HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | pugio's commentslogin

I have a hard time suspending disbelief with sci-fi these days. It's really hard to imagine any believable future along current trend lines; either you contrive a reason why AI didn't become a thing (1), or you have to explain why humans are doing anything - piloting a starship, science, exploration, etc. (2)

(1) Butlerian Jihad. Sanderson's Skyward at least had a reason.

(2) Banks's Culture had a possible future. I'm sure there are others, but not many.

I think about this a lot, and while I have tons of near future sci-fi ideas (which probably would have seemed very far future, 10-20, years ago), I just can't conceive of anything much farther out. I guess that's why they call it the "singularity".


You just have to drop the assumption that sci-fi stories take place in the future, even if they explicitly say so. They happen in fictional universes that are similar to ours in some ways and different in others.

The umbrella term is speculative fiction. The author starts by assuming that the world works in certain ways, and then tries to figure out the consequences.


While these are not far future ideas they were pretty good:

1) Masters of Science Fiction tv series from 2007 Episode 5 "Little Brother" - A person "jailbreaks" the judge who is sentencing him.

2) Terminator 3 rise of the machines - in the beginning they talk about allowing Skynet access to their military systems and so on to eliminate a virus, and they have no idea how it will react. Echoes a little bit where we are now.

These aren't perfect of course but kind of interesting to see at present day


I find battlestar galactica to be quite on point, real Ai (llm is not) will eventually either be banned or it will grow beyond humans and do its own thing.

One short story worth reading, not on this list, is Manna[1] by Marshall Brain. It proposes two different futures that both seem at least possible as outcomes in a future with advanced AI.

[1] https://james.darpinian.com/manna


> or you have to explain why humans are doing anything

Jack Williamson made a case for humans resisting doing nothing: With Folded Hands ... (1947) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/With_Folded_Hands_...


Just re read this. Great book. Frighteningly prescient.

Humanity literally hugged to death and going gentle into that good night is arguably more likely and more frightening than berserker terminators.

Futurama had a propaganda film entitled I Dated a Robot in an episode https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IrrADTN-dvg

Have you read the Bobiverse series? It goes into some of these themes, and explores AI, post humanity and so on.

As to prediction, there were some accurate early hits. A Logic Named Joe nailed the search engine with a chatbot front end, and pointed out the problems of systems smart enough to tell people in detail how to do bad stuff.

Much early SF thinking was that AIs would be logical. That's what I was taught, going through Stanford back when the logicians were in charge. They were trying to hammer the real world into predicate calculus. That turned out to be totally wrong.

Almost everybody in SF underestimated the difficulty of robot unstructured manipulation. So did people in AI. They still do. Most SF assumed that robots would be able to do most eye/hand tasks before they could talk. No. Still unsolved. LLMs don't seem to help all that much. Written language doesn't have much info on grasping, and watching without doing is only marginally helpful.

Asimov's robot novels were all about alignment, and why alignment is hard. That was prophetic.

Banks' Culture novels are great, but they're for a future that has a lot of new physics.

Now what? What we seem to be headed for in the near term is the fast automation of most white collar work, but not blue collar work. SF foresaw that future a few times. One example is the Rosinante Trilogy from 1981, where there's a boss of an orbital space colony, an AI as middle management, and union labor doing the real work. That's a hard SF view. There's How to Live Safely in a Science Fictional Universe, from 2010, where the protagonist's supervisor is "Microsoft Middle Manager 2.0 with passive-aggressive set to low." It's a minor part of the comedic plot there. And, of course, there's Manna, from 2003, which is looking all too likely.


I think for me the biggest problem is what we understand about physics and FTL and causality. For FTL to happen, I can’t seem to get around the fact that to an observer a ball is thrown before it actually is thrown. So it’s very difficult for me to do sci-fi…

A lot of post-cyberpunk hard sci-fi is about augmented posthumans mostly for this reason.

Give Accelerando by Charles Stross a read. The future isn't over yet.

I think you suffer from Fisher's 'capitalist realism':

>the widespread sense that not only is capitalism the only viable political and economic system, but also that it is now impossible even to imagine a coherent alternative to it.

Star Trek and Banks' are post-capitalist futures.


I'm saying that I haven't really seen (almost) anybody present a coherent future. Not just me.

Star Trek, as much as I love it, does not really grapple with AI heavily, and I already mentioned Banks.


Star Trek is easy to "imagine", but also easy to invalidate.

The only slightly fleshed out bit of Star Trek is the military, not the planetary society.


The task of coming up with compelling post-singularity sci-fi is almost the same as the task of ensuring that life after the singularity is actually interesting.

In both cases the question is the same: How to create a compelling plot, either for a story or for your life, in a world where human mental abilities are vastly inferior to those of AI?

From a pessimistic perspective, you could think of reasons why a misaligned AI keeps humans alive. Does it simply enslave humans and use us for our fine-manipulation capabilities until it can get proper robotics up and running? Does it want to observe us scientifically? Does it want to use captive humans as bargaining chips with other civilizations as it expands through the galaxy? Or does it have some sort of quasi-religious respect for humans, e.g. reasoning that keeping us on a reservation of some kind reduces the risk that a simulator-god pulls the plug on the universe?

From an optimistic perspective, what sort of conflicts would exist in a utopia? Stories need conflict to be interesting. And IRL, even if humans are living in relative utopia, they'll still get stir-crazy and create conflict. Even in countries that are very wealthy by global or historical standards, political competition can still be quite bitter, for example. How would a superintelligent AI manage this?

I'm reminded of the stories I read set in Karl Schroeder's Virga universe as a kid. All the characters and plot exist inside a planet-sized balloon filled with gas. But it takes a while for the reader to figure this out, because most of the setting is focused on the details: rotating habitats, air transport, artificial mini-suns, etc.

In the same way, good post-singularity fiction might very well put the AI deep in the background.

Imagine, for example, a story about some friends surviving, exploring, and doing battle in an ancient ruin full of puzzles. Only gradually do you realize that the ancient ruin was designed as a moon-sized escape room by a superintelligent AI. The moon-sized escape room already has centuries of lore, and the escape record to beat is measured in years or decades. But because the escape room "rules of engagement" are so well-defined, the players are deeply immersed and barely think about the fact that the moon is AI-designed. Perhaps some high-tech psychoactive drug or brain implant could play a role in facilitating suspension of disbelief.

Just like Virga, this deep background only gets revealed when the reader is thoroughly invested in the story, and overall is not treated as especially important. The story could be a philosophical meditation on the long-term future of AI-designed art and entertainment. See if you can steelman the pro-AI-art position.


> From a pessimistic perspective, you could think of reasons why a misaligned AI keeps humans alive. Does it simply enslave humans and use us for our fine-manipulation capabilities until it can get proper robotics up and running? Does it want to observe us scientifically? Does it want to use captive humans as bargaining chips with other civilizations as it expands through the galaxy? Or does it have some sort of quasi-religious respect for humans, e.g. reasoning that keeping us on a reservation of some kind reduces the risk that a simulator-god pulls the plug on the universe?

Or another: it just ignores us, but keeps the good resources to itself. There's still humanity, but it's brutish and primitive, regressed to the stone age, and pushed to the margins. Basically feral animals. They know about the AI's works, but don't understand them. The smart ones stay away out of fear, the dumb ones go where they're not wanted and get killed by pest control.

There are so many bad ends to this, and not many plausible good ones. But of course we have no choice but to race forward, off the cliff. After all, we can't let China be the ones that push humanity off it first!


Great idea. Related: My wife and I have been sending each other video game achievement style images (with ChatGPT) to celebrate our little wins and keep us going in a busy household. I've also recently been planning goals for next year, and hit upon making my goal tracker look like the old Quest for Glory V character UI. Instant major (recurring) motivation boost.

Takeaway: Try mining your own past for the easy things that bring you joy, and weave those in. Personal UIs are free now, so do the fun thing.


I can't imagine anything more unappealing than exchanging AI generated images with my wife every time one of us cleans the kitchen or finishes reading a book on time. Goes to show, people really are different!


You really can't see anything positive in celebrating achieving stuff with someone you love, just because AI is partially involved?

I dunno, that feels like an unproductively strong disdain towards AI. But like you said, people really are different, I guess!

edit: I realise I'm assuming AI is the issue here, maybe it's not?


I assume it's a combination of feeling the same way if they just sent eachother feel-good stickers, and involving AI for... some reason.


That is correct. It's basically saying that you made an effort when you didn't.


Personally I don’t want to see any image generated by AI as it is just all fluff and adds no value. A simple text saying you did the thing would be sufficient


Yes. My partner would tell me to fuck off if I did that.


my partner would lose so much respect for me if I did that. and that respect was hard-won, she had a mediocre dude as a longterm ex (the type who would probably send LLM-generated achievements) and basically had to remap her base expectations to fit me being minimally pro-active and emotionally regulated


Quest for Glory! Fond memories of picking warrior, wizard, or thief; and the transition from sunny III to IV.


AI Slop images interchanged...... Jesus


I use Gemini-2.5-flash extensively, mostly for its low latency, and haven't found anything which works better at that speed/cost. Which is why I'm really bummed that Google is deprecaty/removing it next week.

Have you found anything that works as a suitable replacement?


Hmm maybe I misread the mail - I thought they were removing it for new users next week, but turning it off for existing users in January or something?

Now I worry.

And of course I have no easy replacement for when it does go away :(


Cut & Paste always struck me as more of a Windows thing. Which is weird because obviously I can do cmd+X / cmd+V on a mac... I just never do. Instead it's "select" - command+C - delete - cmd+V.

Am I the only one who does that?

(EDIT: Same thing on Finder. cmd+C cmd+Del cmd+V)

Anyway, I love the design aesthetic of the site, and when people question existing paradigms. Will definitely be checking Ishmael out.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: