HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | peterm4's commentslogin

Echoing sibling comments to add that I know for a fact that archaeologists get rather upset about being mistaken for palaeontologists.


There's a fair bit of overlap and people who work in both, but yes, they're distinct specialties. I wouldn't say upset though, except in the sense that grocery store clerks are upset by "if it doesn't scan it's free" jokes.


Archeologist: I am currently working at an archeological dig in Egypt.

Nobody: Were there a lot of dinosaurs in Egypt?


Presumably this sort of thing was rampant pre-internet? News outlets would _have_ to receive embargoed information so that they could publish papers on time. I believe government budgets are a good example of this happening. I think the weird shift was when online journalism started, and live reactions became the norm, no?


Or you could wait a day or two to write about it, but with initial reactions etc. added. 24-hour new cycle came into view in 80s I think?


Ya, 24 hour cable news in the late 80s.

Hype and views die off very quickly, hence advertising money has disappeared by the next day most of the time.


No, embargoed news is super common. Almost every single product announcement goes through that. Critics watch movies early, companies have access to LLM model improvements early, car manufacturers send production models early… it happens everywhere all the time.


Human rights are routinely revoked from those that impede on the rights of others. This is the premise that underpins prisons. Privacy being a human right still holds true.


From which I conclude that prisons are wrong, but also if I don't like someone I can revoke his rights and push him downstairs.


What is the morally correct approach to dealing with murderers?


In principle I’d agree usually, but I think this specific case, it’s reasonable to highlight that the “experts get value” argument doesn’t really add much to the discourse anymore. We know this and you just need to look at what’s happening with LLMs in maths to see it’s true. It doesn’t add anything to the verification point however.


While this may be a common understanding in this community, it's worth repeating so that this community can tell everyone else, as I don't think most people understand this currently.


But also, it is a post that is self promoting their personal twitter page; there should be a high threshold of doing this, and regurgitating some trite analogy should fall below the bar.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: