> If you haven't got two hours but at least have half an hour, some Qwen agents comparing many YouTube transcripts to the film script have suggested to me that the summary-type video essay about Threads by the YouTube creator Pugsr is the summary-type video essay that most preserves the thematic content and chronological ordering of the events depicted in Threads, which I canaried by skimming the transcript now and endorse.
I, on the other hand, greatly appreciate the transparency given here. I think its a bit unnecessary if it was going to lead to a personal endorsement anyway though
DeepSeek has never once hesitated in helping me figure out Proton issues, and so far has never failed to figure it out. It's also never cost more than about a nickel or so to solve the issue, at API pricing
The tracking is normalized, and they're going to grow up to be adults that both tolerate and impose oppressive surveillance that we couldn't even imagine today.
I don't have any data to back it up, but my impression it is mostly young people that are aware and opposed to Flock et al.
I think people can understand the nuance and tradeoffs between your parents knowing your locations, Big Tech tracking you to profit off your data, and companies who's raison d'etre is to sell your data to law enforcement.
Surveillance is already normalized and mostly unavoidable, but I believe tolerance for abuse of the data is higher than you think.
I do agree that surveillance in the future will be advanced. I try to imagine what Meta and Google could do with all of our data from the past 20 years with all of the compute they are building.
They are opposed to Flock, while at the same time they are constantly reporting their location to each other and monitoring where everyone they know is. Which is logically consistent: they're not ok with tracking being done to them, but they're ok with doing the tracking and opting in to being tracked.
Of course, with pervasive tracking being normalized, and the apps doing this being subject to law enforcement and the government, it kind of ends up as the same thing.
(Whether parents have access to this voluntary tracking, I don't know. My kid uses it with his friends, but I've never wanted to track him. Seems creepy and distrusting. Sure, he lies to me about some things, but I have a pretty good idea of what is and isn't a lie. Feel free to disbelieve me.)
I don't think it i s the same thing. I don't like pervasive tracking either, but it is very different from for police to subpoena google to get my data, than it is for flock to directly give law enforcement my location.
I use Find My friends on my iphone, I trust them enough they can know my location and I trust Apple enough to carry that data (I realize this is implying "nothing to hide", but I also consent to giving Apple my location). I get that it seem creepy, but its also a cool new technology if you can get over how creepy it seems. Not trying to sell you one, but give you another perspective.
I'm not a parent, but when I was teen my parents monitored me as much as they could. Personally, I think location tracking is less of an issue than parental surveillance of internet browsing. I do think if parents are going to track their kid's location, they should let their kid track the parents, too.
> I do agree that surveillance in the future will be advanced. I try to imagine what Meta and Google could do with all of our data from the past 20 years with all of the compute they are building.
Right it's not even a question of new data-- a mountain of historical privacy leaks were benign because it was a needle in a haystack. In the future everyone will be electronically stalked by a fleet of AI private detectives. To limit the damage we must substantially restrict the collection and retention of personal information.
They wouldn't even need to stalk us. I imagine they are training individualized models based on our individualized data, then use those models to A/B test the potential for advertisements or other propaganda, but they are probably already doing that. I wish my brain was big enough to know what they could be up to.
I think the issue isn't the collection, or retention (although there should still be data retention laws to protect against the liability of holding that data), but the ways the data is shared or used by third-parties. If businesses were no longer able to be shared or sold to 3rd parties, or be used for advertisements, the remainder of issues are largely ideological.
I mean, it's pretty clear it's not going anywhere or getting any less oppressive. At a certain point, attempting to subvert these makes you stick out even more.
It's not just you. I am deeply saddened that there will no longer be any true wilderness anymore. If I stumble across someone on a work call or prompting their agents 30 miles from the trailhead in the Sierra I think I will go mad.
Technological changes are always ecological, never purely optional. They change expectations, mores, etc.
You are free to feel sadness however you want, but please don’t talk on behalf of others?
For me, PERSONALLY, I love having connectivity just for the peace of mind. And no, I didn’t carry work laptop on vacation. After a day outdoor, I loved to be able to retreat to a corner for online activities at night. I don’t want to stare at the dark night the whole night, every night.
You said others would drive you mad if they used a phone in the wild. What??!?!?!
You are also sad that .... spinning the wheel ... the optionality exists.
It's optional. You don't have to use that option. But nooo that's not acceptable. You want the option to not exist at all for you and everyone. Otherwise, you will continue being "deeply saddened" ??!?!?
Being bothered by the behavior of other people is not speaking for them.
Optionality is never truly optionality when it comes to technology. I would think that people on Hacker News would understand this, even if they disagree with my opinion on this specific issue.
You might want to consider reflecting more on how technology changes the world far beyond personal choices.
Behaviors that were opt-in become opt-out. Behaviors that were opt-out become mandatory.
Think about how cell phones or social media changed social etiquette. Even if you opt out of those things personally, you're still living with the changes.
Admittedly this won't have an effect so widespread, but for those of us who spend a lot of time out in the mountains, deserts and forests where there is no service, I'm certain we'll see an effect.
I'm not sad because some guy somewhere will check his Slack messages on a hike. I'm sad because of how this will change the world.
I use Kagi and have considered moving to Fastmail.
Aside from the obvious larger issues with Gmail (privacy, trusting that Google won't just deactivate your account, etc), is there anything in the day-to-day usage of Fastmail that you find to be an improvement over Gmail, in the same way that Kagi is an improvement over Google search?
- When someone in your contacts sends you an ical attachment with an invitation, it goes to the fastmail calendar (as not-yet-accepted, of course), if enabled in the settings. The calendar can also be accessed via dav, so I use davx5 to integrate it into grapheneos' calendar.
- JMAP (which has stable mail ids--as opposed to IMAP which does NOT guarantee that the ids of the mails will be the same on the next connect! That's why I went to fastmail in the first place: attempted massive two-way sync corruption because IMAP just doesn't guarantee what I thought)
I've been using Fastmail for a few years with my own domain, and it's great. I can't speak to Gmail and if they have this feature, but I use custom aliases with any company or service I do business with (for example, I'll do southwestairlines112026@[domain].net). When the company is hacked and my email address is leaked, or if the company decides to not respect the "Unsubscribe" button, I disable that alias and force it to do a bounce back. This is a feature I only recently discovered and love it.
One thing i like with fastmail is the masked emails & its integration with 1password. It's really nice to have a separate masked email per account, and with 1password browser extension generating them when signing up is trivially easy.
This massively improves your security.
You can keep the actual email that you use to log into fastmail completely secret and never use it anywhere which makes it harder for people to attack your fastmail account.
One thing that stands out is IMAP access. While the fastmail web application is good, it also works great with thunderbird. Gmail on the other hand seems to apply some heavy throttling to IMAP access - folder operations, moving items, and calendar updates are much slower with thunderbird + gmail than thunderbird + fastmail.
I don't feel like I'm a huge email user, but for me the privacy and lack of trust with Google was enough. Losing access to an email account at the whim of some Google algorithm, with nobody to contact about it is just a problem I don't need.
This comment makes it seem as if all these other countries were just standing around peacefully and Iran decided to attack them for no reason. The majority of those countries host US bases, many of which were used to stage attacks on Iran, and all of which are fair targets in a war started by the US (and Israel). It's also extremely puzzling, to say the least, why you would say that "perhaps" their attacks on Israel could be considered defensive, when Israel is one of the two that started this last war.
Exactly. France also has very few migrants from the countries 'Iran attacked': they're largely from North African and Francophone African countries. A lot of inconsistencies and half facts in that comment.
reply