HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | rdevsrex's commentslogin

How long they will have access to staggering amounts of compute is uncertain and not guaranteed, especially if they get a junk or near-junk credit status when they go public.

Maybe in a country like the UK, but not in the US. The Fifth Amendment protects against self-incrimination.

Which covers divulging encryption keys because it is treated the same as compelling you to give up the combination to a wall safe which is testimonial and protected.


That's been my understanding until now as well... the latest on the case against Samuel Tunick has me worried and second guessing that blanket statement though...

https://nccriminallaw.sog.unc.edu/2026/08/03/giving-police-a...


That case has the specific, very important, wrinkle that he provided a _destructive_ duress code, he could have continued to refuse to provide the unlock code just fine legally. It's the use of the duress code that is likely going to be getting him in trouble and that falls outside of the existing defined protections about being compelled to unlock safes/computers etc containing possible evidence against yourself.

We'll have to see how that case goes but ultimately the reason he's getting in trouble is only tangentially related to his phone being encrypted. It's more correct to think of it like he smashed the phone to pieces (and imagine this definitively destroys the data for the sake of the metaphor) instead of it being about the encryption itself.


He didn't smash the phone to pieces, he gave LE a hammer and they smashed the phone to pieces. It's entirely LE's own fault this happened -- they shouldn't have been trying to get into that phone, and it's their own fault it went wrong.

Though I would expect courts to consider that he knew LE planned to enter the provided PIN, and that the duress PIN would then result in the phone being wiped, and therefore accuse him of doing the wiping anyway.

But I don't think it's this guy's fault at all. LE is the one who asked him under duress, he easily could've feared for his life, and he did no direct harm. It was self-defense at worst.


That's too cute by half for the law, this kind of "I'm not touching you" argument comes up each time and it just doesn't work. The guy intentionally provided the code knowing it would destroy the "evidence"/contents of his phone if they entered it, it's clear what his intent was and the data would not have been destroyed if he did not take that action. The minor separation that he did not enter the code himself is highly unlikely to protect him in this case.

It's been a weakness in destructive duress codes since their inception.


> He didn't smash the phone to pieces, he gave LE a hammer and they smashed the phone to pieces. It's entirely LE's own fault this happened -- they shouldn't have been trying to get into that phone, and it's their own fault it went wrong.

Setting a booby trap to destroy evidence that then gets destroyed when that trap is triggered is the same as destroying evidence. This is common sense, but also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal_(criminal_law)


Yeah, if you use it as a way to destroy data that gives them a whole new and powerful attack vector. 18 U.S.C. § 2232 is very broad.


What's more infuriating than laws like that is that there's a class of people completely immune to those laws.


That's completely different. Pleading the 5th and not testifying is completely different from giving false testimony - which is never protected. Even in a trial, if you are asked under oath if you handled the body, you are allowed to say that you invoke your 5th amendment rights not to respond; but you are not allowed to say "no, I didn't" if in fact you did (you can later be accused of perjury in addition to your conviction).


> The Fifth Amendment protects against self-incrimination.

You can still be held in custody for obstruction of justice:

https://www.findlaw.com/legalblogs/third-circuit/man-held-in...

It took four years before he could secure his release:

https://www.sophos.com/en-us/blog/suspect-who-refused-to-dec...


you have the guy sitting in jail waiting for the courts to decide if his grapheneOS wiping his computer after wrong unlock codes is him obstructing.

keep in mind that the "obstruction" charge can be and is abused as a catchall charge.


> courts to decide if his grapheneOS wiping his computer after wrong unlock codes is him obstructing

He didn't provide an incorrect code, or no code at all, he provided a duress code intended to destroy the device. There's a huge legal difference.


The fifth amendment doesn't do jack shit if they haul you away. After a few years of trials and appeals you might regain your freedom.


I think that the issue is that the law enforcement personnel could make you pass a bad time even if it's covered by the Fifth Amendment. The enforcement could be later than the arbitrary decision.


Can't they just hand it to you say "you enter your passphrase, but don't divulge it to us and then hand us the phone". In other words hinging the passphrase divulging to the 5th can backfire in that respect. It like saying we have a search warrant, you open the safe for us, it's fine if you keep the combination to yourself, we just need to get inside.


No, that's pretty absurd. It's not specifically about the act of speaking. It's the act of incriminating yourself.

But that's all beyond the point, anyways. If they did hand you your phone and said, "enter your passphrase," you can just say, "I don't remember it." They can throw a fit and put more heat on you in various ways, but until they resort to torturing you or they develop mind-reading technology, there's not much they can do at that point until the case reaches a judge.

That's not to say "I don't remember" is a sound, blanket defense. But it's sufficient for demonstrating that these dynamics all depend on willing participants which is partially why these laws are designed the way they are.


If the search warrant and seizure wasn't a thing I'd agree with you. But I can easily see opening a phone interpreted not that differently than opening a safe or your reinforced front door.

> But it's sufficient for demonstrating that these dynamics all depend on willing participants which is partially why these laws are designed the way they are.

What happens if during serving a search warrant the door is impossible to open or they find a super reinforced safe. Owner can even say "I don't remember the combination"?


I'm not sure the police can compel you to open a safe. they can get a warrant to have someone weld it open with a blowtorch, but I don't think they can get a warrant to compel you to open your own safe for them.


The act of unlocking it can incriminate you. It's ~proof that you have control of the device beyond what they already knew.


Self-incrimination yes, but not for cases when the person compelled has evidence to incriminate another process in a case.


That being said, overlap protects you still. So if answering a question about another person might incriminate you, you don't have to answer.


He said "jail", not "prison".

There's a difference.


> Maybe in a country like the UK, but not in the US. The Fifth Amendment protects against self-incrimination.

SCOTUS: Hold my beer…

:)


Do they have the rest of the Epstein files?


There is one benefit that Jev has, that it is not OpenAI and thus it's probably less likely to steal your own work.


> that it is not OpenAI

For now. Any company that grows to OpenAI/Anthropic's size and gets VC money is ought to become greedy.


Or OpenAI just buys them outright. Buying your upstart competitor seems to be in the Silicon Valley Ten Commandments. The Fed whussed-out on breaking up FB and Insta last year, so there's never going to be any kind of remediation to worry about.

And for Jev, everyone has a price, and OpenAI's raised an historical amount of funding.


Not steal, but keep it indefinitely, per the JEV TOS


They absolutely need ZDR


At this point, we shouldn't trust company even with ZDR.


I have been told that ZDR is available upon manual request.


I can confirm, I sent their sales team an email asking for ZDR, and they provided it within an hour.


Enterprise I thought.

Or use it through Vercel [0] with per call zdr.

https://vercel.com/changelog/typesafe-ai-jev-now-available-o...


Every company would use your data and "steal" it at some point. VC money would demand it the moment the pressure is up.


This is a tired argument that needs actual evidence to go beyond the level of a conspiracy theory.


TIL the terms of service are a conspiracy theory.


Which clause? For instance openrouter lists openai as "Logs: this provider may retain prompts, but does not use them for training."

https://openrouter.ai/openai/gpt-6-astra#providers


Why would we be talking about model routers in the context of it being a conspiracy theory that OpenAI is ingesting data from users for training? Are you acting obtuse or do you genuinely not reading/following the conversation?

They are all very open about it. It's likely the reason why the frontier labs are ok paying many more dollars a person in compute than they receive as revenue on subscription users for now.

Here is OpenAIs page

https://openai.com/policies/how-your-data-is-used-to-improve...

>When you share your content with us, it helps our models become more accurate and better at solving your specific problems

And as a bonus here is anthropics saying the same thing

https://privacy.claude.com/en/articles/10023580-is-my-data-u...

Especially if you're doing something in a very sparsely populated part of their latent space it just makes sense that it would get used. Their biggest problem getting solved at the moment is going beyond what common crawl enables.

I await the standard goal post moving.


If it's in the TOS, and your settings, and they have pages describing it, and it's the reason they're willing to subsidize your usage, and in your own words "they are all very open about it", then how exactly are they "stealing your work" here, which was the original point about this being a conspiracy theory?


Because most people assume that when they say "we will use your data to improve things" that it means "improve your experience" not "we will steal your non-public ideas and use our subsidised compute to scoop your work and say we did it for press releases and then conduct a weird flail of PR smokescreens and threats when the lie falls apart".

Its quite obviously about good/bad faith use of user data.


Well, one thing is for sure, and that there are very few countries where more than half of the people have a bachelor degree.

So clearly there is a limit, either in space, money, interest, or ability. Perhaps the more important question is what does the economy going to need over the next 30-40 years, and what is the best way to prepare young people for it?


There is no human right to have a US visa interview; everything is a privilege that can be withdrawn.


Agreed. People seem to hold views that getting visas to the US is a human right.

It’s no fun, but these are adults (and often very privileged adults) that decided to move to a new country for more upside at the cost of no residency.

Conflating this with “inhumane” is just a basic misunderstanding of immigration and the contract these people signed up for.

Very uncomfortable, yet a risk these people took, and hopefully a conscious one.


You are both conflating technical correctness with morality


You are conflating morality with proper governance. Democratic government must enact the will of the citizen body, even if immoral in some frameworks.


Democratic government must also allow the citizen body to voice their displeasure with the activity of the government, and to give their reasons for that displeasure


They do, it's called voting. And you also have the right to voice your support.


You also have the right to voice your disapproval, which as the point of my reply to a comment that seemed to indicate otherwise


So it can be inhumane then, by your definition?


I dont think the moral/legal conflation is even the main tension here.

I think this distinction would help as well.

   Inhumane != human rights violation.
Both of these things can be true at the same time:

   1. It can be inhumane to halt someone's visa application

   2. Visa applicants have no human right to have their application processed
One side hammers the first point because they disagree with the government. The other side hammers the second point because they agree with the government.

Everyone is right, except for the implication that their point disproves the other side's point.


Sure. Unless you prefer autocratic rule by a moral paragon, democracy involves doing what people want, not what is moral. Often what is nominally moral is not good for the country or its people.


> People seem to hold views that getting visas to the US is a human right.

Come on, there's nothing to be gained by misrepresenting people's views.

The argument is a simple one: if you are currently within the immigration process you should be able to move through that process in a timely manner, with clear communication of expectations. Freezing appointments is a political hack: they're not changing the law, they're not altering what anyone is entitled to. They're just leaving people in limbo.

You're saying "these people took a risk", and you're right. But that doesn't mean we can't criticize the people ensuring their bet is a losing one in the least moral way possible.


Here is what hvb2 actually said:

> “Just ‘putting a pause’ on people with existing appointments with no answer for when they might resume is.... Inhumane”

And now you're saying:

> “if you are currently within the immigration process you should be able to move through that process in a timely manner, with clear communication of expectations.”

Sure it sucks. But do you understand there is no right to have this visa application interview nor a yes/no decision in a timely manner? Applying for a visa is a privilege. You aren't being denied some human right if the process is interrupted.


Actually, there is. I am a bit tired of correcting these types of misunderstandings that people have. Unreasonable delay, unlawful witholding, arbitrary and capricious are all well defined terms in the law and courts have routinely held and even forced the government to take action (i.e., do their job) when they just pause or suspend things. For a few recent decisions read this:

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/72218277/catholic-legal...

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/72369535/dorcas-interna...

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/72494270/ivanov-v-trump...


We’re talking about two different things and I don’t understand why you’re conflating them.

“It isn’t a right” and “it’s immoral” are not mutually exclusive statements. No, there is no human right to a visa application response. That doesn’t mean that leaving people in indefinite limbo is morally right.


Right is a moral category, not a legal one.


moral != inhumane. It's impossible to have a discussion if you equivocate.


> There is no human right to have a US visa interview; everything is a privilege that can be withdrawn.

I'm not sure what you're trying to argue with this strawman.

No one in the thread is claiming it's a "human right".


Since we’re doing straw man arguments, there’s not a single Republican in charge of the U.S. government today that cares about the inalienable rights given to you in the Constitution and Bill of Rights.

We the people will be reminding them who is actually in charge.


Seems well written to me.


Maybe at a bankruptcy sale; otherwise, it's a bad investment that only relieves current investors of their problem by passing the hand grenade to someone else.

If Norway, or any other country, wanted to, for far less money than buying a problematic company, they could fund a public cloud and rent it out at below-market rates to citizens, universities, and small businesses.


This is the most Euro commie thing I've heard in a long while.

Sure, get rid of factory farms and CAFO's, but I see nothing wrong with raising animals on family farms where they eat a nutritious diet in line with what they evolved to eat.

Grass for cows, pasture and bugs for poultry, silvopasture for pigs. Anyone who wants to go vegan for ethical or environmental reasons is fine, but I hate this idea that all of us have to fall in line with your crazy ideas.


> I see nothing wrong with raising animals on family farms where they eat a nutritious diet in line with what they evolved to eat.

Me either. It just means beef will become about 10x more expensive in places that don't have so much grassland or pastureland. Which is almost all of the places. You cool with that?


Do whatever you want.

I'm just sharing my personal choices based on what I've learned.

What could be more American than that? :)


The problem is, you have to choose. Do you really think people can continue to eat meat 2-3 times a day, purely supplied by family farms where animals are able to roam free?

The reality is that the only way to feed people's insatiable demand for meat is to use factory farms. You can't factory farm without causing suffering to animals, and you can't factory farm without use of antibiotics, etc.

Also you say, 'evolved to eat'. Do you think people were eating meat every day throughout human history? This started after WWII with mass agriculture and factory farming. That's why so many cultures have beans and rice as their primary dish: it's a perfectly balanced protein.

If 'evolved to eat' is your primary concern then actually you should be eating meat like once or twice a month, max. Evolution doesn't happen in less than a century.


> Do you think people were eating meat every day throughout human history? This started after WWII with mass agriculture and factory farming. That's why so many cultures have beans and rice as their primary dish: it's a perfectly balanced protein.

Yes people were eating meat most of the human history, because farming was invented much much later. If you have ever been in a temperate forest which covered most of the area of current Europe, northern America and northern Asia you would notice there isn't really much to eat besides wild game.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: