HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | philsquared_'s commentslogin

This is as high risk as it comes... imagine a person bought a lemonade from you for $1 then later on you charged them $1500 because you saved their cc. That is all stripe sees.

You need to not charge the $1 at all first of all because technically that is a fraudulent transaction since the customer is expecting to pay $1500 not $1501. Stripes docs literally say this by the way... you can always run an auth but that isn't my recommendation...

You should be sending them payable invoices through stripes invoice system not manually charging a saved card. In this case you should have sent 3 $500 invoices.

Stripe is not wrong in this case. You made yourself look like a scammer.


Stripe is wrong in this case. They'd only be right to leave you banned if you are a scammer. If you're not a scammer but just look like one, you should be able to get your ban overturned.

We still don’t know what OP’s business actually is. From the description, it sounds very similar to activities like an escort business.

I’m not saying that’s what OP does, but $1 + $1500 and being super vague about the commercial activity doesn’t help.

If OP wasn’t fully transparent and messaged stripe support explaining their business as “we connect homeowners with pre booked appointments” to Stripe then yeah, anyone who works in the field would’ve closed as unsupported business.


Isn't it in the first line? "Pre-booked appointments with homeowners, sold to local contractors" is appointment setting for home-improvement contractors: you line up a homeowner who wants a roofer, HVAC tech, etc., and the contractor pays per appointment that actually happens. That's a common, boring industry.

It did put a smile on my face, realizing how easy it is to miscommunicate. I never would have imagined someone hearing that and thinking "Ah, escort service."


"Indistinguishable from scammer without manual intervention" isn't really scalable. After all, this is the first occurence, who's to say this isn't some accomplice's card and they're not going to scam the next 10 customers?

> "Indistinguishable from scammer without manual intervention" isn't really scalable.

Their fees on $1500 should be able to pay for a couple minutes of human verification, let alone what they make on future business.

> After all, this is the first occurence, who's to say this isn't some accomplice's card and they're not going to scam the next 10 customers?

You could say that about most businesses with recurring charges. Tripping this flag doesn't say much about whether there will be problems in the future. And if stripe just told them not to save card info for the future that would negate the red flag and put them on par with any new customer, there's absolutely no need to blacklist them.


With or without training they would have gotten eaten.


There is a difference between dying tomorrow and dying in 5 years.


Why?


The golden age of SO was when all the important questions that have accumulated over decades were getting asked and answered. SO stabilized once that backlog got finished, and then started dying once people moved to github issues for project-specific questions. Chatgpt just replaced the last remaining type of questions ("plz do my work for me"), which arguably shouldn't have been getting asked in the first place.


The peak number of questions was in 2013, and they had roughly zero growth between 2013 & 2016. They were in decline long before LLMs were on the scene.


Bonus points put cryptocurrency private key on their server as bounty.


It's risk assessment, nothing more. Some weighed the risk high and paused their site. Nothing wrong with that and not hysteria or FUD.


I think the article is suggesting that a sober risk assessment was not done by most folks period, not that they merely perceived the risk differently.


You've got under 5 minutes to decide whether or not a widely reported critical security vulnerability actively being exploited in the while is severe enough to warrant taking down your site or not. The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0, and the upside is that you don't get shrekd

No security expert can or should work that fast. Its a completely reasonable thing to do given the hyperbolic reporting just in case it turns out to be true. Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world


> The downside for taking down your site is approximately 0

> Some websites being down for a few hours doesn't end the world

Many governmental websites are still down and they say might stay down for days or weeks. Some are not directly related to PHP, but auth doesn't work due to firewall hardening or similar. There definitely is a non-zero downside.


Agreed. This is all lazy chair hindsight talk, maybe by those not affected by it. In the moment you act on the imperfect information you have available and you use the safe than sorry rule. And to demand perfect information is also a fallacy, it doesn’t exist until after the fact.


I hear you, but also I'm not so sure. I remember Log4j, heartbleed, etc. and they were just as serious, but I don't recall people just going dark immediately. Scripts to validate whether or not you had exposure were built, people ran them, and if you did have exposure you started checking to see whether or not it was exploited. This timeline for this seems wildly different to me.


Because it’s not the same type. There was no actual info until the patch dropped, with some people in the know , which made it dangerous to leave your site up. The stopgaps were wild guesses. The multi-upload mitigation wouldn’t have worked.

There was no check that could be trusted to be the check to mitigate it. So that left the scenario that we went through.


Presumably the lack of sober risk assessment was on the part of the hyperbolic reporters.


There wasn't any info on the exploits beyond hearsay and the claim that they're very serious, so the risk assessment, sober or not, boils down to "do I trust the PHP people when they claim this is very serious"


Of of course, an excuse to email a user base to say "sorry we're offline for xyz", from a company I haven’t dealt with in 7 years...


I disagree... while those are definitely better art-wise, they are not better marketing-wise. I imagine this is why the ai one won because the others do nothing to actually sell the fair.


No fucking way, that rooster is awesome.

The winner makes me want to avoid the slopfair at all costs.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: