HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | raizer88's commentslogin

The thing is that in auth (like in cryptography) the rulebook is 2000 pages and there is an annotation book of another 2000. If you miss one page, the llm doesn't and will open you like a tuna can.

What 2000 page auth(n) are you referring to? authn may use aspects of cryptography but it’s largely orthogonal. The point is, it’s fine to roll your own authn.

If you don’t want to roll your own authn, you’re delegating to oauth (oidc) identity providers like google/apple/facebook/etc., which not everyone has an account.


This type of attack lasted few days in different countries, quite hard to believe the fridge manufacturer could keep pushing these updates after all the news around.

Every time something like this has been done on my company I follow up with the question: did anyone watched the code to see if the business logic is the same between the two versions? The answer is: but but but automated testing.

Followup question: did anyone read the automated test suite?

Silence.

The software rewrite is shelved.


Honest question: does that even remotely matter, or is it an outdated prior? All software has bugs.

The goal and objective is to deliver value for your user/customers; to the speed, reliability, and assurance requirements your market segment expects.


All software has bugs, but right now you have a legacy product in production that works, then you have a rewrite that nobody tested. Do you accepted the risk to yolo it?


Sometimes the risk is acceptable, sometimes it's not.


> to the speed, reliability, and assurance requirements your market segment expects.

I suspect that the average Cisco customer expects a bit more stability than $RANDOM_SAAS.


I worked with Cisco products over 30 years, I don't expect much from experience.


Ok but what’s the alternative? Owning a piece of software nobody understands or knows how to maintain?

I’ll take the system written in a language that people can maintain and fix


The alternative is spending money on AI and spending money on someone reviewing the code. But the last one is an hard sell


The self-driving bus factor.


Every time somebody rewrote code in my company, my questions were more on the line of "why did you preserve all the known bugs and incoherences?"

The answer is always that the rewrite was bug-compatible on purpose, the bugs were to be fixed later on the more tractable system. Every time development was abandoned right away, because there was no gain in using the new system.


> did anyone watched the code to see if the business logic is the same between the two versions?

Why not just ask the coding assistant?


also take the money saved on engineering and just run two systems in parallel for a year


Yup. And its always garbage as result


Not if you have a good harness. Docs and tests first


Why do people doing a rewrite need to have read the tests?

If you have good test coverage, and the tests are reliable, then what's the problem?

If your engineering culture is bad already and you don't have good test coverage or they're flaky or whatever then that is different. If that is the case, it is probably from smart-ass attitudes like yours asking these "clever" rhetorical questions to derail people trying to improve things that led it to be like that. Do everyone a favour and keep your mouth shut and let people fix things.


The tests aren't reliable if the entire codebase was rewritten, including the tests, and then nobody read the tests.


> [if] the tests are reliable

Reading the tests is meant to check that.


Because you spread the bots farms in multiple countries and set the command center on the other side of the Cremlin square, than VPN to a Yandex datacenter to coordinate the farms. Kill Yandex and the farms stay idle and the traffic drop.


Stop smoking the stash


Offgrid garage tested it a couple of videos ago and basically the battery lost capacity due to age and not for cycling. And that battery was made with the first generation of lifepo4 from eve, recent battery are better. Realistically it will die first the BMS than the cells in a couple of decades


Until astra goes bonkers and use the tpu for days



Billing caps that Google notoriously doesn't enforce?


This is kind of what it was supposed to do, in this case


The engineering problem is called physic and thermodynamics. And unless we learn how to change those rules the problem will be unsolvable. It's like discussing perpetual motion...


I hear this a lot without actual calculations backing up the claim.

First of all, orbital data centre doesn't mean a monolithic 500MW monstrosity orbiting Earth. That's not what the companies actually investigating the idea (Google, Amazon, SpaceX, ...) have in mind.

The real-world implementation would use constellations of Starlink-sized satellites, so we're talking about a ~10kW power envelope. Under ideal orbital conditions (sun synchronous near polar orbit, ~250-450km), you can get away with as little as 40m² of radiator area depending on engineering margins, provided you allow your radiator/coolant temps to be 70°C and above (70°C is what I used for my estimation plus an ideal 400km SSO and a reasonably efficient radiator similar to the improved ETCS on the ISS - no ammonia for the coolant, though see below as to why).

People often cite the ISS and its ~100m² radiators for comparison. The problem with that is that for one, the design operating temperature of the ISS' EATCS is 4°C on the low temp loop and 17°C on the moderate temp loop. That little known fact aside, the current improved ATCS is capable of rejecting 70kW of waste heat - way more than the thermal output a realistic satellite would produce. The active temperature control system (ATCS) of the ISS is designed around humans and science experiments in a 400km 52°N to 52°S orbit, not silicon chips that are allowed to run much hotter than 25°C and sit in SSO.

In short the *actual* thermodynamics work out just fine if you consider real satellite designs instead of sci-fi monstrosities, use realistic operating temperatures for the coolant loop designed around silicon chips, and the desired target orbit.

So when you say "unless we learn how to change those rules the problem will be unsolvable" I'd honestly like to know why my 25+ year old literature on satellite mission and hardware design, Boeing's numbers from "Active Thermal Control System (ATCS) Overview" document, the formulas from NASAs "Guidelines for thermal analysis of spacecraft hardware", this gem from DLR https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asr.2024.11.024 and my calculator are all wrong at the same time.

Sure, I only did some napkin math (still took nearly 45min) using some simplified formulas and crude estimates for the required parameters (I was curious, but not THAT curious), but I always rounded up and used a healthy 2x margin on top of the estimated result.

So please tell me why I'm wrong.


Didn't they fire half of siri team yesterday?


Because the capitalist west doesn't have strategic view, beside maybe on the defense sector. Everything else must produce profits next quarter not in the next 3 years.


It's this. Wall Street won't allow american companies to make long term decisions and long term planning that cost money in the short term, because they want all that money immediately now. Like, right now now. If an executive promised they could deliver big profits in 5 years by spending the next two investing their profits, Wall Street would fire them and put in someone who will happily spend all the profit (plus debt) to do stock buybacks and dividend disbursals.


The stock market works that way, it's true.

But what about SpaceX, Blue Origin... there are also counter examples that show it is possible for investors to wait out the big profits.


I don't believe either of those two companies have ever been profitable. (I'm sure Musk has some accounting tricks to make it look that way, though.)


Indeed, if these are loss making operations, who puts the capital for those rockets to get off the ground? and why are they putting their capital in this when instead they could have a "nice ETF bringing 10% yearly"?


I mean, if you want to count investors as revenue, that's not exactly standard economics.


no, that's not what i'm doing, just the opposite.

OP argued that investment is lead by short term thinking, yet i point out example of long term thinking and risk taking by investors.


Oh, I understand what you mean. Thank you for explaining.


those are not run by Wall Street. they are run by 2 billionaires who care about something other than near-term profit (legacy, ambition, etc).


That's exactly my point, those are run by private equity, investors willing to take the risks and wait the big payday out.


Both those companies only can exist because of massive amounts of corporate welfare. What exactly are you trying to argue here? That the government should give private capital more of the people's money while the country suffers from lack of healthcare, childcare, education, and housing?

What's the point of this? Honestly?


The point I'm trying to make is that there are also investors that are long on an investment and willing take losses for a long time before the big pay off materialises, or not. But that's private equity investment rather than stock market logic. Capitalism can also be about the mid-long term profits, given the proper opportunity.

Musk did not go it alone in the SpaceX venture, he obviously had other investors joining in on the risks and potential losses.

As for the government giving private capital public funds, no, that's obviously not what i'm arguing for, even though that's pretty much how the US has been running since WW2. The military industrial complex did not rise up as a normal capitalistic venture.

I am as appalled as anyone by the divestments in healthcare, education and such in the US, but the moral underpinnings and fundaments of the United States and its history, the puritanical element in particular, lead me to think that this is going to remain a long term issue in this country.


America is the greatest country on earth because someone owns 50 billion dollars.


It's even worse, the entire ideology is that industrial policy can't, by definition, be better than what the market would decide without interference. So every kind of actual strategic decision making (i.e. investing a few hundred billions in the industries of importance for the next decade(s), or at least in the infrastructure supporting it) would actually make matters worse. That is essentially what neoliberalism is all about.

This is core reason why the German industry became so irrelevant in the last 2 decades: The rail infrastructure became pseudo privatized and now is in shambles (IIRC only about 60% of trains arrive on time). The PV industry was axed by the conservatives about 15 years ago and now is completely dominated by China. Even now, as the other EU countries demand strategic investments - and again the German conservatives say this ought to happen without any new debt. "We can only spend what we have", to quote Merz. Imagine China saying this about chip production, or even Sam Altman about compute hardware...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: