HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | peteforde's commentslogin


That's funny, I was going to suggest Bunnie's book, but this is the new edition of that book (updated by Naomi Wu). Thanks for the link!

Good to read some news about Naomi.

Agreed.

I went ahead and placed an order, since it seemed the least I could do.


The instructor is Neil Gershenfeld. He is a brilliant dude. https://ng.cba.mit.edu/

I'd love to be able to audit at least parts of this.



So he met with Epstein... and?

The mass hysteria around the "Epstein files" is largely justified given how widespread abuse was, but many people are really trying to invoke guilt by association / guilt by proxy even when there is nothing particularly revolting about specific individuals mentioned in those files.

I would have thought HN would be more sensible in this discussion. Alas, newly-created throwaway accounts are already here trying to derail the discussion.


People who just have a superficial knowledge of what Epstein did are the quickest to jump on guilt by association.

You have to remember: Epstein was always looking to expand his network and reaching out to any person of interest he could find. The fact that someone replied to his overture in and of iteself doesn't mean anything. He was like a fisherman, always casting lines into the water to see what bites. Once he got to know you better, he'd judge your value to him and your propensity to do illegal/immoral stuff and then blackmail you if you went along.


I've been using Cursor for a few years now, and while I'm well aware that it's more expensive, from a UX perspective I am 95% happy. There's still a few things like not being able to move conversations between folders or computers, but big picture, a lot to love. It's just a really coherent dev experience.

When I read what folks write about CC and TUIs it all sounds... really, really awful and I kind of don't get why any wouldn't want to use Cursor. I'm posting this to see if anyone wants to explain how/why I might want to ditch Cursor and go all in on Claude or Codex or Pi or anything else. I'm open to being convinced!

Mostly, I just want to understand. My sense of CC is that it's great for folks who are looking to spend lots of money having 4 agents one-shot an entire application from a single prompt so that they can pick their favourite when they wake up. Is that an absurd perspective? If so, tell me how you use it.

I'm someone working on fairly significant but personal projects; I have a very clear picture in my head about what I'd like to get so I tend to write extremely dense, detail-filled prompts and go through a multi-revision planning phase before kicking off agent mode on a feature. The apps I build tend to be the result of several dozen or several hundred features developed mostly serially, and I am always the bottleneck because of that whole "knowing what I want" thing.

So, that's my usage pattern. Should I be using Claude (or Pi)?


> The apps I build tend to be the result of several dozen or several hundred features developed mostly serially, and I am always the bottleneck because of that whole "knowing what I want" thing.

This is probably where the disconnect is - the TUI workflow only really clicked when I started working across multiple worktrees at the same time.

It’s not all or nothing. You can still be fully in the loop, read all the code and steer each session towards the outcomes you want. You’re just doing it across multiple branches at the same time and imo it’s easier to do that through the TUI.


How do you stay effective when working across multiple worktrees at the same time? That is, how do you keep context in your head?

Then when it's all over, how do you evaluate which one to keep?


This is indeed a challenge and there is a practical limit to how many you can manage at once. It really depends on what I’m working on, for a sufficiently large enough project there are lots of independent tasks that can be delivered in isolation and so it’s rarely a case of babysitting all of them in realtime.

I tend to have one session that I’m actively focused on as my primary session, everything else I come back to every ~5-10 minutes to nudge them along while I’m waiting on the ‘main thread’. If my core task demands more of my time to think then I check less often.

The important thing is to find what works for you. If Cursor is giving you enough productivity then that’s awesome, carry on with it! I would recommend trying out other workflows, weighing up the pros/cons yourself and ultimately find what works for you. TUI-driven development isn’t for everyone in the same way not everyone likes to use vim and that’s okay.


I appreciate your conclusions, and frankly, you're probably right.

I'm still quite curious how folks evaluate between four completely separately but presumably functionally similar outputs and conclude that work tree 2 is the winner.


I finally got around to firing up the Neurosity Crown I bought some years ago to experiment with BCI. Lights are on, but nobody is home; it knows the position of my head, but no actual EEG data is coming into the system.

Multiple attempts to contact any kind of support have gone unanswered, and according to Reddit the founders appear to have quietly disappeared, which pisses me off more than a little bit. This thing was not cheap.


Guy is currently working as a engineer at 1X so if anyone works there and can ping him, that will be useful

That would be a pretty excellent outcome. Thanks for posting.

That sounds like the perfect use case for Reverse Engineer Anything, and it's totally justified..

I certainly wouldn't be opposed! But in this case, I strongly suspect that there's something electronically wrong with my unit.

I'm quite confident that other people are happily using theirs. It's just that mine doesn't work.


I'm really sorry to hear that you're going through this. Any company would be lucky to have you on their team.

My strong suggestion to you: pivot to hardware. I still use Ruby but most of my development efforts are ESP32-P4 and RP2350-based these days.

Learning CAD and mastering various additive and subtractive fabrication techniques, getting PCBs made to make ideas real... it's been a roller coaster but LLMs are remarkably good as engineering mentors these days.

And yes, as several others have already said, this might be the time to learn woodworking and/or video production skills.

You'll find that you still need your programming brain, instincts and intuitions. You just deploy them in a different way in support of creating a device instead of an experience [or yet another CRUD form].


AI is coming there soon. May be faster than one can learn it.


I understand why you think that this is a valid point in this context, but 95% of what's hard about creating a thing you can hold in your hands does not happen in KiCAD.

It might be 98%.


Ryan is a big deal in the Ruby community. He's not imagining his accomplishments and not long ago it's reasonable to say there would have been several companies fighting for the opportunity to have him on their team.


> He's not imagining his accomplishments

I didn't suggest that.


I don't need your permission to say words.


Alright enjoy the phantom arguments


I actually have a fairly simple answer to that: if it doesn't come up in the list of LLMs that Cursor supports, it effectively doesn't exist.

I'm well aware that there's nearly infinite opportunities to yak shave "perfect" OpenRouter setups and some people appear to enjoy bouncing from IDE to IDE as though change costs aren't a thing, but I discovered that I genuinely like Cursor and at least right now it's insanely subsidized by Auto clearly defaulting to whatever Grok's most powerful model is.

I dropped my $200/month subscription to $20/month and stick to Auto for all but really important Plan tasks, and I have basically zero chance of using up my monthly credits even using it 6-10 hours some days.


> I actually have a fairly simple answer to that: if it doesn't come up in the list of LLMs that Cursor supports, it effectively doesn't exist.

You make Cursor sound like one thousand times more important than it is. It's a product in deep water.


It's been freaking amazing for me. I genuinely love it.


No, that's not what happened in this thread at all.

There's a recurring pattern on HN where any time someone talks about knocking dozens of personal projects off their list - things that almost certainly would never have actually been addressed in the finite span of a normal life, the way things go - and you AI doomers show up and demand receipts as though that's a total reasonable and definitely not obnoxious request.

It's like if you tell someone that you love your partner and they demand to sit in the cuck chair or else you're obviously lying. I keep hoping people will move past this "prove that you're actually productive" reflex, but it just keeps happening in basically every AI thread.

In reality there are many reasons not to list out projects that you've worked on with LLMs, and while "none of your damn business" is always going to be at the top, the simple truth is that I want my products and projects to be judged by what they do and how well they work, not by how they were made.


> "There's a recurring pattern on HN where any time someone talks about knocking dozens of personal projects off their list"

Nobody was talking about that very believable use case. What they specifically said was "enterprise scale projects". Enterprise scale means lots of users, decades of backwards compatibility, regulation compliance, logging and auditing, reporting, role based access control and permissions, integration with other enterprise systems, etc. etc.

> "you AI doomers show up and demand receipts as though that's a total reasonable and"

Asking what large scale programs they have built is not "dooming". It's also not demanding. It's also not unreasonable.

> "definitely not obnoxious request".

Saying that it's "unreasonable and obnoxious" to ask people to justify their claims is where the likes of Theranos and Nikola electric truck company are hiding. If they don't want to talk about their stuff, they could have not commented. Since they commented it's reasonable to ask them about what they said.


> What they specifically said was "enterprise scale projects". Enterprise scale means lots of users, decades of backwards compatibility, regulation compliance, logging and auditing, reporting, role based access control and permissions, integration with other enterprise systems, etc. etc.

Do you really think that's what they meant?


Yes I think that what they wrote is what they meant, and unless you want to ignore their words and hallucinate what they were thinking, so should you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterprise_software


It's extremely obvious to everyone else here that they were not talking about literal enterprise software. Perhaps they could have chosen different terminology, but the fact that you've clearly latched on to this relatively minor word choice as some kind of smoking gun says infinitely more about your perspective and motivations than it does about whether some guy is building big-to-him projects or Enterprise Projects.

Tell me: when someone says that the shit hit the fan, do you furiously start looking around for actual shit?


1) someone makes unbelievable claim, someone else questions it.

2) You jump in: "how dare you not accept this obviously-true claim at face value, why are you AI doomers always insinuating that these claims are false and demanding evidence?!".

3) I comment taking the claim at face value.

4) You jump in: "idiot, how stupid are you to take the claim at face value, it's extremely obvious to everyone here that it's not meant literally".

Well if we all agree it's completely unbeleivable if taken literally, can we now have your permission to ask about the reality behind the statement? "if 'enterprise scale' is not intended to mean 'enterprise scale', what scale is the person actually talking about?


I didn't call you an idiot. And yet...

Absolutely nothing you're saying is in good faith. You're just arguing for the sake of arguing.

So, no: you don't have my permission. You haven't earned it.


> "Absolutely nothing you're saying is in good faith. You're just arguing for the sake of arguing."

And your dragging the conversation off topic, turning it into personal attacks, redefining what words mean, refusing to address the point, flip-flopping your position 180 degrees, refusing to acknowledge that you did that, turning it personal again, has all been good faith positive contribution, has it?


> I can do things it took teams years to build as a hobby project over a weekend.

That is a pretty strong statement. And without even anecdotal evidence, it becomes very weak.


Nobody owes you evidence.


You misread a comment so badly that you ended up responding to a completely different and made up comment. Your unwillingness to admit that you were wrong is way worse than whatever reflex you are ranting about.


>I want my products and projects to be judged by what they do and how well they work

Hence the question "what's the most impressive and useful thing you have made"

But no one really has any examples. Just half baked slop they never got over the finish line.


Ladies and gentlemen, the cuck chair is going to be occupied tonight!


Is this an announcement that you will vibecode tonight?


I know this will not be a popular take, but surely I am not the only one who is super tired of endless control surfaces for the same FM and Karplus-Strong algos.

I'm a weirdo, but I love the sound of acoustic and/or sampled instruments - especially drums - over the metallic plonks that supposedly sound like "flute" any day of the week.

Don't get me wrong: the M-VAVE is looking like the Flipper Zero of music hacking, and the price is a steal. But at the end of the day, these sounds only really work for certain genres of music and even then there's only so many wavetable shapes before the same-ness has to set in.


i havent played with the unofficial firmwares yet but i thought i saw that some of them have added sampling capabilities... wouldnt that make this exactly the kind of thing youd want? (assuming reasonable sample rates durations are possible on this hardware)


Sort of, but mostly not really...

On a small device like the M-VAVE, "sampling" usually means that you take (or record) an audio sample and perhaps if you're lucky, algorithmically pitch it up/down so that you can play it on the keyboard.

There's nothing wrong/bad about that, but when I talk about sampling, I'm talking about usually large libraries of professionally captured sounds. These are often the product of teams of specialists who rent a professional studio and use an array of high-end mics to capture every sound an instrument makes in an intimidating number of ways.

Indeed, they often capture multiple takes of each sound so that if you play them quickly, they don't sound like they are repeating.

Really what I'm getting at is the difference between recording a high-end snare or cymbal at Abbey Road with a fancy mic and putting white noise through an ADSR and a voltage controlled filter. Wildly different strokes for different folks.


I'm not saying that you've clearly never built and shipped a hardware device as a small team in North America; maybe you have, and maybe that's what you do all day.

However, I have noticed that the only people who look at a product like Chompi and think "overpriced" are people who have never built and shipped a hardware device. Perhaps you'll be the one to prove me wrong.

I'm not saying that Chompi wasn't expensive, or that you couldn't get a mass-produced device like a Roland SP-404 for less on Reverb. I am saying that that is not a fair comparison, however.


Oh, I never have. I'm speaking truly as a consumer. I do not doubt your numbers.

But -- your response really gives me a "what were they thinking?" vibe. Like, I have multiple raspberry pis and a flipper zero etc.

And just coming from a consumer of stuff like this POV -- I could MAYBE go as high as 300-350, and that's really pushing it.


I don't understand the second line/paragraph of your reply. Could you please clarify?


I suppose my thinking was that they were going to try to sell this to -- maybe not even the general public -- but to someone like me, pretty well versed in tech but not ultra deep in the game, that price point is still waaaay too high.

Perhaps I'm missing it and it's almost a sort of, no really we're just building this for ourselves?


Okay, I think I understand. More importantly, I want to say that I don't think you're trying to be jerky about this, though I was initially sort of triggered (admittedly) because you see this sort of sentiment a lot and it hits close to home.

So, the main thing that many/most people do not remotely understand is how incredibly difficult, time consuming and expensive it is to get hardware to the state where it can be sold to strangers. Even HN folks who on the average understand software well frequently just have no way to grasp how much R&D actually goes into even a very simple device. It's playing in hard mode from start to finish.

In a bigger company, there's entire departments whose job it is just to source components. For a small team like pre-CBA Chompi, all of the electronics, firmware, enclosure design, UX, documentation, not to mention the certifications and environmental certs and marketing and packaging and shipping logistics and returns and support and.... two people. I forgot lots of steps, but the number of people stays the same.

The reality is that a product like Chompi can't address a larger market like a product from Roland or Korg can, and everything costs more at smaller scale, and yes, they were doing a lot of the work in the USA so this is directly comparable to the ongoing arguments around categories like fast fashion and how if you wanted to buy a high quality T-shirt made in the USA without any branding it should cost about 5x more than most people think that they should have to pay.

Basically, you want to pay an Ikea price for a limited edition shelf made by a single woodworker. This translates quite literally to stating that you wish Chompi would give you a product that only breaks even at $600 when they sell thousands for $300 because you've convinced yourself that that's what a Chompi should be worth. It doesn't make you bad, it just means your working from a different set of expectations which don't line up with the economics of Chompi. The snarky response is to tell you to just go to Ikea like the other people who don't really care what they are buying but just need a shelf that isn't terrible.

Every year in May the Superbooth festival and trade show happens in Berlin. Almost everyone you meet there is either making or has made gear, so it's an incredibly cathartic opportunity to collectively process shared trauma.

Anyhow, I'm going to leave you with a strong suggestion that you check out this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2B-AmJUQ1m0

It's a masterclass in empathetic communication around this stuff.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: