HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | reducesuffering's commentslogin


> the 0.1% hold all the wealth and AI power

Is the equivalent of ants trying to outsmart Google that wants to build a datacenter on their land. ASI will unfathomably outsmart the wealthy and intelligent humans like Stockfish 13 does Magnus Carlsen


This is jumping the real world concerns into the realm of science fiction. How about we engage with the premise that before the AGI god comes into being and annoints the Rationalists as it's chosen people, there will be people who will try and use this to enrich themselves and immiserate others.

Every year we are making the "science fiction" of the previous year come true. The trajectory has been clear, the insider info from lab employees themselves are that the scaling laws continue unabated. The coding of the last 40 years is gone in a flash. Unanswered math problems are being solved every week and the top mathematicians of the world see crisis. The only "science fiction" is hyperbole about anointing rationalists, it's a strawman no one holds, X-risk concern is about disregarding everyone.

"there will be people who will try and use this to enrich themselves and immiserate others."

This is already happening from Big Tech and VC's, all the big money. You should try listening to the people that have shirked enormous fortunes in order to tell the truth about things. Some examples:

https://x.com/hilbertspaess/status/2097476196791709843?lang=...

https://fortune.com/2026/09/26/geoffrey-hinton-godfather-of-...

https://yoshuabengio.org/en/blog/faq-catastrophic-ai-risks

https://ai-2027.com/


Sarcastically quipping that the AGI god would anoint the Rationalists as it's chosen people is like saying that the global warming god is going to come along and anoint the Climatologists as its chosen people. It's like saying Al Gore is a reptile and is excited for the universally hot, humid future.

Everybody who thinks they're "the chosen people" predicts the end of the world is coming, but not everybody who predicts the end of the world is coming thinks they're "the chosen people". Maybe the end of the world is coming and it's Just Bad.


Alex Karp has always thought of himself as progressive. He's liberal on all the social issues and moderate on economic, practically like establishment Dems that voted for the Patriot Act.

He is liberal on a few social issues but he is ideologically opposed to liberalism. He cannot be progressive unless you're on of those people who think progressive is progressing towards an authoritarian "utopia"

Alex Karp knows more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet.

Absurdly unverifiable

Aligned at least as to not treating humanity as a colony of ants to be disregarded when harvesting resources for its own goals.

Absolutely not. Just look at the fiasco when it came to Bun's rust migration. So many threads about how it was a marketing stunt, how it will never work, how when it's working it's still not on main, when it was on main how it took a whole couple months and X $. And now that the articles about it's completion have come, practically radio silence and no admission of being completely repeatedly wrong. HN was bad, lobste.rs was awful. That saga showed how inaccurate and motivated reasoning both of these forums are.

No, Jensen has admitted in a memo to employees he had an affair.

[flagged]

Cheating per se is not a problem other than showing a concerning lack of judgement. A strong desire to keep an affair secret is more dangerous.

Also imagine an intelligence agency is designing cover for someone to seduce YOU.

It is not just having an affair with some random person and using poor judgement. It is a person what was crafted with you as a target. The whole thing is weaponized.

I have never cheated in a relationship and it is not something I would ever consider. It is easy to say this though knowing I am not going to be the target of an intelligence agency honey pot.


I wouldn't expect his wife to excuse the infidelity just because the mistress was intentionally trying to seduce him. As an Nvidia investor, I don't excuse him for lying about it and opening himself up to blackmail even though I can understand how it came about.

> A strong desire to keep an affair secret is more dangerous.

I'm no expert on having affairs, but isn't secrecy key to the whole thing? At least secrecy from the spouse.

If you have no strong desire for secrecy, then is it even an affair at that point? Either the spouse tacitly supports the extramarital fornication, or the relationship is already in tatters.


I am not a puritan, so that's not the angle of concern for me at all.

I believe the actual larger concern here is "in case Jensen didn't want this to become public (whether it was due to the divorce potential or whatever other reason; that's not relevant), what lengths would he be willing to go to keep it under wraps?".

If it gets confirmed that Jensen simply had an affair (without a "shared/did things he wasn't supposed to share/do" component), then it is a nothingburger (for anyone except him and his family).

But until we have that confirmed, the US government is concerned about what critical info he might have shared/done to avoid being blackmailed by an agent acting on behalf of PRC.


This could be seen as lack of integrity, which is a problem

He lied about it to Bloomberg as a representative of Nvidia, so it goes beyond his personal life.

The affair itself is not the problem. The problem is if his wife doesn't like it, that secret is worth billions of dollars to keep. What would Jensen do to keep it secret?

Well, when the NY Times floated the first blackmail attempt, he obviously didn't play ball, so I guess we already know the answer?

unless he's absolutely open with his partner and other people in his life, doesn't care or even wants them to know, this provides leverage that can influence his actions. It's almost like you're the one pretending to be out of touch to make a your point...

Bedding an adversarial entity's agent in a regulated field is a serious matter (for the company) with potentially serious consequences. It can lead to executive decapitation, it can even lead to / criminal investigations if the operative bypassed export controls using executive proximity.. the fallout can be great and widespread. It can also be a nothingburger and an amusing page six divorce story in the end where we all read how rich cry as well. Time will tell. What's telling of where this might lead and how serious it is, is that it was US federal government that warned about this.

Yeah, 50 years ago this was a big deal; nowadays... meh. There are tons of people who have survived this and even worse. The public has become inured to infidelity, but so have the media and the various industry gatekeepers (it’s not bad enough to get someone blacklisted or made persona non grata). Except Epstein... those involved with him probably won’t recover. So there are lines that cannot be crossed, but cheating is not one of them. Hell, even beloved Patrick Stewart cheated on both of his first two wives, admitted it in his memoir, and no one cared.

This is completely false and there are numerous public examples to pull from. If anything, it is worse now than it was in the past with how the mob can dogpile.

Case and point, caught at a coldplay? cheating? Both fired? Lives destroyed?

As for the actor, really? Totally dif industries and people do care. Execs make a company look bad and when actors do too, cheating or not, they also get smacked.

You may not care but most people do and if a tiny spark hits Patrick, his legacy will be destroyed. There are many actors that the public is well aware of how gross they are and are hated for it regardless of ability.


Patrick cheated twice and it amounted to a footnote in his obituary. no one cared.

> Except Epstein... those involved with him probably won’t recover.

What? Nobody involved with Epstein has gone to prison yet. One of them was even re-elected president. If I had to list the terrible things you could do when you're rich and not face consequences, trafficking and raping children would sadly be high up on the list.


reputational harm. You think Larry Summer's career will recover?

Maybe I’m old but it doesn’t seem that long ago that Clinton got impeached for infidelity.

He got impeached over Perjury and Obstruction of Justice. For the coverup (a crime), not "the crime" (not a crime).

> Clinton got impeached for infidelity.

This is just blatantly false.

He wasn't impeached for infidelity, he was impeached for lying under oath and obstruction of justice[0].

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impeachment_of_Bill_Clinton


The most damning report indicating the severe trajectory towards RSI and ASI at frontier labs, the soon to be most impactful event in the world, and it’s barely a whisper on HN. Typical

HN has devolved considerably. It is practically general Reddit-tier kneejerk contrarianism now. I'm getting literal "Cool story bud" replies to me within the last day.

Year after year of the advent of LLM's has repeatedly shown HN overall consensus gettings things wrong again and again. AI lab employees aren't here they're on Twitter/lesswrong. 6 months ago Mythos was announced and it has been an absolute deluge of "it's just marketing stunts." Practically 75% of many threads had that take. Strange, we don't hear much about that anymore, now that the plethora of hacks has taken place and increasing. There will be no mea culpa, just moving on to the next kneejerk dismissal as peoples' subconscious fearfully grapples with our immediate future. They want the AI boom to fail, because the implications of what happens next when it doesn't fail is unknown and vaguely frightening to them, for now.


It's been that way forever here, don't worry. Signal to noise is lower today, but it's the same vibes, trust me. That said, earlier this year I got really frustrated, and put out https://github.com/vessenes/hn1k/, which lets you build a local hn restricted to 1k / 10k / 100k commenters (and threads they engage in) which will massively de-ragebait you.

I don't know why you've been flagged, I've noticed this trend and the Mythos thing as well.

Lots of people here called Mythos a marketing stunt, yet continue on in HN today having totally forgotten their original takes. I would bet some of them are reading this very post.

They don't even acknowledge that they were wrong, yet continue with the same behavior (reflexive contrarianism and denial) without updating. This confuses me greatly: why would anyone choose to be this stubborn, when it results in worse correctness? What do these people gain out of it?

(If anyone reading this fits the description - I'm genuinely curious.)


According to HN of the last year, "marketing stunts." Remember when Mythos preview was announced only 6 months ago


"It's just marketing" HN mostly told us


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: