HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | robotpepi's commentslogin

it's a bit funny: all that psychological jargon and shaky speculation about his mental state, but you missed that Tao didn't write the post.


similar to banner blindness or sidebar blindness, people have disclaimer blindness.


> This stuff reads as cope by scientists who spent their entire careers chasing these problems.

This is their only defense so far: deflecting valid criticism by suggesting, without evidence, that the scientific community is gripped by fear.


They're wrong. They're right about it being cope, but the cope is not from people in fear.

The people who feel fear about AI taking their jobs or doing worse things are not coping. They're saying all this is real and impressive and that that is why they are terrified.

The people saying it's bad and lies and they stole the answer and a million other things are just in tribal mode throwing whatever at the wall to defer to the pre-existing conclusion that AI is a corporate hoax. AI would have to be real to fear it in this professional and existential way, but they know it's fake, so they're not afraid.

It's sometimes done with more subtlety, like "it just comes up with some proofs by connecting existing things, it is not producing new insights, it's not creative or truly generating ideas". Which may be partly true. The denialism is shifted into refusing to acknowledge that within 20, or 2, years it probably will be producing new insights.


The cavalcade of illogic from the critics has been quite revealing, hasn't it?


To be honest this doesn't feel as such impressive as the others. It was recently proven in 3 dimensions, so it could be "just" an extension of that. I haven't read the paper anyways so this is pure spectulation.


> but incorrect in macro/long run

That you don't know. Nobody knows what AI is going to be capable of in 2 years. It could continue improving, or not. There's no strong evidence in any direction. You're just ignoring what doesn't fit your narrative.


people here really struggle with metaphors.


There's no real evidence for it but it is scientific fact that every Hacker News thread that's more than 7 deep is just a war between terrible metaphors.


They would unironically benefit from talking to Claude about this, lol.


> that is most people's experience with LLMs.

citation needed. my (university) students don't seem to learn as much as before.


your reasoning is sloppy. so confidently incorrect throughout this thread!


doesn't it use special relativity or some modern physics?


We don't know what models are going to be able to do in 2 years. If they don't improve much but people in charge simply decide to reduce the number of mathematicians, then we'll end up with a dead math community and no progress. That's obvious to everyone in position in power. Arguing that he's not emotional ready is very naive.


> All the arguments about the future mathematicians are imagined, and emotional.

Even if you don't like, at this moment, AI cannot replace mathematicians.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: