HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | rixrax's commentslogin

Same. But instead of rPi get a cheap N100 etc. 'real' PC with M.2.

N100s are not cheap anymore. :(

I paid ~$150 for a fanless 4-port router with 16GB of RAM a few years back. Now they are ~$400 and up.


Yes, and that hardware is now half a decade old or so. It's truly shocking.

I think used optiplex / thinkcenters are the current cheap x86 options.

Optiplex/Lenovos are still <150. Lenovos have PCIe ports.

If you want something that works out of the box without too much work. Home Assistant Green is also a great little device. We first ran on a NUC (more powerful than N100), but then we switched to a HA Green. Passively cooled, doesn't draw a lot of power and has been super reliable. And it's well-supported by HA for obvious reasons.

What’s wrong with rpi?

Its a do-everything solution with a do-not-break-compatibility history to its design and a lot of attention driving its price upwards. These are good things as well, so...

Examples:

- SD cards are very convenient for hobbyists "experimenting" with OS variants. They are not great for performance or reliability; a soldered on storage device is common in many other products. - The price is more than it seems - you need a case and a power supply and an SD card. - The case situation is bad. If you want to 'set and forget' you really want a robust case, potted. Many N100's are designed for more abusive environments. - Most use cases don't need the HDMI, Camera, Audio, Ethernet, or all the USB ports. That is board space, purchase cost, and idle power draw that can be reduced or dropped. - It doesn't have some modern connectors, e.g. M2, because there is no space on the board, and the PCIe lanes have gone to the connectors you probably don't use.

Many stick based computers, particularly second hand and older generations, are better for most use cases. These are typically Intel N series; but are increasingly ARM, particularly at the lowest prices.


Absolutely this. For pretty much all use cases I have, for performance, power consumption, robustness, etc. is much better the ESP option or the “big” N100. Rpi is there in the middle. For some playing or prototyping I have some from the ol good times…

It's now crazy expensive for what it is. It's still okay if you prefer low power standby / rare use but other than that probably not so much.

Everything is now crazy expensive, if buying new.

I mean, yeah, but comparing what rpi is and can do it seems more overpriced than some other hardware I was looking for.

But yeah, true.


It all has its place.

RPi hardware is nice because it's a fairly-consistent, known quantity. All copies of a given board have the ~same features and bugs, so an image made for someone else's Pi 4 will run on my own Pi 4. This grants appliance-like utility that we haven't really ever had much of in the x86 PC space.

Pi hardware almost never shows up as cheap as a person might wish for. It's scarce on the used market, even when prices are high. In that space, demand outstrips supply.

And it's never been "cheap". A decade and a half ago when it first showed up, folks were already comparing the price (plus the SD card, and the appropriate power brick, and the USB cable, and the wifi adapter, and some kind of housing) to that of a used PC or laptop, and the Pi seldom came out on top.

But if we're doing new vs new, then it does alright price-wise.

And it's tiny. It's got some hackability built in, with the not-USB camera interface and the not-HDMI display support, and some GPIO that can be useful for some stuff.

It's got places where it's useful. I use them in those places. (And despite that lengthy defense, I run Home Assistant on a cheap SFF Lenovo box that came to me with RAM and an SSD for $50, delivered, in pre-used form)


I personally don’t like raspian at all, and how they change things. They try to be “compatible” with very old HW, while at the same time many SW things I’ve done, are systematically broken in each new release. My 2ct experience.

used workstations are even better such as Dell Wyse or HP Minis

And surely cannot trust credit card details alone. Instead let's do age verification on top of CC just in case.


"Q: Son, what is window manager needed for? A: Running multiple terminals on one display."


tmux


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: