HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | riskable's commentslogin

I'm surprised there isn't a DNS standard or standardized API for link shorteners. You'd think we'd have a SHORTN record type that works like SRV or TXT with a standard format to verify where the short link is supposed to point. For example:

    short.name. 300 IN SHORTN 0 5 /foo https://some.long.name/whatever/foo
...could tell a browser/app/whatever that http(s)://short.name/foo is supposed to point to https://some.long.name/whatever/foo

At the very least, we could have a standard shortener API call that clients could use to verify before allowing the link redirect.


If organizations can't move off Excel, and outages like this continue to be a problem, then competitors that don't use Excel stand to gain an advantage.

Let the dinosaurs go extinct!


Believe it or not, companies are legally required to do due diligence on such things. For example, I work for a huge bank and when there's even the faintest hint of money possibly being funneled through an intermediary to a sanctioned state/person or a company on the Entities List they will absolutely send someone to investigate. Physically, if it is deemed necessary.

A multi-billion dollar deal in Singapore would absolutely require some folks to physically go out there and do some inventory at the very least. It needs to be in the realm of, "We walked the data center and counted how many of our products were installed and we were shown their yet-installed inventory" documentation. "It matches what we sold them." A great big, fancy report. With pictures.

How much would that cost? Basically nothing compared to how much trouble they could get in for not doing that due diligence. Compare how much it would've cost against how much their stock just dropped.


There's still no evidence I've seen that the chips ever left Singapore. I believe the Singapore company rented out compute to some entities in China. What then? You can't expect nvidia to enforce draconian controls on the usage of the GPUs once they've been delivered.

https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/megaspeed-statement-n...

give it time, I think there's plenty of evidence already that Megaspeed was not the company it pretended to be.


> I suspect our $2.5M annual cloud bill could be replaced with a Mac mini.

Ahahaha! I laughed so hard at this because at work I regularly say something like, "why do we have a 32GB VM assigned to this system which runs a microservice that would run just as fast and reliably if we used Raspberry Pi instead?"

The amount of waste in big enterprises is unreal! The reason why we use a 32GB instance is because that's the minimum we're allowed to order for the reliability category of the app!


How very considerate! Steal from the rich, not the poor.

Conversely, don't bother with poor people!

Now we just need proper Robin Hood malware that "levels out the playing field" as it were, by stealing from the rich and moving that money into the poor people's accounts (that have also been hacked).


Bolt this on to a self replicating worm that uses open ollama instances (~10k of them on the internet as of this comment) for distributed free inference, and you’re off to the races. Send discovered crypto to burn addresses where it’s unrecoverable, or skill the agent to know how to buy itself more compute with it.

You’ll have created an autonomous Robin Hood clone army. Fun times.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morris_worm


I'm just imagining some poor person getting a call about 100,000$ that's been transferred to their account without any idea how or why.


Means testing for malware


The problem is that advertising works! I hate that it works!

Marketing and advertising aren't the same thing but I swear both sides of that coin have devolved via some process of carcinization where their claws emerge from the darkness everywhere people gather. Especially places where those claws are inappropriate and unwanted and yet it still works.


I don't think it actually works very well at the rate the big companies use it.

I think for a Mom & Pop trying to build some form of brand recognition in their small community, it gets people informed.

But persuasive convincing, the mind control target that marketers claim to be able to drive? Nah.


Yeah, people in our line of work tend to look down on it and don't understand it because we discover things more manually. But that's not the case with the vast majority of people. Advertising works and it works really, really well.


We do not "discover things more manually", whatever that means. Statistically, the more someone thinks they're not affected by advertising, the more they're actually affected by advertising in reality.


I hear this all the time, but my detailed book-keeping says otherwise.


It works in the same way that the mafia prevents your store from being wrecked.


It works only to a point and only if the product has not degraded/enshittified. Retention is often terrible for bad products/service. Humans are not robots. Most people think about what they are purchasing and no amount of ads can fix it if the product/service is bad.


I actively/mentally block products I see in ads now. For example, when I use Amazon's terrible search feature, I'll make a mental note of which listings are "sponsored" and make sure NOT to buy them. Ever, if possible.

When I see ads for things on YouTube, I automatically assume it's a scam... Because it almost always is!


The YouTube sponsor situation is actually crazy, I think 100% of them have turned out to be either scams or just very overpriced. Even ones that sounded reasonable, like Ground News, and VPNs.


It's why I don't get viewers getting angry with a creator for taking a specific sponsor. YouTube sponsorships are basically an advisory not to buy a product. It's like an anti-advert in a sense. Something appears in a sponsorship, that thing is definitely bad even if we don't know why yet.


yeah my rule of thumb is never buy anything advertised on youtube unless it's independently trustworthy or otherwise notable

like I get ads for Lexus -- I'm in a big city and don't need / want a car, but like Lexus is a real brand, basically Toyota.

Some no-name VPN or idle-game app is an immediate "I will actively avoid this, froever"


What happened with ground news?


Ground News presents you a "balanced" news diet by presenting you with two sides that are implied to be equally valid. Except one of the sides is just (relatively accurate) plain old news and the other side largely consists of institutions who publish a lot of nonsense and paid Ground News to be there, or have ownership in common with Ground News. Their target audience is people who were mostly consuming the first group before (not a single Ground News ad was ever run to an audience aligned with the second group) and the purpose is to make them gradually accept the second group as equals to the first group.

Also it doesn't actually show you the news. It just shows you links to news sites that you need to be separately subscribed to if you want to read them, so in that sense you're just not getting the product you probably thought you were getting (access to balanced news), so it's a double scam.

There's video essays about this on YouTube of course since that's where Ground News was mainly advertised.


The product never purports to show you the news directly, and the reaction of "the other side largely… publish[es] a lot of nonsense" is a) not true and b) why the product exists. For that matter, the dichotomy you have in mind is not even valid in the first place.

If what you say about the audience composition and the general background situation were at all true, it would be impossible for them to find sponsors, because it would require YouTubers who depend on appealing to a partisan audience to deliberately seek to betray them. And if what you say about the product were at all true, it would again be impossible for them to find sponsors, because none of the YouTubers would be willing to endorse the product.

If anything, the problem with Ground News is that they buy into the same categorization scheme of the news that you do, perhaps with a different bias but the same clustering and same false impression of a single-dimension spectrum.


The product ads definitely purport to show you news.

You deliberately misunderstand the point about advertising audiences, that is not how advertising audiences work, at all. The point about influencers rejecting shady sponsors is also false, and circular. All evidence suggests they mostly accept sponsors who offer money.

If Ground News "bought into the same categorisation that I do" there would be literally no reason for it to exist. It exists to change the categorisation you buy into.


What could possibly go wrong with a (I think) VC funded news aggregator that becomes your authority on what "Right" vs "Left" thought is and how to interpret a bunch of news without actually reading any of it?

Where could that possibly end up causing problems?


it doesn't give you anything, just links you to paywalled articles

there is the illusion of "balanced" or more in the know but they are no more balanced than any other curator, and in many cases try really, really hard to present a mixed view of something that is otherwise inexcusable.


> When I see ads for things on YouTube, I automatically assume it's a scam... Because it almost always is!

Their reporting system is useless, too. Funny thing, though, sometimes Gmail spam-filters legitimate automated emails from YouTube.


We really need more terms for AI-assisted writing. There's degrees to everything and writing is one of those things where there's LOADS of gray areas. Did you use AI for research? What about generating random names for characters/places? Did you use it to check your grammar (why do people even care about this? They do!)?

Anything touched by AI is starting to become "the fruit of the poisonous tree" for a lot of people and it's getting ridiculous. I've chatted with people who will refuse to read a story because they think the cover art was generated by AI (even though they don't really know; they're just guessing). "It's AI slop."

One of the listed stories was almost disqualified for that very same reason (AI cover art). Another was controversial because the author used AI to generate a random name for a disease.

If we had better terms for the levels of AI involvement, maybe people would get a little less worked up about it?


There are like 5 gazillion books to read, even without AI. As a reader to curate your limited time you cling to every indicator of quality you can get.

And authors not bothering to write their own books or publishers not caring enough to get someone to design a good cover (which you would think would really be in their own interest...) is a good sign that the work is of low quality and that I'd be better served to just read something else


The value is going to show up when AI can know you and hammer out a banger just for you so you don't have to pick one of 5 gazilion.


Fiction requires charting a path through the infinitely large space of what is possible. I think AI can be very helpful assistant when plotting, figuring out how you lead characters naturally, as the storyteller, to where you want to get them through manipulation of circumstance.

One is limited as a writer because of the hard problem of bringing to attention possibilities you haven't considered yet (ie writer's block). AI can be very helpful as a search tool for the "possibility space" even if its judgment and voice are mediocre.


To be honest I doubt it. As far as I am concerned at least, it's a bit like the distinction between a shit sandwich and a sandwich that uses shit as a condiment.

In the terms of the fruit of the poisonous tree, the tree is not AI or what it touches, it is an author who chooses to use AI in the process of writing. The fruit of that tree is simply not one I care to eat.


Thanks for explaining your opinion with profane metaphors and nothing else. How can you tell if an author used AI to research a topic or not. Why is this bad?


There's no "good" or "bad" about it. Everyone is just wading through mountains of slop (man-made or ai made) and need a way to filter what's actually worth investing time and attention to. Effort, or percieved effort at least, is a good enough measure for most people. If 99% of ai generated "art" is low-effort garbage, why would people give the benefit of the doubt to the other 1%? What would they gain from it?


99% of output from cameras is unmitigated low-effort garbage, yet people still hang 1% of photographs in art museums and on their walls.


There's an obsession here with replying with half baked analogies that I really don't see the point of. Is this an attempt at a thought-terminating-cliché? 1. People mostly hang their own photos. 2. People mostly go to museums because they expect a certain level of quality (i.e. they're offloading the curation to... curators) 3. Photography is it's own medium, generative ai is a "tool". Apple to oranges comparison.

There's nothing about the analogy that works, what is your point here?


> Is this an attempt at a thought-terminating-cliché?

No it’s a counter example. Calling a point half baked is closer to a thought terminating cliche.

> 1. People mostly hang their own photos.

So then that’s an answer to the question: they would give 1% of ai art the benefit of the doubt despite 99% being trash if they made it themselves.

Also I don’t accept the premise unless we are talking about family photos. Otherwise I’ve never been in a house where they’ve hanged their own photography on the wall despite being in many houses with photography on the wall.

> People mostly go to museums because they expect a certain level of quality (i.e. they're offloading the curation to... curators)

Says nothing about whether or not ai could be curated. Moreover people go to museums to see many things, including to be surprised, informed, disgusted, or to just see things they’ve never seen before.

Also curators curate on other factors than quality, or we might say “quality” doesn’t always mean the art satisfies conventional or critical tastes. No reason ai art can’t fall into that category.

> Photography is it's own medium, generative ai is a "tool".

I don’t see why ai can’t be a medium, can you explain why the output of a camera is a medium but the output of ai is a tool?


Thanks for explaining the another person's opinion using your own, entirely-different, opinion. "Shit sandwich" usually implies "bad".

> Everyone is just wading through mountains of slop

I'm not. What am I doing wrong? Should I be on TikTok more? LinkedIn?


> Thanks for explaining the another person's opinion using your own, entirely-different, opinion.

Not that different, just formulated in a tamer way.

> I'm not. What am I doing wrong? Should I be on TikTok more? LinkedIn?

You're not? You don't have to wade through mountains of grifters and "hot-takes" in your social media of choice? Or through a hundred garbage sites gaming SEO every time you need to search for something online? Or through the never ending catalogue of low effort drama in streaming sites?

If so I'm sure you realize yours is not the average experience on the internet.


> need a way to filter what's actually worth investing time and attention to

nothing on social media is worth investing time and attention to. including hacker news, yet here i am so i guess my experience is not that different from the average experience, it's just not because of ai

> social media of choice

tiktok, x, linkedin, etc. have been garbage as long as they have existed. if ai slop made tiktok worse i would welcome that as a good thing for society.

> search for something online

just search on claude. the water is warm here on the dark side

> low effort drama in streaming sites

these are front and center because people like them. they have filters for acclaimed movies that aren't front and center because people don't want to watch There Will Be Blood on a random Tuesday after work. this seems like a reach


yes, you seem like someone I want to spend time talking to


In PRs at work (software engineering) we distinguish between drafting, editing, review, and straight generation.

In creative writing I think it's less about the tool(s) and more about the investment. Reading takes time and attention. If an author offloads the actual composition (the deliberate thought, structure, and prose) to an LLM then they've reduced their effort to as close to zero as they can while still asking for the reader's full attention.

There is nothing unreasonable about identifying this as a bullshit proposition.


Suppose you are an author and you have some plot hole you're trying to work through. You say to llm, I'm thinking maybe we can have this event X happen to explain why some character needs Y. Can you research X more and tell me if this a plausible way to handle this in the story? And the llm says, that almost works but you didn't consider this, so it needs addendum Z. Then who composed the structure?


The author did.

Bouncing an idea off an LLM, or an editor, or a friend, to check for plausibility isn't composition. It's no different than rubber ducking. The human still did the work.

Generating ideas or checking edge cases isn't the threshold. The threshold is delegation of the craft itself. Who is actually wrestling the thoughts into language, making the hard calls and owning the consequences of the narrative? If the human is still selecting, structuring, and writing the prose then the investment is real. If they hit a button and let the model generate the chapters resolving X, Y, and Z, they abdicated.


So, so many people would disagree with you. "Bouncing an idea off an LLM" is fruit of the poisonous tree in a lot of people's eyes because you involved an LLM at all.

I see this stance every day on writing Discords. Just mentioning that you used an LLM for anything (even unrelated to the story you're working on) can get you banned.


> If we had better terms for the levels of AI involvement, maybe people would get a little less worked up about it?

I feel like the people getting worked up about it are the ones collapsing everything into a single term they can blanket apply everywhere.


A term is all you need?

> I've chatted with people who will refuse to read a story because they think the cover art was generated by AI (even though they don't really know; they're just guessing). "It's AI slop."

There is beyond enough literature on offer for me to read in my lifetime. I'm not certain what this new age of expression will bring us, but the genie is out of the bottle. It is obvious to me that viewing llm output is distinct from the fusion I am part of traditionally when reading, even in the case of a shoddy translator. So for me personally, I will be attempting to continue reading in the same spirit traditionally. Anything contemporary I am reading, I will more fittingly treat as introspection or a window for dialect.

“Today’s old world won’t get in our way,” said the machine, enigmatically. “It even came to our aid. History has ceased its flow; no need to refer to it any longer."


>If we had better terms for the levels of AI involvement, maybe people would get a little less worked up about it?

I think this suggestions lacks an appreciation for why people get worked up about it.

Anybody willing to actually apply some nuance to all of this aren't these people. If you're willing to write off an entire book because you suspect AI may have been involved in its creation, then you're likely just grandstanding. That's not even to say it isn't a valid "strategy" for "dealing" with AI, but the approach is to just hardline the issue to a degree that there's explicitly no room for nuance. This strategy suggests there's a way for people to suppress AI basically back to the point of nonexistence, and it will take an absolute position that any AI is bad.

The people who are willing to apply some nuance will eventually have to learn that being a consumer almost requires you to ignore how the sausage is being made. If you get more value from something than it costs, then it is ultimately a worthwhile product to consume. It doesn't matter if it was made by a team of passionate humans who have never even touched a computer or if it was spit out by an AI seconds before you consumed it (or anything in-between, of course). This is the way it worked before AI, when most people didn't care to acknowledge that they were just consuming some engineered slop that lacked any semblance of a human connection, and this is the way it will work "after" AI.

At this point, the only reason this is still a factor is because there are still tells which remind consumers of this greater context which is uncomfortable (thanks, in part, to the first group of people). But at some point, it simply won't be a significant factor and people will assume their products were created with at least some AI input the same way people are generally fine with assuming their products are being manufactured with slave labor, cause global warming, make them dumb, etc.


> We really need more terms for AI-assisted writing.

I actually think we need less discernment. All AI work is slop, but an enormous amount of human-written work is also slop. I think we need to come to an understanding that we're filling our lives with repetitive, derivative garbage that mostly shouldn't exist. AI is adding to the problem, not causing the problem.

We started deleting all of the good stuff on the internet and replacing it with crap long before LLMs were viable. Too many books are published every year. The biggest sellers are sort of ideal, overengineered, perfect slop that will just get over the bar of acceptability for the widest audience (and be enthusiastically praised by people in the industry whose ideal is perfect, bestselling slop), everybody else sells zilch, if they can find a publisher. Consolidation (media deregulation and the end of antitrust) has forced everybody to shoot for that widest audience, or cease to exist entirely. People are trained to slop. Slop is a sign of maturity and understanding adult responsibilities. Slop art, slop opinions, slop design, slop world.

We don't appreciate the good things (or can't even find them), let them be crowded out by slop, and we lose some of them forever every day. AI is an industrial level advance in this process, but it's still human hands letting it loose. Their motives are mortgages, healthcare, not being fired at will, avoiding social rejection, feeding your kids that maybe you'll one day be able to afford to have. You feed that into the market in return for the least amount of security the surveys and equations say that they can possibly give you, and the equity of pigs, born pigs, just rises like a hockey stick. Making slop for the pigs.

I'm sure you can do good things when assisted with AI, or you can trick AI into doing things that are great by themselves. But you've always been able to collage things out of slop, or pick a piece of slop and recontextualize it into something that implies a particular conversation with the context. But denying it's slop is just denial.

Nothing on this list looks appealing outside of the "AI Was Allowed From The Start" section; it all looks like annoying literary pandering. If you need AI to come up with names and change your grammar, you're not a writer who in concerned about writing imo, but about creating product.

I heard once that Peter Straub, a horror writer from the 80s, started his career in that way. He looked at all the bestsellers, found commonalities, such as the types of main characters, the types of conflicts, the genres that were selling (horror was big), the lengths of books, the lengths of chapters, the types of sentences, adjectives, plot arcs and scene descriptions, etc., and engineered a career. That's artistic and inspiring for me, but the art isn't on the paper, it's in the process. A.E. Van Vogt did the same thing in the 50s iirc, and he inspired Philip K. Dick who could slop nonstop without sleeping for days in a Methadrine haze by mixing his own divine inspirations and paranoid hallucinations with Van Vogt's cynical commercial nearly-incompetent dreamlike incoherence. If you use AI to express things that you calculate might be lucrative to feel, you're part of a long slop tradition, maybe you should be proud.

Or maybe you should just render unto the slop machines what now belongs to the slop machines, and work on something else. The slop market is full.


> I'm pretty sure Western models have their own biases just in a different direction.

This statement warrants testing.

If we don't see an equivalent study out in a few days saying that this is true, it's clearly false. The methodology of the study was clear and easy to replicate (in short order, though you'll need the hardware/money for tokens). No reason why other groups shouldn't be performing the same exact tests with Western models (open weights or not).


Are you going to perform the work? If not, why do you expect someone else will?


Because these are ads. He may not have a company marketing products in this space, but others do.


Exactly. I don't have the power to replicate the testing but this is the type of thing that easily makes the news!

If you have the power to do so, why wouldn't you perform your own testing right now and release the results? It's a marketing/status gold mine.

If you find that western models don't have the described anti-china bias, then maybe you won't publish anything since it's not as interesting—that would be evidence there's no conspiracy.

Hence my conclusion that if we don't hear anything soon, the anti-china accusation is false.


If we don't see an equivalent study out in a few days saying that this is true, it's clearly false.

Yeah, that's not how evidence works, bud.


It's a bad smell for China if "westernization" makes code more secure.

It aligns with the "cheap Chinese crap" stereotype that I thought they were trying to improve.

To summarize my take: Come on, guys! Really‽


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: