HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | reenorap's commentslogin

No one anticipated that OpenAI would put in an order for 40% of the global supply of memory in 2025. And then it became a mad dash for everyone and that’s why we are where we are today.

I really doubt that it was a surprise. The big cloud providers talk to suppliers (and potential suppliers) frequently to telegraph future demand, both the amount of parts and specs.

OAI would be doing the same.


No it was a huge surprise. I bought a 512 GB Mac Studio for $9k in April 2025 which was market. Even as recently as Jan 2026 I bought a 5070Ti for $750, the retail price. Now it’s $1500. No one anticipated the effects.

I meant it was not a surprise to the ram manufacturers when demand shot up. Customers did not show up with massive orders out of nowhere.


AMD is 3x slower than Nvidia isn’t it?

Slower in what specifically? It wouldn't surprise me if the card is up to 3x slower (it has roughly 3x less bandwidth), but do note that we are comparing a 2.3k€ card vs a +9k€ card here (plus on top of that the power usage on the RTX 5090 can be up to 2x under load).

The RX 7900 XTX has slightly higher bandwidth at almost 1kGBps compared to AI PROs almost 650GBps but has only 24GB instead of 32GB, though I can't find the card on sale anywhere rn.

In the end I see it mostly as a "is the massive jump in price worth it, or do you risk it and maybe get multiple AI 9700s instead and deal with ROCm instead". I can't tell how good ROCm has gotten in regards to training and such, but for inference Vulkan on my 9070 XT is pretty solid.


People are acting like vendors extending financing to their customers is somehow irregular or illegal.

It’s not. It happens ALL THE TIME. This isn’t “circular financing” which is a great meme term but is not factual.


Vendor financing is not illegal but in this case it may have created significant non-recurring revenue. (And maybe amplified scarcity and artificially high chip prices in the industry at large.)

And the part that sounds shady to people is that part of Nvidia’s recorded cash flow is its own cash coming back around.

Edit: In typical vendor financing it’s a loan that has to be repaid on a schedule but in Nvidia’s case it’s equity. And btw vendor financing was always kind of shady but maybe the “loan that has to be repaid” type is more palatable when recording own’s cash on the books as cash flow.


That's what these allegations of circular financing are about? Extending credit? Lmao

Is this Planet X that they have been talking about for a while now?

No, all dwarf planets are too small to affect orbits the way that hypothetical planet is supposed to do.

Planet Nine is the new Planet X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet_Nine

Glad that artist's impression was there so I could get a good idea of what Planet 9 may or may not look like.

This artist’s impression is optimized for plausible deniability.

The proposed Planet X would be something the size of Uranus or Neptune. This is 1000km across, +/-50%.

there are a few different “Planet X”s theorized

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planets_beyond_Neptune


Yeah but Dwarkesh is completely wrong and the fact he couldn't see this made me think differently about him.

Money is like oxygen. If you deny oxygen/money to the Chinese chip market, they can't grow as fast. By supplying China with chips, all the money will go back to the US and not enough money will go to Chinese chip manufacturers to help them advance the way Nvidia can.

This is what Jensen was saying and he is 100% correct here. The chip ban to China will really help them catch up because the money will recirculate since they have no choice but to buy Chinese chips, and in the end it will make them much stronger.


I'm doubtful of this hypothesis. Maybe for a few years, sure. But China has proven time and again that they do not need foreign supply constraints to incentivize the growth of their own competing domestic industry.

The fundamental contradiction of the AI maximalists like Huang is claiming that AI does not need regulated while simultaneously supporting chip exports to China. The supporting claim for the former is that we need to compete on AI with China and move as fast as possible and every day matters, while the latter implies that slowing down their compute is inconsequential.


You shouldn’t be doubtful. China executes the exact same strategy with manufactured goods exported to the US.

Exporting their extremely cheap and relatively good quality products to the US destroys any incentive to invest in domestic manufacturing and production.

If the Chinese were to stop exporting those goods to us, there would be massive incentives to make those products domestically. Given a few years we would be producing everything we previously bought from China after a painful adjustment period.

The incentive effects are identical for chip producers in China. Give it a few years and they’ll be at parity with any western producer.

“Show me the incentive and I’ll show you the outcome.” -Charlie Munger


If this was the case, the Chinese government would have placed import restrictions on US chip manufacturers. Currently Chinese AI companies are constrained on compute. This is why they go to such great lengths to use Singaporean straw purchasers of NVIDIA cards. Merely having strong market incentives to succeed is not enough. Sustained, time-consuming R&D and technology sharing is necessary to catch up to competitors.

If this principle were true, then autarchies like North Korea would be the most advantaged since they never have to worry about international competition in their domestic market.

Your confidence is not backed by any data or observation, it's just an unfounded inference.



> If this was the case, the Chinese government would have placed import restrictions on US chip manufacturers.

There are. A lot of Nvidia chips are still stuck in Hong Kong.

What the government does is not always what corporations follow.


> the Chinese government would have placed import restrictions on US chip manufacturers.

OT but one thing I didn't realize until reading this comment:

Those used CMP 170HX 8GB were advertised in front of crypto server rigs. Those were probably spread across South Asian scam malls(shopping mall buildings built in literal sovereignty contested areas of non-China/Japan/Korea/Russia non-India non-African non-Muslim Asia, under guises of Chinese tourist destinations, that are literally rented out to local Chinese-speaking gangs engaging in all sorts of gang crimes from tech support scams to human and organ trafficking, straight out of the fictitious Chiba in Neuromancer), and they would happily sell or rent compute to Chinese AI firms if only those were more valuable than 8GB VRAM they have, which they all had all along.

GPU export to China must have become significantly less meaningful since the 170HX unlock became a thing. That alone must have provided petaflops of unsanctioned untraced junks for parts priced compute to Chinese AI startups.


> If this was the case, the Chinese government would have placed import restrictions

"About 600,000 of Nvidia's advanced artificial intelligence chips are stored in Hong Kong awaiting shipment to mainland China, two people familiar with the matter said, as Beijing withholds approval for large-scale imports despite demand from tech firms" [1].

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/china/nvidia-chips-pile-up-hon...


> "If this was the case, the Chinese government would have placed import restrictions on US chip manufacturers."

I do not know full details, but China did exactly that. There were articles about limiting Nvidia chip imports more than a year ago. It really highlighted the absurdity of the export ban.

To my non-expert knowledge, the reasoning behind the export ban has never been explained beyond a vague assertion that China would do some sort of evil with AI if they have bigger GPUs than some arbitrary number of transistors, and also some silliness where paying a 15% tax made some of the GPUs safe to export. It has been pretty great for Huawei.


IMO that ignores the decades of investment the Chinese government has made in its semiconductor industry. It’s literally been written into their five year plans at the highest level with tons of government pressure to buy domestic when possible across industries. With the biggest captive consumer market on the planet, there is no universe in which China doesn’t get its own cutting edge chip industry. They have been determined to do it since at least the 90s and have invested hundreds of billions in a concerted effort to pull it off.

Bingo! This guy gets it.

The best way of hampering China technologically has always been about keeping them completely dependent on foreign chip supply chain, e.g. ASML, TSMC, NVDA, ARM, AVGO, INTC, etc.

If you simply ban them from getting any western chips or chip tech you simply light a viciously hot fire underneath them to develop their own TSMC equivalent and their own chip designers, and we are now seeing them catching up rapidly. In fact, they are pretty close to catching up now, basically within one or two years...


Supposedly, one of those half-billion-dollar ASML EUV machines has found its way to China somehow.

The best reason to NOT ban exports is that it really doesn't work against a peer state, and China is close enough now to count. Given the significant economic trouble in the PRC (youth unemployment, unwinding the property bubble, overproduction of EVs) the US could definitely have played this better instead of creating a vibrant full-stack domestic AI sector in China.


How would they obtain one? These kinds of industrial machines come in pieces and need to be assembled, commissioned and maintained by OEM personnel. The only thing I can think of is ASML sold a machine to a compromised company who secretly shipped it to China without ASML knowing.

He is probably referring to this : https://www.reuters.com/world/china/how-china-built-its-manh...

They hired old asml employees.


Still, it’s not like an off the shelf product with an 2 pager quick installation and first steps manual. Training, and maintenance, and repairs, and configuration,… I doubt you can simply ask your friendly neighbourhood LLM

> vibrant full-stack domestic AI sector in China

This has crashed, check the markets.


This would work in a fully capitalist economy where supplying them with chips would remove funding/investment from the local alternatives. This is not China. China has been and will continue to pour billions upon billions of dollars into their native industry because they too believe that having their own chips is important, so they will take all the cutting edge chips they can get and they will continue to develop their own at the exact same rate.

They do not need a ban to light a fire under them. The fire is already lit and burning and nothing the west can do will even slightly dampen it.

You yourself claim they are within a couple of years. If that's the case you think they will stop developing if we sell them chips? That's laughable.


You say this, but there is already massive scarcity in the domestic market for any 16GB+ GPU. We can't get enough and it's bottle-necking scale out. Even if Nvidia diverted their entire supply to China there would still be a global shortage and an economic case for Chinese companies to build chips.

One can have good argumenta against a specific law (personally I am very much pro free trade), but as long as the law exist, breaking it comes with consequences.

This might make sense in a pure free market. But as a state planned economy, regardless of export bans, China is going to continue to heavily invest in cloning EUV.

Both China’s geopolitical situation and technological history point towards them cutting any reliance on a foreign tech stack as soon as they can.

As I see it, giving them chips just means they have less of a gap to close when their own EUV fabs come online, it can’t have any delaying effect on their plans.


Giving them chips now will no longer change anything because it is too late. Now they know that they must not depend on US-controlled imports.

Before the US "sanctions", China did not make any serious efforts to develop EUV lithography, because the government did not believe that this is a priority.

After US blackmailed everybody, including TSMC and ASML, to stop providing products and services to China, the Chinese government understood the importance of being able to make up-to-date integrated circuits, so they started providing incentives for all companies willing to work in this direction.

The result is that now China claims to have working prototypes for EUV lithography and they estimate that they will begin to use EUV lithography in mass production some time between 2030 and 2032, which is a very plausible estimate.


> Before the US "sanctions", China did not make any serious efforts to develop EUV lithography, because the government did not believe that this is a priority

Possibly true, but it’s hard to disentangle this issue specifically from the broader trade war / decoupling started in the Trump I admin. Which itself predated AI as a major geopolitical issue.

I think that China was inevitably going to work their way up the stack to DUV / EUV. I agree as you say it’s plausible that the trade war accelerated their prioritization here.


Yeah, Jensen sees the whole hw/sw ecosystem as a package. It isn't just chip n+1 on process n-1.

Keeping adversaries X-behind discourages adversaries from developing a new ecosystem since X-behind is better than building new. If an adversary with tremendous resources must recreate the ecosystem, it will be adopted by US+global companies since it will be lower margin.


The Chinese chip market is exactly like any other market in any other country, except it's run by the largest and arguably most successful autocratic organization in the world, one which views reducing reliance on external suppliers who can turn the taps on and off at will/whim, to be of existential importance. I mean, aside from them being autocratic despots and control freaks, I can't even blame them. Your main adversary's president (and we all know how high-quality they always are) can wake up any day and decide you don't get to buy a critical part of the AI tech stack, good luck with all your future endeavours!

Yeah, no. No one in Beijing will let Nvidia or the White House have that kind of power in the long run because the free market knows best and golly gee where will we get the money and whatnot. They will buy whatever they can to bridge the gap to a time when they own their own tap.

It's not a completely dissimilar argument to selling them the nukes or F-35s because "it will deny oxygen/money to the Chinese nukes and fighter jets market".


I'm not sure if this is true or false, but as an observation: this is the exact opposite reasoning people use to criticize isolationism and market protection.

You are essentially arguing that CEOs can violate US laws if it makes them personally richer. That is litterally the crime.

Your argument is that it's actually good to break the law?

Some people argue that it is indeed a moral responsibility to break an unjust law.

Cue the "What did it cost" Thanos meme

No one will contribute because AI will slurp it up and serve it for free immediately.

Well, not no one. My blog is intended to be consumed by AI and I try not to robots.txt them out of it except to help them succeed in browsing it.

I don’t mind if they load in information about the experience of IVF or pregnancy and everything else that I’ve written down. To contribute into the intelligences grown out of our collective written experience seems kind of cool to me.


I'm a shareholder, and the fact that both the US government and Nvidia itself is going to investigate him is very, very bad. So yes, I care about it a lot because I'm probably going to lose a lot of money tomorrow!

This US Government investigating Jensen Huang will be an exercise in cotton balls and kid gloves.

Trump himself relaxed laws on chip exports to China.

P.S. If you have any other liquidity available, maybe 'buy the dip'?


It's not going to ruin his life. At worst he will lose $100 bil and maybe if it's really bad, he will get kicked out of Nvidia. He will still have $100 bil and can do whatever he wants at that point.

If he loses his family over it, it will ruin his life. There’s more to life than money. I hope for your sake that you don’t really believe this morally bankrupt concept.

The man was cheating on his wife. He already wasn’t thinking of his family.

I think it's common enough for people to have regrets after the fact. Not all do, but enough that you can't rule it out entirely.

Men are known to think with their penises every now and then. His wife knows that too. It's cheating, but cheating is often repaired.

Allegedly he was assaulted by a spy and wasn't able to deflect that assault. Who knows what techniques they use, wouldn't be surprised if they can sprinkle something in a drink that switches off half the frontal cortex.

Is there any example of this specific thing happening before?

Dopamine agonist are known to ruin impulse control: pramipexole, ropinirole, rotigotine.

That’s just conspiracy talk. It’s called honeypots for a reason. It requires willingness.

And there is more to life than family too, there is any amount of people who lived great lives without any family.

If the woman involved turns out to really be a Chinese spy, then it will definitely ruin his life.

AI and chips are, for better or worse, considered a national security matter.


Being a “Chinese spy” has very little to do with reality, much like being a terrorist. It’s a matter of what the State Department decides.

He is the the tech CEO most aligned with the current government’s optimism towards the AI build out and also its key orchestrator. What are the odds he will be held to any real punishment ?

I would not bet on punishment that is meaningful unless he screwed over other big capitalists. That's the one law you cannot break.

Being a state of national security, yes.

Spy is rather easy to define though, and it hardly depends on what the State Department decides (although of course, they can call anybody a spy, for political or other reasons, I agree on that).


I don't know why this is being downvoted. The federal government has never really prevented a terrorist attack that they themselves have not recruited. It is entrapment, and it is legal in most cases. I know it sounds like a conspiracy theory, but even mainstream media has covered this: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/16/fbi-entrapment...

It is perfectly reasonable to suspect similar claims of catching "spies".


Your article doesn't support your claim that the 'federal government has never really prevented a terrorist attack'. And a lot of that was highly motivated reporting itself by people like Glenn Greenwald who was basically denying that things like ISIS were real threats at all in 2014 and then went full victim blaming for things like Charlie Hebdo the year after (it was harder after the Bataclan).

Will you next claim that the police have never really prevented a murder?


I gave a link as a reference of how the Federal government operates. I did not think that I needed a whole bibliography to prove something that is very easily verifiable.

Not only that you think the reporting is not reliable because of the reporter without pointing out what is wrong with the actual report.

But I'll humor you.

- Here is the judge calling the US government the co-conspirator in the same case: https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2023/07/27/judge-quest...

- The Gretchen Whitmer kidnapping plot:

- https://www.rawstory.com/plot-to-kidnap-michigan-governor/

- https://reason.com/2022/04/08/gretchen-whitmer-kidnapping-pl...

- The liberty city seven: https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna22249838

- The cleveland bomb plot: https://truthout.org/articles/cleveland-anarchist-bomb-plot-...

- Sami Osmakac: https://archive.is/NINN0

---

These are all the cases that had some investigative reporter poking, or the jury/judge seeing through the bullshit. Here is initial reporting on recent cases. The "Iranian Agent" sent to "Assassinate Donald Trump"(emphasis mine):

>Asif Merchant traveled to New York in June for the purpose of meeting with men he thought he was recruiting to carry out the killings, even paying a $5,000 advance to two would-be assassins who were actually undercover law enforcement officers, federal officials said

https://www.ksat.com/news/politics/2024/08/06/pakistani-man-...

