dangerous to call out a billion-dollar lifestyle...
A $100k+ certificate from an academic institution is still as a justification for giving rich people positions of power and influence and there is a massive pyramid of those who believe that having the piece of paper will elevate them to that status.
Having several such pieces of paper with my name on it I'll tell you they're only useful if you follow the field professionally. And even then, people tend to be more interested in the interview discussion of what work you did rather than the actual piece of paper. Other than that they're sed for justifications to grease the wheels and actually present a useful excuse as for making a barrier to entry. I have several wealthy friends who didn't do this route and correctly applied themselves and they're genuinely some of the smartest people I know.
I remember asking someone what prompted them to leave the field whilst their partner stayed on to do a doctorate. They were adamant that they had spent 4 worth-wile years on a degree. When I asked why it made them better at their current job (unrelated to their academic specialty) they got overly defensive asif I was being unreasonable... (for the record, yes they also probably had better on-paper results than me in uni)
The conversation went badly when I then asked why they believed the public should have payed for that...
3. teaches foundational material I likely would never have learned on my own (like math)
4. teaches how to discern truth from nonsense
5. teaches understanding of things that give one a lifetime of enjoyment
As for making college publicly paid for, the difference is making sure you aren't wasting your own money vs being paid to avoid getting a job for 4 years.
Taking this more generally (based on multiple education establishments).
1. For most, nope, not really, it's about passing exams, try thinking of masters courses or doctorates the real cash-grabs. Solving of complex problems in a truely independent way requires being given enough room to fail and having to ask for help.
2. Maybe, but again, rewards are very how-to-exam or how-to-write, how to ingest material maybe but little how to actually learn from the ground up into unexplored new non-textbook territory.
3. Foundational skills are a requirement for most skilled labour, if you don't follow the field you will never use these skills and frankly then a lot of this is wasted and I've both tought and experienced people having their eyes gloss over. Not everyone truely cares 'why?'.
4. Frankly a very bold statement with little direct evidence of research based consistent arguing from undergrads based on a consistent framework/process. If so a lot of discourse wouldn't be so tragically painful in skilled online forms. If you were tought how to embrase realising you're wrong in an argument I might agree, but generally most aren't.
5. This is the same argument for learning the classics before going into finance. My response is still the same, it's nice for the rich...
Post-graduate education has become what all of university is advertised as imo, the undergrad seems to be more and more kinder-garden for adults unfortunately. (Speaking from not being able to shout at students who can't understand the concept of binary numbers anymore...)
Regarding item 3. Yesterday, I had a meeting with an accountant to get my tax returns finished. It was clear they wouldn't be done on time, so he filed an extension.
He asked me if I wanted to pay an estimate or not. I asked what was the interest and penalty for paying late. He replied that I'd be charged 4% interest on late payments. I said I wouldn't worry about it, then, and would pay it when the return was finished.
He laughed, saying he had clients that were paying 29% on credit card debt yet preferred that to paying 4% on debt to the IRS.
I.e. he had many clients who simply did not understand how interest works, and was unable to explain it to them.
I can recount many episodes where understanding math has saved me a boatload of money, where most people get their tailfeathers clipped and never realize it. You can go on saying that most people don't need this knowledge, but I counter with they don't realize how much this lack of knowledge is costing them.
Why, oh why, do people in the US need to go to Higher Education to understand something as simple as percentages? (If this is the case the education system has simply failed)
This is, (to coin your own), grade-scool mathematics, or is treated as such across most of Europe.
Granted a lot of people fail because they simply can't be bothered. I don't buy the self-deprecating excuse of "I'm no good at maths me" from 99% of people repeating what they've seen on the idiot box, they just don't apply themselves. I've known someone math-dyslexic and they made a great deal of effort _not_ to highlight it, they were better than most normal people at simple stuff like this it just took them longer.
You are making an assumption that they are carrying the credit card debt. I pay for nearly everything with a credit card, but I haven't paid interest on a CC in close to a decade.
Without naming names, top league tables globally and all infamous from the UK abroad (and yes was on a hard-science), so no I went to the right university, but I'm highlighting that the main part of "teaching" is done at a post-graduate level.
If you've not pursued academia this far it's akin to that moment about 10 years after you left education where you think, "I wonder what it would have been like had I known this at uni" stage.
My experience (Caltech) is a major counterexample to all your complaints. It doesn't matter if your uni was top tier - if your complaints about it are valid, you went to the wrong one. Sorry about that. I got a great deal of value from my Caltech education, professionally and personally. I have no complaints about it.
P.S. The value you get from a university also can be heavily dependent on the choices you make while attending. I.e which major, which classes, how you went about taking the opportunities available. I chose classes for maximum utility in my expected career.
At University of Washington, for example, you can get an excellent education. But you can also get a worthless one. It all depends on the student making the right choices there.
Yes, but how else do they plan to announce they have achieved it without 1984 word management/control and polluting the training pool so badly that future trained models agree?
Plus show me an off the shelf solution to MDM that exists in the Linux space?
(Not too mention an easy to buy consumer devices which supports suspend/resume correctly in 2026, not even Windows can do that any more)
Apple is crap and evil about many things, but at least here they know their paying audience...
One case where Apple can be very useful is if you're traveling a lot for work.
Wherever you are you can probably find a local store that sells and services Macbooks. So if your machine is damaged during a trip you can get it fixed, or buy a replacement on the spot, and at least get through the work you are there to do.
For small-ish companies that can be a very useful feature.
Except it's still a slightly different challenge each time to "get it working", each different PC. A Mac is a Mac is a Mac, more or less.
I have a nice Framework laptop on my desk running Kubuntu alongside my Macs. Every now and then I check in, make sure I could switch to it if I needed to, test all my important tasks, plug it in so the stupid mainboard battery does not go flat.
And then I go back to my Mac, because I prefer it and even Tahoe isn't painful enough to switch. KDE is fine and I'll use it if circumstances dictate I have to.
I think critics misunderstand the extent to which Mac-using devs are "locked into Apple's ecosystem". Unless you're writing iOS apps, you aren't. You perhaps even exist in a more heterogeneous world (Mac and Linux, Mac and Windows, all three) than a Linux-using web dev does.
Essentially everything I run is not at all "locked in". I would miss the ease of keychain, handoff and Apple Notes (which I like despite its flaws). And then I'd deal with it. I'd probably carry on using an iPhone (I am very ambivalent about the iPad)
FWIW my "Apple ecosystem" is why I have been able to teach myself open weights/open source AI at a pragmatic level, because my secondhand off-the-shelf kit does an acceptable job of it without me yet having to specify a PC I don't have enough use for as a non-gamer. A lot of people have solved a lot of general problems that I don't have to tinker with too early.
This isn't a fanboy thing (I would consider myself a qualified critic). Both KDE and GNOME have some nice things. It's just a question of energies.
IIRC it was Adrian Cockcroft who said he used Sun at work, and a Mac at home, because performance tuning was his day job and he didn't want to do it at home; I think this resonates.
It has been my own choice for 28 years, largely: Mac plus linux.
Right but a secondhand thinkpad is not a laptop you find in the travel context of the thread.
(I dispute the main point, too — I spent flipping hours trying and failing to get trackpad speed right on a Surface Go in GNOME/Wayland. Ended up having to abandon that combination.)
On the contrary it (faster Surface Go 2) was one of the most practical little machines I’ve ever used, and was really impressive in Windows 11.
I am totally happy to lay the blame for the poor trackpad performance in Gnome/Wayland on the software, because the hardware was super. Absent that problem I would have used it for almost anything and I loved taking it on trains and to coffee shops; Apple has no equivalent machine at all.
But you’re making the point for me. Success in Linux involves either tinkering or constrained hardware choices, even now. That’s fine but I think the Linux world pretends the situation is better.
> But you’re making the point for me. Success in Linux involves either tinkering or constrained hardware choices, even now. That’s fine but I think the Linux world pretends the situation is better.
Have you heard of this new Windows thing that everyone's going on about? Almost nothing supports it out of the box and it's just all tinkering - and that's for something you have to pay a lot of money for.
You're equally hardware-constrained with Apple too. Can you find me an Apple laptop with four "proper" USB ports, a Displayport socket, and swappable battery?
> You're equally hardware-constrained with Apple too. Can you find me an Apple laptop with four "proper" USB ports, a Displayport socket, and swappable battery?
This is now a circular argument.
As I said, a Mac is a Mac is a Mac. Nobody is arguing it is otherwise.
That's the whole point of the thread I was replying to.
Of course it does! I'm exactly suggesting that those constrained hardware choices have value in the context discussed (agreeing with an earlier poster) and that in fact, if you're out on the road or you're under pressure and something fails, the Mac does have that advantage: you'll easily find one and there is no setup time to speak of.
Buying on the spot - sure. Anything that requires repair has to be usually booked in advance with some waiting time. Relatively short, usually days, but still not really possible to go into the store and get your laptop fixed right away in most cases.
There's also a difference between treatment and cure but we call it all a "vaccine" now (I prefer the transitional OED definition from pre 2019). We've already entered 1984s use of good speak especially around healthcare.
A $100k+ certificate from an academic institution is still as a justification for giving rich people positions of power and influence and there is a massive pyramid of those who believe that having the piece of paper will elevate them to that status.
Having several such pieces of paper with my name on it I'll tell you they're only useful if you follow the field professionally. And even then, people tend to be more interested in the interview discussion of what work you did rather than the actual piece of paper. Other than that they're sed for justifications to grease the wheels and actually present a useful excuse as for making a barrier to entry. I have several wealthy friends who didn't do this route and correctly applied themselves and they're genuinely some of the smartest people I know.