HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | piker's commentslogin

> but nowhere has value been destroyed

There used to be (perhaps excess) value of knowledge being created in the brains of the employees of the organization building widgets. That value was transferrable as individuals moved around firms. That value has evaporated in "zero-data-retention" contexts where not only do the employees not gain the knowledge, but the providers themselves cannot instill that knowledge in the model.


In this very simple model this knowledge must eventually show up in output somewhere, either more efficient or better output to have value.

If management is replacing employees with some undocumented knowledge that AI lacks that will affect output then that is bad management but not an inherent part of the AI problem.


It’s not a good analogy because the side effect of drilling is exhaustion, and the side effect of solving math problems is knowledge.

In the short term the side effect is exhaustion, in the long term you build your bodies muscles and physical capacity. Something similar happens with knowledge work.

In the story John Henry died at the end of the race

I've been mentally exhausted solving for distributed data complexity between various authenticated systems so I imagine a math expert would get exhausted on those problems. Just as I've built muscle exercising and getting fit by being paid to do physical labor in college. I think the analogy has some value.

People commonly get mentally exhausted from solving hard problems?

Another side effect of drilling is holes...

Same reason as always? The barrier for creative expression is also falling. You can spend your time re-inventing something that is mostly solved to eek out that extra 1% if you think you're Rockstar, but if you want to focus on the 99% of value, buy don't build.

[Edit: I strongly support and love folks building their own engines, too, for non-economic reasons, just suggesting the answer to the QP.]


I agree with you here, but I am also thinking of large studios who have the level of output that justifies having their own engine.

Many of those studios have still decided to use Unreal out of workflow convenience, ease of hiring, etc.

But will that out-of-the-box platform advantage continue into the age of AI? We’ll soon find out.


unless they change the rules...

Thankfully they didn't for SpaceX I don't see them doing it for the effective altruists here

> effective altruists

I thought they were transhumanist?


Respect! Good science

Shouldn’t have announced the alert. It will be subverted by the most willing to cheat and could have been used to terrify future test cheats by making an example of this crop of cheaters.

I mean, there’s literally everyone else with a phone to think of.

Honestly seems a price worth that society paying. If academic dishonesty is rampant in your youth, is that not a national emergency?

hopefully we just end up in a Her situation and the bots take the hype/doomer crowd with them

As a parent, it's clear: time to start cutting technology from children--social media, cell phones, tablets, AI, even internet--until we've returned to at least Millennial academic achievement levels.

An economy without any consumers doesn't work. If that becomes true, then the economy will shrink to the point that human labor and intellect will again compete with AI.

Isn't this what most tech companies are racing toward though? As a matter of fact, a ton of white-collar jobs are being relinquished because of the certainty that they'll soon be done by AI. When shown that DoorDash ordering often comes from an EXPENDABLE income, do you think that DoorDash C-suite aren't trying to figure out more ways to remove humans from the loop? Who will be able to afford DoorDash in 5 years if all we can find are jobs paying 50k (in the US) a year? Right now that's "someone else's problem". In 5 years, it could be "everyone's problem".

Or Elon is right and somehow we'll all just "be rich". I'm not sure where that money's going to come from - he certainly isn't going to just start handing it out.


> Isn't this what most tech companies are racing toward though?

No? A lot of them seem to want you to go earn a seven figure salary, come home and glue your eyeballs to their algorithm.


> he certainly isn't going to just start handing it out.

I mean, that's the ultimate power move. When nobody has anything, and you got some, and there's nobody to dictate you what to do with it, and you get to hand pick the winners and the losers.


I hear John D Rockefeller used to hand out pocket change to kids....

Powerful. I feel like this is emblematic of the economy as a whole since the 80s. Consolidation and outsourcing makes hyper-efficient but brittle businesses.

* Efficient

* Resilient

* Cheap

Pick 2

With the advent of individual computers/disks/networking equipment not breaking as much, we optimised for Efficient+Cheap software. This results in systems prone to cascading failures.

The most resilient systems I've worked (mostly telecom) on we built from crappy parts which broke all the time, and they sure weren't cheap.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: