This was a huge milestone, but you're right that there are a long list of future milestones: catch both on the same flight, reuse of both on a given flight, fly without significant refurbishment, fly N times in T time for many values of each, orbital refueling, crew, etc.
On May 27, 2025, Starship’s ninth flight test successfully lifted off at 6:36 p.m. CT from Starbase, Texas. The flight test began with the first Super Heavy booster to be reflown starting up successfully and completing a full-duration ascent burn with all 33 of its Raptor engines before separating from Starship’s upper stage in a hot-staging maneuver. During separation, Super Heavy performed the first ever deterministic flip followed by its boostback burn." -- https://www.spacex.com/updates#flight-9-report
Per Claude, if you use Chinese prices for the metals (especially tungsten) Simon still wins from 1980-2026. If you use US prices, Ehrlich wins. Copper is the only metal with a market price above the 1980 value, but tungsten is export-controlled by China, so much more expensive in the West.
I think directionally Ehrlich was quite wrong, given that he expected widespread and crippling shortages before 2000, with a much lower population than we actually have, and there's no sign of such shortages being inevitable. In particular, we are opening new extractable oil sources and switching to solar fast enough that pure market actions seem on track to where we'll be leaving cheap oil in the ground in a couple decades absent AI X-risk, and this is after we politically killed the previous tech that would have produced this result earlier: widespread fission.
I'm fully aware. But Starlink is blocked by today's Starship launch cadence and payload capacity. Pointing out Starship could handle this payload 5 years in the future isn't helpful.
All of Starlink's future ambitions are blocked by today's Starship.
The primary science fiction quality of the show is that something like that could have been done as early as it was said to have been. At the time, that part of it seemed almost completely impossible. With subsequent developments, it now only seems implausible. Wild.
To me the wildest part was always that this originally aired almost 2 full years before Snowden. The premise that the government gave itself permission to read and analyze all digital traffic after 9/11 was more conspiracy than science fiction back then, but Snowden showed that basically everything the show claimed (except for the artificial superintelligence doing the analysis) was actually true. And heck, if it is not 100% true today, it probably will be very soon. I'd be very surprised if the NSA isn't tapping into the secret in-house research models at OpenAI that are still a long way from public release.
The European Parliament's ECHELON report was in 2001. It was well known that the NSA intercepts everything digital it possibly can. When Snowden came along, I was baffled at people treating his claims as uniquely revelatory, because all of that had already been in the news a decade prior, and sites like Cryptome were known in nerd circles.
What Snowden did was prove it being any doubt to the general public. Until that time people were considered tinfoil hats mentioning it, even though the Airbus Boeing incident was well documented. But people really thought they weren't a target unless they were a rich industrialist.
If you brought up the concept that they surveiled everyone just because they can, you'd be laughed out of the room. Nobody would pay for all that, nobody would have time to look at it blabla.
Snowden made it all real. And even then, instead of a serious outrage most people just shrugged and accepted it, strange enough.
This! Back in the early 2000s I was doing my BSc and had so much free time to spend in the depths of the internet. Cypherpunk lists, web forums and even usenet. Thus has been "known" since way back in the day before Snowden.
I remember when Assange founded Wikipedia, it was one of the reasons I thought.
>Jimmy Wales launched the site in 2001 and funded its initial servers through his company Bomis.
>Larry Sanger co-founded the project alongside Wales, proposed the name "Wikipedia," and drafted several foundational policies such as the neutral point of view.
PRISM and XKEYSCORE were born post 2007 from the Protect America Act. Echelon was merely a report that agencies were sharing data (which wasn't much of a conspiracy in the first place) and them targeting private data. But a secret, global mass surveillance program of basically every individual on the planet without court orders or any oversight was only a plot element of movies before Snowden.
The ECHELON report detailed how international telecommunications had been vacuumed up by the NSA for years already, first phone calls, but it was clear that this was already extending to the internet, too. And as the other poster mentions, Room 641A was revealed in 2006, again years before Snowden.
That was all corporate espionage, like the Boeing-Airbus case. Noone actually knew they had the power or even cared to monitor literally everyone. XKEYSCORE as detailed by Snowden was literally the main plot driver in POI, although it was not AI in reality.
> To me the wildest part was always that this originally aired almost 2 full years before Snowden
Enemy of the State came out in 1998, Sneakers came out in 1992, If you are old enough to have been around in the usenet and later slashdot days most of us techies assumed then that anything technically possible with a giant budget and no oversight that could be done was been done.
Echelon was "known" to exist for example long before Snowden.
Snowden was essentially useful to confirm that suspicion, sadly it seems to have had little impact on how anything is done.
> this originally aired almost 2 full years before Snowden
Now watching in season 1, episode 2, Harold says about the machine: "If anyone else ever found out, there'd be such an outcry... They'd turn it off." which feels incredibly prescient and quite naive at the same time. Love it.
Similar to how the show 24 manufactured consent for torture, imperialism, etc post-9/11, part of me wonders how much of a role POI played in doing the same for mass surveillance.
A flamboyant billionaire hoarding all communications and digital events while claiming to be the good guy. Sure sounds familiar.
PoI had full-take surveillance of domestic data, which Snowden's docs showed wasn't true, despite many people believing it before the dump. It's more similar to Flock.
It wasn't my favorite, but my first Mac was a PowerBook G4 17-inch, which I ran Gentoo and (I think) Yellow Dog Linux on at various times. It never worked super well, and I eventually joined the dark side. In 2003, a 17-inch laptop was ludicrous among all the netbooks that seemed to be the future of laptops. People around me called it the "aircraft carrier Mac".
Ok you know what? Very fair objection. Just because I never encountered it personally doesn't mean anything. My first web development was not until about 2007, and simply was not ever in any company that used it.
hah, you skipped right over a world of pain in the early 2000's! Every site had to essentially be built twice: once for everything but IE, and then once again for IE, it sucked ass
Yes, you should assume that all software you use is full of holes, and after we patch all the holes that could conceptually have been discovered by a motivated human, there will still be holes that can only be found by considering larger windows of context than any human has or could. Even when something is formally verified, that doesn't extend to its software environment or the hardware it's running on, and those can introduce exploitable vulnerabilities as well. You can only ever be very confident that we've found all the holes at a given analysis capability level -- if something a hundred times as capable looks, it will likely find many more. That's how it will be.
I mean, you quoted them as saying "with a complaint", but your example is of something that needs to be fixed. I also very, very rarely complain to customer service, and am more likely to use another company if my ire rises to the point where I am considering a complaint.
My wife complains to customer service without any expectation that something will change. If she gets a refund or partial refund, she's somewhat more mollified, but she will definitely write a complaint even if she has no expectation that there is anything that can now be done about her experience. She mostly wants to vent, and for the company to validate that they screwed up and seem apologetic about it.
Contacting customer support doesn't make me feel better, and it's almost always more bother than any refund I could get, so I don't do it much. The article is indeed about trying to get something fixed, but I wouldn't call that a complaint. It's more a suggestion.
> i think everyone who complains to customer service is doing so because they want something fixed
When I worked customer service a substantial number of complaints to customer service seemed to just be to complain. They won't care if you fix the thing, they'll complain about that too.
> i think everyone who complains to customer service is doing so because they want something fixed?
Clearly you've never worked in customer service. Yes, people absolutely will call in or email complaints purely for the sake of complaining. No specific actionable complaint, no resolution possible, just complaining to complain.
I don't know how you draw the line but to me there's a clear distinction between "you've fraudulently taken my money" and "this is shitty for everyone could you fix it please".
While I've never met anyone named Jody, it was a common nickname decades past in the US Army for the guy who your girl is cheating with while you're deployed. I'm surprised to see it was considered a female name in the time I would have expected it to be more definitely male, given that context.
Looking it up, it appears that the original name was "Joe" rather than "Jody", so maybe that's the distinction in the early 20th.
A lot of people have recently started smoking with the expectation that cancer will soon be a nonissue. He just promised not to use AI for the coding itself, but for fixing problems created along the way... ;)
reply