HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | prvc's commentslogin

A "stop-motion movie" that makes heavy use of CGI---what's the point?


All of the "important stuff" is practical stop motion. CGI is only used in cases where stop motion is either impossible (fire, waterfalls, the distant backgrounds of shots) or impractical (the wide shot of a scene with thousands of people)

And as a general rule, the main subjects of a shot are never CGI.

So the point is- it's stop motion. The amount of hand crafted and hand animated art on display is astonishing.

Disclaimer- I work there. In a support role, not directly, but I'm lucky enough to get to see the insane level of hard work everybody is putting in for years and years for a single movie


3d printing a sequence of computer animated models and photographing them stretches the definition of "practical stop motion" as I understand it to mean. This is quite apart from the issue of using post-production CGI.


That's a fair complaint, but for the most part that only applies to the faces (which would be an absolute nightmare to hand animate in sync with the voices in a way that felt real) and hair on some characters. The rest of the bodies, and objects in the scenes, are usually entirely hand animated.

To avoid the 3d printing elements would undoubtedly result in a less realistic and immersive movie. Not that you couldn't do it, but I think that's one element that makes these movies work so well.


Saw it with my family last last night and we all loved it. I was amazed at how much Laika has upped their game with crowds and FX. That, and I definitely noticed things like the subsurface on the skin and smoother motion in general.

I previously worked at Pixar for 11 years on the RenderMan team and would sometimes talk to some of your CGI folks. I'm crossing my fingers that this is Laika's year at the Oscars.


Almost any movie makes heavy use of CGI. Combining them with practical effects, like stop-motion, yields better results than sticking to one technique.

The practical grounds the digital, and the digital enhances the practical.


Here is a behind the scenes video

https://youtu.be/ocEXQSIcT-o?si=lxHFIaSioF9xLpnC


There is now an opportunity for them to do it again by providing an easily understandable proof which isn't broken up into a large number of cases.


>Sounds more like brute forcing than intelligence

Do you have a criterion that distinguishes between whatever you mean by those two respective terms?


Power (Watts).


This was a glorious and layered response. Thank you for making me chuckle.

Next thing you know, we'll have a WattsApp to help AIs connect and discuss.


Article could have profited by adopting a neutral tone instead of attempting to be comedic. Surely information on historical sizes has not been lost. As for the candy bar market: the ideal outcome for the consumer would be if a single candy bar ended up being a reasonable portion size, priced proportionately to cost to produce.


"Surely" is doing a lot of work here.

If they are in manufacturer databases or government bodies registration information - often behind different SKUs and product code name changes, it doesn't mean they're not effectively lost, without a known and easy way for the public to check and compare.

>As for the candy bar market: the ideal outcome for the consumer would be if a single candy bar ended up being a reasonable portion size, priced proportionately to cost to produce.

The "ideal outcome for the consumer" would be the candy bar not to reduce in size and increase in price, which is what we're seeing.


I am the complete opposite of that. My attention wanes when someone fails to get to the point, instead dwelling in irrelevant details which are not intrinsically interesting. Have to muster the motivation to concentrate in such circumstances, and doing so is not enjoyable.


What's the Pareto front of "get to the point" vs. "attempt to tell a compelling story"?


is this also true when the irrelevant details are (by coincidence) interesting (to you)? it sounds to me like GP is interested in mario kart and you simply aren't, so this is a perfectly natural result.


I’m not interested on Mario kart at all and still found the article to be interesting.


There does not seem to be a documented close lineal connection between August Dvorak and composer Antonín Dvořák, although it would be reasonable to suppose some relation exists.


There's also no documented close lineal connection between John C. Dvorak and August Dvorak, any more than his birthplace being Los Angeles. Both of which are blindly-repeated, unsourced (and untrue) Wikipedia inventions.


Wikipedia sources the claim to an article by Jerry Pournelle in BYTE magazine, from 1985.


Here's the snippet in question from the magazine:

https://imgur.com/a/8SVQGnj


Wikipedia and Pournelle are wrong, here's John Charles Dvorak himself on November 27, 1988:

https://ibb.co/x8RJvWyX

"I'm told there is a relationship, but I can't prove it."

John knows who his uncles are. His father is Walter Charles Dvorak born in Minneapolis to John Steve Dvorak (also born in Minneapolis). August Dvorak and all of his siblings (none of them Walter) were all born in McLeod County to IMMIGRANT Joseph Dvorak. If there's a connection it goes back to Bohemia.


Is that from the San Francisco Examiner? Do you have sources for the family information you mention?


Yes it is, and yes, several primary sources that anyone can easily find if they're looking in the proper places.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: