomodoro timer, a task management app, a password manager - I'm sure 1password, or Todoist, or some time management app with a bunch of bells and whistles is better for the average user, but the stuff I vibe code is better for me, since I can tailor it to exactly what I want.
Right now, it's mostly tech people who are doing stuff like this, but I don't actually think these hyper personal apps require all that much technical skill to make, especially when they just run locally, so I could imagine a world where all sorts of people make things for themselves using prompts.
Is the explosion of this little personal utility apps worth the multi-trillion dollar investment?
Anthropic's published accounts will tell the story. I find the current implementation of agents on top of LLMs pretty fantastic as software tooling. I really hope they're here to stay. But that's not the story sustaining all this trillion dollar companies building, running, renting GPUs and "frontier model" development. The real question is: will this technology transform the economy (or at least the economics of software?).
So far I'm tending to see it as a continuation of the cloud play: incentivize ever more inefficient use of ever more expensive compute. Just look at the valuation of public "tech companies" over the past 10-15 years.
I'm excited to see how it all turns out, but I don't see another decade and a half of exponential growth in profits and stock prices. Feels like a historic peak right now.
Sure, I'm not making a comment on the viability of the industry in general. I'm just saying that at least with the pricing and ecosystem we have today, AI apps have a leg up on customization, which can beat out good design a lot of the time.
>> I have a bunch of little utilities like that that work the way I want to work - a pomodoro timer, a task management app, a password manager. Right now, it's mostly tech people who are doing stuff like this, but I don't actually think these hyper personal apps require all that much technical skill to make, especially when they just run locally, so I could imagine a world where all sorts of people make things for themselves using prompts.
I'm baffled at the utter stupidity of people making such extrapolations. Sure, everyone and their cat will start to vibe code themselves pomodoro timers and task managers. The hobos living under bridges are in desperate need of pomodoro timers and custom vibe coded apps to manage their tasks.
Pomodoro timers and task managers are sure worth a trillion quadrillion dollars because everyone needs, wants, and will AI-vibecode them.
I can be more precise if you don't want to rely on context clues and want to take a pedantically literal interpretation of "all sorts of people". The people who currently pay money for these kinds of apps have pretty good odds of just making their own in the future provided AI agents stick around and are comparably priced to now. It's already the case where about 30 minutes of effort and maybe an hour of waiting will get you something that likely matches your workflow better than a paid option, and if it's being created by an under-utilized AI subscription, the cost is essentially free.
You're substituting different actions. There's no reasonable justification for "beats his wife". "Sleeping with someone who isn't their wife" could have justifications - you don't know anything about their marriage.
I'm certainly not making a statement about Huang here, more of a general one, but generally speaking, when you're making judgements about infidelity as someone not part of that relationship you're working off very limited information, doubly so for a public figure that you don't know personally.
Obviously it's somewhat complicated when subordinates and Chinese spies are involved, and I'm not condoning infidelity, but IMO infidelity is a reason for a spouse to be justifiably outraged, not the public at large.
"Rules for thee, but not for me" makes some sense for OSS maintainers. The maintainer may be comfortable using AI themselves but isn't interested in slop grenade PRs, especially if they accepted PRs fairly begrudgingly in the first place.
This is only a sane move if the thing you're optimizing is to make the best product with no regard for time.
Unfortunately, time is a constraint for every company that exists, and a kinda-crappy implementation of something that's available today often beats a perfect implementation tomorrow.
Like with accelerating productivity gains, the actual wall clock start-to-end time is mostly unchanged if you wait with starting a project, you can always catch up, why does it matter if I do most of the work in the beginning of a project, or toward the end?
If you have users that want a feature, are you telling them, wait six months and I'll give you a perfect implementation, or, here's a 80% good enough feature you can use tomorrow?
If you have users, presumably your users are already paying you, so why are you rushing out half-baked features to meet their feature requests? They'll almost certainly keep paying you whether the feature comes tomorrow or in six months.
Changing vendors is a pain in the ass, especially in B2B. Like case in point, Confluence has been around for 20+ years and still doesn't have a working search function, and is comically useless it is at everything it does. Yet businesses all over the world are all in on that garbage.
> rushing out half-baked features to meet their feature requests
Holy strawman batman!
Wouldn't you prefer confluence fix their search now rather than hold off until the can fix it perfectly according to your end-all-be-all spec (that'll be invalidated after 2 weeks of actual use anyway)?
Well someone at some point requested a search function, maybe a business owner in house or a customer, but regardless they said "no problem fam" and hastily hacked together the monstrosity they've built.
What I'd preferred was if they took the time to implement it correctly from the get go. What they built instead is of no use to anyone. It's a search function in name, but it doesn't provide useful search results.
Search is hard though. From how it's behaving I think they're just sticking the data in Elasticsearch or Lucene or some such, without having done the long and arduous effort of then making it good.
Though my point is that even though confluence has a search function so broken they effectively don't have a search function, they aren't meaningfully bleeding customers over it. Business sales are incredibly sticky that way. Regardless of what pleases me as a user, Atlassian has no real incentive to fix the problem, and evidently hasn't (at least last I checked).
I would say the vast majority of people outside a tech bubble will not be offended by "we didn't use AI to write any of this" (the converse might be true though!)
As other people have said, if I wanted AI slop I'd just ask Claude.
Our workplace are heavy users of AI for nearly everything, but we still hold to the rule that if the audience of text is a human, it should be written by a human.
I know of one CEO who said "If you copy/paste an AI response and send it to someone else, they didn't need you in the loop and you don't need to work here anymore".
I had a situation recently where I had to onboard to a new process, I spent the day analysing the onboarding docs raising PRs working through all the issues we hit using Claude. At the end of the day my Claude was primed with all the knowledge from the days efforts. When a colleague asked me why his onboarding was having a specific error my session was able to quickly debug it and give him an accurate answer. His agent could have absolutely done it but it would have taken (slightly) more effort to get it primed rather than proxying through me to my agent
I find it shocking and disappointing how rare plainly logical and intelligent reactions like this are.
Not that I would ascribe actual intelligence to "AI", but those fans who claim it's better than your average human almost seem to be proven right by the sheer amount of incredibly stupid behavior around "AI".
Maybe better phrased as "another human". If you're prompting AI for your own purposes that's totally fine, just absorb the information and summarize it for people instead of just dumping AI output directly on them.
Is it a gentlemens agreement, or do you actually enforce this somehow? What stops anyone from prompting "copy my writing style, use less words, make some small typos and gramma inefficiences
That’s what I am doing. My writing is horrible and i produce much better results when i take AI output as starting point. But I do much more than adding typos (never) and grammar inefficiencies.
Try flipping it, that's what I do. I usually prompt AI for research, absorb thta, write my own thing, and then ask AI to proofread it and I'll let it fix small grammatical errors and typos, while larger structural suggestions I'll still implement myself. It doesn't take much more time in my experience and I'm infinitely more satisfied with my output.
It's expected to call out people (usually in DMs) when they post AI generated stuff. Occasionally people will link to a claude doc as like an "additional details here" type note, but that's the extent of it.
It's entirely possible that people have just finely tuned AI to perfectly mimic them, but if it passes the Turing test, I guess I have nothing to complain about. Our rules are less about some fundamental opposition to AI and more that it's just annoying to read unedited AI slop.
The obvious difference between your experiences and the person you're replying to is that he's residing there and you're visiting. You're right that your rights are far more limited when you're a visitor to a country crossing a border, but he and this thread are talking about what rights residents to a country have regarding the border.
Asking why someone is visiting is also pertinent to the border agent's direct job, because different types of visits require different documents, such as a work visa.
reply