The woman arrested for "plotting to bomb the NY state capital":

>According to the criminal complaint, an FBI confidential source drove Bowie to the Home Depot in Rensselaer and gave her $200 to buy bomb parts. It’s not clear if they told her what items to buy.

https://cbs6albany.com/news/local/feds-say-capital-bombing-t...

---

This is not some fringe idea even here on HN. Here is a clear fed trying incite people to commit violence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49629430

This common in most internet forums. It is called fedposting: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fedpost

I hope all of these sources are of sound character by your standards. Now I would ask you; can you give me an example of the FBI catching a terrorist that:

a) They did not recruit, or b) Did not provide materials, or c) did not provide the target

AS for the police in the US, they are indeed very bad at preventing crime. Though that is due to multiple reasons, mostly policy related, rather than institutional malfeasance like the FBI.


> It's not going to ruin his life.

It might if he loves his wife.


Sometimes, it's the humiliation that comes from the public finding out and putting a spotlight on it that is the kicker; not the random side piece(s) (ex: Bill & Melinda Gates).

I agree, though.

___

edit: Funny enough, there's a House of Cards scene that goes over this exact scenario. Francis is sleeping with Zoe the reporter (they're both using each other for the perks/their own agendas). When Claire finds out, her response is something like "you know you must not embarrass me (publicly) with this", which Francis already knew because he would never do that to Claire... she doesn't say those exact words, but that was the vibe.


> "The reporter? ... What does she offer us?"

Exactly

If he loved his wife he wouldn't have cheated on her, and then humiliated her and his children in front of the entire world.

Humans are complex creatures. Plenty of men and women who have loving families and genuinely love their spouses cheat on them and destroy their lives/families. It just takes a moment of weakness. Stay vigilant.

Love and sexual attraction is totally different thing. As long as you get married Male usually lose interest and sexual attraction on female and want to try new things. That happens to me too and its like both biological and mental.

It's not really a moment when the moment is stretched over months and years, but yes we are all human and all make mistakes. That does not absolve us of the consequences.

A "moment of weakness" leads to a one-night stand, not to however long a fling needs to be to be dubbed an "extramarital affair."

Way to minimize cheating. Describing it as a “moment of weakness” makes it sounds like it’s a minute of lapse of judgement, meanwhile we’re talking about pre-mediated, long-term cheating.

I have zero sympathy for this guy, generally speaking. But this is one of those very few things where what you have said is the socially "correct" thing, and actually is probably healthy to believe, but is factually wrong.

Lamentably, people don't have cartoon emotions. Life would be so much easier if they did.


That is not an automatic fact. Humans are very emotionally complex creatures. And Jensen didn't call his secretary and say "can you pencil in 'humiliating my wife and kids around 4PM'? You can? Great, thanks".

He has full agency over his actions, so yes, it's an automatic fact. He knew what he was doing and he knew what the effects would be on his wife. He knew what would happen when this came out. If you're saying he DIDN'T know what would happen, then you're saying he's extremely stupid. I haven't seen any evidence that he is even a little bit stupid.

Are you saying this was an accident and he didn't have control over himself?

If he doesn't have control over himself and he isn't accountable for his actions, then how does that factor into him being the CEO of the most important globally strategic company in the world? Are you saying that he is capable of making actions that he isn't in full control over? Does Nvidia need to have a CEO that doesn't accidentally make mistakes like potentially giving secret information to Chinese spies?


This seems like an emotionally compromised perspective (which is very, very normal, and I am not insulting you).

It is, of course, not an automatic fact. The context here is emotions, so it makes no sense to point only to agency as proof of an emotional "fact". Such a thing doesn't even exist.


People, especially men, are not robots.

> especially men

meaning that women are more likely to be robots? wasn't aware of this, gotta try doing turing tests on women around me.


This is not complicated if you define “love” as “wouldn’t cheat”. Which plenty of people do.

Well, yes, nothing is complicated if one already agrees with their audience.

Oh, with this “open letter” he literally did just that.

$100 bil? You say that like there aren't trillionaires going around in their "flying" cars... /s

Not the same as Uber all. Lots of employees got fucked because at lockup expiration it was much lower than the ipo price (at which they were taxed at).

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: