Companies still have good products and services... And also mediocre and bad ones, too.
The thing with ads is they are not informative, they are literally propaganda - a message that intends to change your mind about something and take action. Which ads inform you "this product is kinda bad" or "you don't really need this service"? None.
So ads aren't just visual clutter,they're basically a psy-op to get you to buy stuff. I don't have any respect for them, and the claim that "ads are useful and informative" is truly bonkers.
At most, an ad can tell us something exists, and then it's up to us to do the homework of researching it's usefulness.
A government is supposed to represent its people. There is quite a wave of AI criticism, so governments should apply incentives to the good results and oppose/mitigate the bad results.
The problem is when governments are in bed with the big corps and stop representing their people.
The super rich can achieve regulatory capture at a faster rate then the people can fix it. That's the real problem here. That's why we have so much consolidation in spite of anti-trust rules. That's why many industries can 'regulate' themselves. How do you think we got such absolutely nonsense copyright durations? It's not because that's what the people wanted.
The people can, on increasingly rare occasions, make such a stink that they get something they wanted and the super rich have to make a concession. For a while at least, but then it always moves back.
I predict any new AI laws that come out of government (regardless of party in power) will have a spin about being good for people, but under the hood will be designed very carefully to further entrench the power of the existing players.
The governments are freaking out about being left behind. The narrative is that this is the new industrial revolution and nobody wants to be caught with their pants down using horses and muskets when every other major power has moved on to heavy industry and tanks and machine guns.
Lee came from a web tech company (Google) to the PTO, adopted web tech company friendly policies at the PTO, then left for a web tech company (Amazon).
Cantor Fitzgerald is a diversified financial services company with 12,000 employees, which is exposed to a wide swath of the economy (meaning that government action in any one area doesn't move the needle much).
Michelle Lee joined Amazon 2 years after leaving the Trump administration USPTO. Neither Google nor Amazon are her family business. She clearly followed the federal ethics law. In no way, Lee was operating in a manner that clearly indicated nepotism.
Lutnick's adult children: Brandon Lutnick is chairman and Kyle Lutnick is executive vice chairman. This family owns Cantor Fitzgerald.
As to the scale and magnitude, we already know that Cantor Fitzgerald was designated sales agent in a ~$1 billion offering for a single data center of Bitdeer. And they involved in many such business deals with Bitdeer that involved hundreds of millions of dollars. A full scope of how much "the needle moved" will need a formal investigation. Remember again - this is his family-owned business.
Michelle Lee is rich, but not even a billionaire. Her personal wealth is ~$100 million.
You are comparing two extremely different people. One is clearly corrupt to even a layman. If you cannot see it, then I am afraid you are operating with an extreme bias. I suggest talking it over with someone you trust.
Why do you keep emphasizing it’s a “family business”? What difference does that make? The facts you’re pointing to aren’t relevant to corruption. The problem with corruption is where an official does something he or she wouldn’t otherwise do because it serves their personal interest. So what’s relevant is how direct and specific the connection is between the official acts and the personal interests.
With Michelle Lee, there was a very specific link between her policies and her employer’s interests. Michelle Lee went to the USPTO and implemented patent policies that directly effectuated what Google and Amazon had been lobbying for. The patent policies Lee worked on were specific hobby horses of tech companies.
Lutnick by contrast is a pro-AI guy in a pro-AI administration who happens to have a generalized investment in AI. That’s not a direct and specific connection. AI is 25% of economic growth right now. It cuts across a huge swath of the economy.
Again, what Lee did is not “corrupt” by typical standards. But the specificity of the conflict of interest is much more acute. But I’d say your average high level bureaucrat is worse than both! There are many, many lawyers who implement some major regulatory framework in government, then spend their whole careers helping companies navigate the regulations they implemented. If anything is “corrupt,” that seems much more corrupt than what we’re talking about here.
> Why do you keep emphasizing it’s a “family business”? What difference does that make?
What ? It makes ALL the difference in the world. He is directly enriching himself. I fail to understand how you cannot understand this.
> The facts you’re pointing to aren’t relevant to corruption....
I just don't get you at all. This is an utterly clear-cut case of corruption - as stupendously blatant as it gets. As clear as the Sun rising in the east. Worse, this is just the tip of the iceberg. Why bury your head so hard in cement for Trump cronies ?
His net worth has more than doubled to around $7.3 billion - a big portion of which is thanks to Lutnick’s indirect stake in Tether, via his stake in Cantor Fitzgerald.
Remember this -> Lutnick publicly vouched for Tether. Lutnick promised to divest his business interests when he joined the Trump administration. This promise was UTTERLY broken. Lutnick also continued to market and directly support his family business during his tenure as Secretary of Commerce.
Case-2: USA Rare Earth hired Cantor Fitzgerald as the lead placement agent for a $1.5 billion private share offering needed alongside the government deal. This after the CEO had a meeting with Lutnick. So, the Commerce Secretary effectively said - kindly use my family business for the govt deal.
>Lutnick by contrast is a pro-AI guy in a pro-AI administration... AI is 25% of economic growth right now. It cuts across a huge swath of the economy....Again, what Lee did is not “corrupt” by typical standards.
Ahh.. I finally get it. You don't really care about him being massively corrupt and want to hand-wave his actions away. You really don't want to rock the "AI Boat". Trump cronies can continue to be corrupt to their heart's content and keep favoring up their family businesses earning them billions in any/all manner. Just don't "Rock AI" plz.
I think we have reached the limit of our discussion since we apparently fundamentally disagree on simple tenets regarding public accountability and basic corruption. I really look forward to the future change of the US administration and the investigations which will come into play.
So not exactly equivalent? If she worked at Google and the patent office simultaneously and received bonuses from Google based on the decisions she made in her other job then it would be a fair comparison to what Lutnick is doing...
Right.. to his sons. I guess that's fine then. Its perfectly legal to abuse your office and make decisions that financially benefit your close family members. How could both the president and the secretary of treasury do it otherwise.
I agree with the abstractions, but there's still criticism to make - someone must fix the bugs in the layers below. If the code is messy, and the llms aren't getting there (they aren't infallible!), you have the risk to have put yourself into a corner.
This is because you are not Italian. If in Italy you find a wall writing with Dux on it, there is 100% only one thing it can mean. To me this sounds as weird as someone naming their project Führer
This is why free markets need reasonable legislation.
Even if a good willing CEO wants to do what's right, he is pressured not to do it by the unlegislated free market - his company is at (economical) disadvantage with the opposition, putting the company at risk or not meeting his obligations to shareholders. Let's not blame consumers either, because they cannot be informed about consequences in the nth order either.
If the legislation is reasonable, everyone must play by the same rules, both the good and the bad willing CEOs. The companies gain trust, the government too, and the consumers (and affected citizens) win.
I think with software engineering the biggest jumps have been agentic platforms or work flows. You can create a ticket and this triggers na agent to read the relevant docs and submit an MR, another to validate multiple concerns (correctness, security, performance, costs), another to uodate docs, etc. That's far more impressive than "dev sits down and asks LLM to write code".
With images, I don't see such potential. A builder and a reviewer iterating on improvements? Maybe the reviewer noticing it just needs programmable improvements, eg contrast, color balance etc and triggering a script on top of the LLM generation?
The thing with ads is they are not informative, they are literally propaganda - a message that intends to change your mind about something and take action. Which ads inform you "this product is kinda bad" or "you don't really need this service"? None.
So ads aren't just visual clutter,they're basically a psy-op to get you to buy stuff. I don't have any respect for them, and the claim that "ads are useful and informative" is truly bonkers.
At most, an ad can tell us something exists, and then it's up to us to do the homework of researching it's usefulness.
reply