HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | robswc's commentslogin

I don't believe I suffer, but it seems pretty obvious why someone would do it in silence. Many times when I tried to get help from institutions for anything nobody seemed to care much at all. It's like you could either deal with your problems in silence or deal with them "out loud" and have people pretend to care while looking helpless.

To be sure, not referencing mental health here but rather virtually any issue institutions claim to care about.


Institutions don't and cannot care. You're looking in the wrong place.

Well sure, when you're younger you don't realize that though and you believe when they say "we care about xyz."

I have difficulties, mostly due to overload, and sometimes it would be good looking at it from an other angle, discussing with someone. There are some male peers I am being able to discuss certain matters, usually a different detail with different peers, but not everything. I look with curiosity how my wife is able to discuss things with a professional. My concern are usually: the professional can only know about what she explains, the way she explains, the amount she explains. The output can only be based on that constrained input (sessions are bound by time). Probably it is not a surprise that things do not get changed much. I have no time for that - did I mention that I am overloaded? By the time I was able to tell it in a decent granularity, complemented by details from people knowing me a certain way - no-one have full picture - so the picture is not distorted by looking through my eyes only, by all this time I'd be really frustrated that things went on and we got nowhere. And all those assume that I am able to phrase and express clearly what the heck is going on, very difficult sometimes. Also that the professional is good at listening and is not trying to force a pattern on me. I am from an upbringing that taught me doing something when something is wrong, try my best and accept what comes out of it. Suggestions of others are pieces that may help or may not. Possibly pretty random (e.g. the person was basically me in that scenario and came out well, so they really know what they are doing, not just meddling for some reason).

Yeah, getting any external help is difficult. Need some inner source some way, accepting some level of 'flaws'.


This is not something I think about much (fortunately), but what is the point in attempting suicide by means that are not likely to work? How do we measure "true attempts" vs "cries for help." I guess ultimately they are very close together... but all the same it seems harder to attempt and not succeed.

The person may not definitively want to die, but may wake up one day and not care either way, so attempting is a roll of the dice.

It also may be down to what was available to them at the time. There’s a famous case study where a lot of women in the UK were dying by putting their heads in the oven and gassing themselves in the 1950s. The UK government changed the formulation of gas that was being piped to homes and the suicides stopped. If those women really were dead-set on suicide, they would have just chosen a different method.

What people who’ve never had extreme depression might not realize is that in those low moments it feels like you will always feel this way and it will never ever change. Then you wait an hour or so and the feeling passes. So a person may not feel suicidal 24 hours a day, only at specific moments. But in those low moments, the chances of suicide dramatically increase and as the UK case shows, accessibility to quick suicide methods makes a big difference.


I think in general people are not educated on the likelihood of success per attempt method, which seems ok.

Men are more aggressive so they choose more aggressive methods, which work better.

Attention.

> cries for help.

This is the most plausible hypothesis, judging revealed preferences by the outcomes.


>This is the most plausible hypothesis

It's not the most plausible hypothesis. Men are more likely to own firearms than women are, therefore they're more likely to attempt suicide by firearms.


How does that explain that this male vs female ratio stands in countries with low gun ownership rates?

I don't know anything about that statistic, so I can't comment. I'm talking about the US here, where the above is true.

I've been curious about the phenomenon of suicide for a while, so I've read quite a bit about it in different countries. One of the interesting things about suicide is the means of suicide is always whatever is most available or readily available in the environment. In the U.S. where guns are more available, about half of all gun deaths are suicides, and about 80% of those are men. But in some countries in Africa, men kill themselves more frequently as well, and the primary mechanism is by drinking pesticide.

My mental model is that men tend to be more extreme and less conservative than women (risk-taking is more prevalent), and this leads to more extreme approaches in how they try to kill themselves.

But it's been a while since I've read any of these statistics, and I have no special credentials. Just thinking about what we're observing.


Nonsense, that is an America-centric attempt at making up a narrative. The sex differences in suicide outcomes are essentially the same in countries with low to zero firearms ownership, eg Europe, Australia, Japan. If there are no firearms available, then other almost equally lethal methods are used (hanging, trains, etc).

The sex difference in completed suicides is nearly universally 3-to-1 to 4-to-1.


Top suicide methods in my country:

hanging/strangulation (9,164, 49%);

self-poisoning (4,098, 22%);

jumping/multiple injuries (2,423, 13%).

All three are equally available to men and women and anyone else.

In terms of rate, male suicide rate 17.2 per 100,000. Female suicide rate of 5.4 per 100,000

London has the lowest overall rate of just 7.3 per 100,000, 65% of the national rate. North East being highest at 14 per 100k.

The highest population group being Males aged 50-54 years, being 27.9 per 100,000

Wales is even worse, with Males aged 45-49 years being 32.3 per 100,000, and overall 21.6 (male) // 7.5 (female)

Generally the worse the economic opportunities, the higher the rate. Middle aged men are most at risk, men in general are at high risk, and guns have nothing to do with it


>Generally the worse the economic opportunities, the higher the rate.

Ding ding ding ding ding. There’s a throughline between men's issues and male suicide, and it's got a lot to do with money and power.


Even controlling for that the pattern holds.

effect still remains after you look at statistics in countries with low firearm ownership

Gunshot suicides account for 2.5% of suicides in England and Wales [1].

Try again.

[1]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15834784/


> How is this different from when you join a company and learn your corner of the codebase?

Because most AI generated code is incredibly verbose and noisy. This can be true for any codebase, but it is especially egregious in AI codebases. It is hard to prevent that by just saying "be concise" because knowing exactly where to be concise is the measure of true skill/intelligence.

Every time I have success with AI coding, it is because whatever I need done can work as a pure function, where the probability I have to return to it is very very low.

Making sense of a codebase is like putting together a puzzle. A purely AI generated codebase is like trying to put it together without a picture on the pieces.


I think its mostly because;

- Nazis were worse, and Soviets fought Nazis so they get a bit of a break

- It isn't convenient to for some narratives. (The idea that leftism is immune from authoritarianism).


I have been ringing this bell for years.

When I first started software, I thought it was the weirdest thing in the world for everyone to go "ok next step, download 1000 different pieces of code from 100 different places."

The only thing missing was the financial incentive, and ease of entry... and man if crypto + AI haven't got that combo down.


I guess I'm missing something but I don't see how this isn't just:

1. Creating more work 2. Shifting the existing work to specification

There's not really such a thing as a perfect specification. One of the things AI is taking away is character by character feedback cycles. Can't count how many times I'll be writing software and think in the middle of writing a return, realize this is probably not what I should be doing. I'm not sure how you would really replicate that experience when creating specs... nobody is going to sit and meditate on their specs for hours before writing them.


> If you have suggestions on how to name our products better, I'm all ears. Our intention is to make things clear and simple, even if we miss the mark sometimes.

I'm not the one you were talking with but catching you is godsend since I just ran into a lot of confusion on the naming myself. I think some of it has to do with how they are labeled in the app.

I think simple numbers in naming is great, even 6.1 is fine bc I understand that if I want the latest model, I just need to look for the biggest number. Where I got confused is in the "work" tab, I saw 'Astra' is set as the default. I see the label for it is:

"Frontier intelligence for your most demanding tasks."

To me that reads "this is the 'best' model." Then I see Sol-6.1 which is labeled:

"For coding and every day work."

Then Terra-6.1 is:

"Terra 6.1 Codex Model" (tbh this one might be the most confusing, I'm aware of codex the product but Sol is the one labeled good at coding)

From my POV as a basic plan-based user wanting to do something like...

> design a robust event-driven system, here's the details [...]

I honestly have no idea which one I should use.

Would Astra-6 produce a better design than Sol-6.1? Is the '.1' a big step up from Sol-6? (I'm guessing no but I truly have no idea). I would assume the answer is Astra-6 would produce the best one, even though the labels don't imply it is necessarily geared towards coding?

But tbh the "default" seems to always work for me... and after reading your comment, typing this one out, being forced to think about it... it doesn't seem too bad given your challenges in communicating the purposes of each model and wide audience of consumers. I'm also sure anyone could find a million problems with decisions I've made in software I've built so I try to not be too harsh :)


I would trade (as if I have any say lol) every single breakthrough they have made in math/CS for _any_ good progress towards a universal cancer cure (very theoretical, I know).

I'm kinda hoping they are investing just as much into that type of research. Its their money but man... I'd say 999/1000 people are unaffected by all these breakthroughs. They probably have no idea tons of legendary math/CS conjectures were proven true/false. If a breakthrough in cancer research were to be made, it would very quickly start effecting everyone on earth.


> I would trade (as if I have any say lol) every single breakthrough they have made in math/CS for _any_ good progress towards a universal cancer cure (very theoretical, I know).

> I'm kinda hoping they are investing just as much into that type of research.

The money would be better spent trying to breed a flying unicorn, because that's remotely possible.

"Cancer" is not "a" disease. It's a symptomatic description: cells in your body multiplying beyond a limit that is healthy for you.

What you are asking for would be like asking for a universal cure for headaches. What if your headache is caused by a tumor? Or a nailgun injury? Or psychotic hallucination?


Exactly my thoughts.

I find that unless the outcome I'm looking for from the model is almost binary and easily verifiable, it is basically faster to do the work myself.

Assumptions made by the models multiply and by the non-deterministic nature (dbf, similar to work by humans) I'll have something end up light years away from where it should be. During a normal workflow, I have to contend with every line I write forcing a very tight feedback loop... I suppose I could also sit there and spend 9 hours writing out a "perfect spec" but we've already tried that with waterfall development!

So, not sure if its the models, rather the class of problems I'm applying them to... but it is a bit ironic they are allegedly able to solve these conjectures but not stop to ask about assumptions.


> I suppose I could also sit there and spend 9 hours writing out a "perfect spec" but we've already tried that with waterfall development!

And a perfect (or near-perfect) spec is actual source code. And that's where I see myself with LLMs. They are great about generating source code. They are terrible at writing well-specified software, and so they need a lot of context: docs, plans, existing source code, existing templates or examples. And even then, they still need a lot of guidance.


I'm incredibly skeptical about everything these frontier labs put out. Results are results though.

However, could someone with a firmer grasp on the problems weigh in on how much are these recent results are function of cutting a virtually unlimited budget for some very smart people? I believe the LLMs certainly help iterate on ideas faster... but I am aware of very impressive work that goes on in quantitative finance. Stuff that would not really be published. That stuff is the result of paying smart people millions to produce results which produce $$$.

I have to wonder, would this have been solved if we simply gathered tons of smart people and paid them a ton of money to solve it? Or is it exclusively because they had access to LLMs?

Could they have achieved this result with previous versions of ChatGPT?


Quant finance is very different from math research; quant is much more applied math and programming, and the tasks are typically smaller than math research questions. Although it's true there's a huge overlap in the people good at both, there is massive re-training needed if you want to turn non-math-phd quants into research mathematicians.

As I argued in another comment here, I think even with unlimited budget, humans wouldn't be able to reproduce these results within a few years. I think AI has crossed a superhuman theshhold in math problem solving skills.


Sure. I can see how the problems being solved would be very different, and would require "re-training." I'm wondering though how much is it the LLMs and how much is it the humans driving them? Could this have been done with the models currently accessible? Could I have just prompted "solve this conjecture" and hand the work over to a PhD to verify? Or is it "unlimited budget" + "super smart ppl prompting" + "SOTA model" ?

I guess I just see this like how NASA went to the moon. In theory there wasn't a lot stopping us from going besides a good reason (and money). OpenAI has a good reason (PR) and money, so they're doing it. Will these things stop coming out after funding and motivation is no longer there? Or by next year will we have access to this model and anyone can solve any of these open conjectures with time + money?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: