HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | petcat's commentslogin

nobody is "relying" on anything. The people who are going to buy it are going to buy it regardless.

I don't think there is anything wrong with people being empowered to build dumb things, even lots of dumb things. Especially if we believe that there will be a market correction that will force the good things to rise to the top, and everything else to go away.

I don't disagree, but I think we got the ordering wrong. This step should've come later in its evolution.

You're still left with a filtering problem. App review, Job applications, games on steam - any huge increase in volume means it's harder to find the good stuff now.

I think friction to distribution is an interesting thing in this. Pretty unbaked thought that isn't really saying anything, so you'll forgive me: When we were getting deviantART off the ground, folks wanted the user growth to speed up, so we reduced the amount of work to upload things. Then, the quality took a dive and it became too difficult to moderate with the tools that we had, so we increased the friction a bit, over the time I worked on it, the amount and type of friction increased and decreased as we tired to dial in the right amount of growth and quality. It was also interesting what friction filtered out what type of people... add 6 screens you have to click through with drop downs etc, lazy people drop off but creative people get fatigued, add 3 screens but require a minimum of a 200 word description, creative people love it and copy/paste artists drop off, etc. The internet itself has had various versions of this in different aspects of it. I think that is also true in reverse, things can sustain mediocrity through friction. I'm sure there are loads of interesting examples of this all over! Just a thought. :)

Wow, I remember spending so much time on dA throughout the 2000s! I use it less now because I take fewer photos generally, but it still brings back a flood of good memories and still holds the bulk of my portfolio, which has now spilled somewhat over to Flickr. That's interesting to think about: I don't really remember what the upload experience was back then... I think probably a file-picker, one or two screens and then bam it was up. At my moderate volume, any friction would indeed have been a turn-off and a source of fatigue. It was a fun little friendly community to spend time in, and a great source of inspiration looking at all the crazy cool stuff people had created; I hope it still is. Thanks for your work!

> Especially if we believe that there will be a market correction that will force the good things to rise to the top, and everything else to go away.

Do we believe that, truly?


Yeah the mobile app is excellent

This should also indicate which EUDI wallets will require Google or Apple device attestation. My guess is all of them.

For all the talk about digital sovereignty, EU still builds the fundamental element of EU citizenship, the digital ID, on American companies. Baffling.


Hmm... AFAIR Duch one (https://github.com/MinBZK/nl-wallet/) will not force it and they are actively working on handling it.

What's more - you won't be limited to using your national wallet - you would be able to use whichever implementation works for you (so, for example Duch one).

Alas: yes, UE should push harder to avoid google/apple :/


But it was a problem that peered from long ago, it was implicit in the plans (cpr. the "digital euro"), and if you do not secure what you need for your plans doubts are legitimately cast about you.

Edit: sorry, there is a possibility there is a case of bad communication. A comment nearby (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50486125) mentions the open specs could allow for the non-requirement of Google, Apple and the likes. I may have leant on thinking that the situation could be similar to that of age verification - for which the EU built open software for ZKP, but it is said to require Google or Apple or the likes.


> more - you won't be limited to using your national wallet - you would be able to use whichever implementation works for you

Unfortunately not true. You can verify other nations IDs but you can only bind your ID to the eID wallet of the nation you are a citizen of.


Looks like it's an open spec so can create a wallet for any OS https://eudi.dev/latest/main/

I doubt that will ever matter. There are niche alternatives to lots of American tech. But that isn't what the "digital sovereignty" push is about. It's about not building fundamental services on American Big Tech in the first place.

But it's obvious that nobody really cares about it after all. For instance, Germany's own official EUDI wallet for Android explicitly requires Google Play Integrity

https://bmi.usercontent.opencode.de/eudi-wallet/wallet-devel...


You are linking to version 0.14.0 of the documentation. The latest version is 0.19.0. The release notes of 0.15.0 mention that they dropped the Play Integrity dependency

Good news

> But it's obvious that nobody really cares about it after all.

That's not remotely obvious.

The push for digital sovereignty is only a few months old. Governments work on timescales of years—or even decades.

It's certainly true that it would be good if they could be a bit more responsive, particularly in this fast-paced digital age. But demanding them to be doing that already, today, is just not living in the real world.


Okay scratch my doubtfulness from the other comment, of course you're right what was I even thinking. Man I really hate that.

The play integrity dependency was removed in version 0.15.0

Its an open spefication but the identity issuers (your country) locks it down so only their own wallet can be used for their countries ID

Does one exist which does not require integration with Apple, Google, or Microsoft services?

The German teams AMA said it doesn't. Though for legal reasons it'll need to be certified for every OS.

Polish one already have app that de facto works as ID and uses independent authentication than Google's/Apples (using either banks or govt site for it)

Yet it mandates that you have access to Google Play for Android or App Store for iOS and use an OS that wasn't modified or replaced. They also specifically tell you it shouldn't be run if your device is rooted or you have an unlocked bootloader

https://www.gov.pl/attachment/735d96d3-8d85-492c-8d00-0a80c2...


Yeah but that's easier to decouple than using google login

Can you run google play store without Google login?

Any talks about physical sovereignty? Why do EU let its auto industry struggle against Chinese EVs? What about electronic products? Why can Europe wean off foreign energy such as from US or Middle East or Russia?

> Why do EU let its auto industry struggle against Chinese EVs? What about electronic products? Why can Europe wean off foreign energy such as from US or Middle East or Russia?

Your two goals are fundamentally at odds with each other: cheap Chinese solar panels and EVs are the only realistic route to energy independence.

That many of the EU car manufacturers bet hard against the EV transition, is pretty much a bed of their own making.


EU car industry languished in safety too long, focusing on how to bump the price of cars up and up while having them less and less reliable.

It can't survive honest competition, let alone one that also benefits from lower costs


You are saying the Chinese EVs which came into being by corporate espionage and which are government subsidised to exactly destroy EU car production is honest competition?

Why should people be forced to only choose from a limited amount of suppliers?

> Any talks about physical sovereignty?

You mean about the 3.5 wars Europe is directly involved in? Up from 2 three years ago.

Ukraine - Russia

Russia - Black Sea EU member states (esp. Bulgaria, but also Greece)

Turkey - Greece

Russia - Georgia (kind of)


That way you can list pretty much any combination of countries around the world.

> Turkey - Greece

How’s that a war?


See Cyprus. Plus there was a coast guard confrontation this year with shots fired.

That’s a bit far from a hot war like Ukraine or Iran.

Cyprus’ ongoing occupation since the 1974 invasion is, of course, another thing (habitually not raised in either the UN or the EU), though Cyprus is a sovereign state with Greece as only an inert guarantor nation.


Why should China buy our chips / other 1000 exports if we refuse to buy their cars?

I have bad news for you, China doesn't import much these days, except for raw resources.

So your being baffled relies solely on your guess being correct? It kinda feels like a good idea to wait until we know for sure.

I mean I wouldn't really be surprised if you were right, but I also want to give them the benefit of the doubt for now.


I looked at the source code for Germany's Android EUDI wallet and confirmed my suspicion that it will require Google. So I have very little doubt about any of the others too.

https://bmi.usercontent.opencode.de/eudi-wallet/wallet-devel...

Edit: apparently the requirement was dropped in a later version


Can we just say no I do not want to use the digital identification and continue our lives as before?

You can...

It will have to be seen. E.g. try to travel in some countries without carrying electronic payment systems.

Imagine trying to travel in some countries with electronic payment system ;) (I mean Germany for example :P)

Lots of tech people thought they could build alternative platforms to things like Reddit or Twitter. Mostly because the tech stack is relatively straightforward and the mechanics are proven and easy to implement. But none of that is ever the problem. The enormous amounts of moderation required to make a community even remotely useful is a burden that most people will never be able to undertake. The worst content, the most toxic users, bots bots bots. It's basically a cesspool that nobody in their right mind would get into at this point.

Less than moderation, my biggest problem with e.g. Reddit is that Reddit isn't one destination, it's a million. I go to Reddit for a specific set of sub-reddits much more than the site itself. Each one of those has its own separate network effect.

The biggest shot Lemmy has is that Reddit is taking every possible step to drive users away - just today I had to install another block rule because I started getting obtrusive overlays to drive me to the mobile app even when browsing it logged in on my desktop.

But even then, the fact that so many of us are willing to go to increasingly extreme lengths to keep using Reddit for various subreddits even as the site gets worse and worse shows just how sticky the network effect of the existing communities is.

I've been in some of them for nearly two decades, and finding a community with the same topic elsewhere won't reproduce the set of people.


Yeah, lemmy is alright but doesn't have a critical mass of users (and may never have that).

I suspect that Reddit is running into similar problems with a slowly dying user base. The reason I suspect this is because Reddit has slowly started to try and hijack the UX to force me into seeing and interacting with subreddits I don't want to see or interact with. The default UX is now "You might be interested in this because you viewed that".

I've noticed a number of formerly pretty active subreddits to be ghosts of their former selves. I've also noticed a ton of new subreddits pop up that appear to be just a mass of bots trying to hook in real users.

A big part of the Reddit problem is that reddit has made it as hard as possible to tell whose a bot. You end up noticing a bunch of 3 month old accounts swarming whenever certain topics come up but you can't dig into their history to see if this is what they always do.

All and all, it feels like the social internet is just dying. I feel like I'm getting more value by revisiting the old forums. (See ya'll at anandtech).


Unfortunately a lot of old forums are now dominated by a handful of cantankerous or mentally ill people. After all, one had to be a bit weird to hold on to forums as the rest of the world moved away. Other than them and their antics, the place might otherwise be a ghost town. Forums are also greying out, because younger people tend to be less interested in a site accessed from a web browser (which they might never use) instead of a dedicated app.

I tried to recommit myself to forums around 2020, and already then it was too late to find the healthy community I remembered from the early millennium.

When Reddit started going downhill for some travel-related hobbies I'm part of, the community's solution wasn't to go back to forums, it was to move to invite-only WhatsApp groups. WhatsApp sucks for discussion, but it's more familiar to the world now than a phpBB website.


The problem with whatsapp is that it's meta, and they have a generally sketchy smell to them.

its got around 50k active users retained for 3 years from a 200k peak. Thats pretty good retention and its enough to visit every day for its users.

Banning two thirds of their user base probably has something to do with it becoming a ghost town too.

> I go to Reddit for a specific set of sub-reddits

Same here. r/ProgrammingLanguages was great until about four or five years ago. Now the contributions guide is mostly about what you may not post and you almost need a lawyer to find out what is allowed, and the mods again have another opinion about this than what is written and just delete stuff. The result is that I didn't see an interesting post in month.


Could they be maliciously complying with the new (since 2023) Reddit rules for moderators? A lot of subreddits closed, and then Reddit replaced their moderator lists and reopened them (most of those subs are now shit). Maybe the one you mentioned is avoiding running afoul of the don't close your sub rule.

I don't know. But it is apparent that "the" moderator of r/ProgrammingLanguages has an agenda.

I am literally here now because reddit became so unbearably botted that I deleted my account in disgust.

I think it's a simpler problem: the general public these days uses the internet from phones, not computers with actual keyboards. Phones just discourage longform text and nuance, and encourage 180-character quips and video and image posts. Even if you had a well-moderated forum that kept trolls and bots at bay, the average quality of posts is going to be poor compared to a decade-plus ago. No one yet fully perceived that shift back when Reddit alternatives were first proposed.

Also an entire generation has now been raised ignorant of the concept of a FAQ, because commercial platforms like Reddit wanted people asking the same basic questions over and over again, it was good for engagement metrics. Try to moderate a forum today and close posts covered by a FAQ, and you'll just get young people calling you an overzealous moderator and leaving, because your perspective is unintelligible to them.


This exactly. It's always confusing to me when people realize that [current centralized platform] is bad, and their solution to that is [new centralized platform everybody moves to]. None of these systems can work.

As soon as they reach a size where they become actually interesting to use, they also reach a size where they become interesting targets for attackers.


Has anyone ever made a decentralised platform work?

Why couldn't a rotation of centralised platforms be the answer? If my hairdresser is shitty to me, I can go to another hairdresser. I don't have to invent a decentralised permissions hairdressing marketplace. Why doesn't it work that way with redditlikes?


it's like the thing the stack overflow team said about how devs think about cloning stack overflow and they imagine an SQL table for questions and answers and maybe a little CSS, and ignore everything else

I'm moderating r/Oberon for some months now and it is no effort at all. If there were bots, they didn't stand out in a negative way.

If there's hope, it's that Reddit/Twitter/etc now function as a quarantine or flypaper for the eternal September, the bots, the scammers, the slop, etc. And newer sites/networks can flourish at a smaller size because there's not enough profit in targeting them.

AI will bring the cost of ruining smaller communities way down.

Closed boards always have been and always will be the way to avoid this. Read only for non-users, and an approval chain for new users so if someone brings in a bad actor everyone they brought in can be banned in one go.

Ah so I see you're new to the Fediverse then? On Lemmy you can enjoy:

- People creating endless sportsball subs for a single team or even a single player

- Duplicate subs for the exact same thing across multiple instances, e.g. you might find two dozen Lewis Hamilton subs (forget the Lemmy name for them). And then duplicate that for ALL the topics...

- Endless subs in foreign languages because, why bother to specify your language for a sub if you're on a not-english-langiage instance?

- Getting shadow banned because your instance administrator and another instance administrator have beef or have political/religious/moral convictions or whatever and decided to de-federate, you know, just how telephone companies decide you aren't allowed to speak with someone THEY don't like...

- Endless, endless furries, especially trans/non-binary furry subs

- Breaking version changes every year or two, as in your (main) instance maybe literally being broken

- Struggling to share a link because maybe you'd open the upstream sub and not be signed in, maybe synced via your instance and you would

- checking that you are signed in on the right account to the right instance and that the instance itself is synced and on up to date version...

I checked out when I realised I had hit 1000 blocked subs and was trying to sync them across a dozen or so accounts to multiple different instances


Most of it is just part of the fediverse instance model. This couldn't happen on atproto... then again everyone who leaves Reddit for Lemmy in protest is both a redditor and easily pissed off, so technical solutions probably wouldn't save it.

> Endless, endless furries

Can I get a link?


What stops people creating subreddits that already exist on ATproto?

French schools K-12 and university do not have better education outcomes than New York state, despite having nearly double the taxes. 53% of New York State residents go to a SUNY university for free and the rest pay a maximum of $7,000 a year on average.

French education budget also accounts for teacher pensions. I don't think that's the case for NY. So it's somewhat apples and oranges.

New York state pays teacher pensions through the New York State Teacher Retirement System. About $8.5 billion a year, ~$4,000/mo per teacher on average. $7,000/mo+ with 30 years of teaching history. It's also protected under the NY State Constitution.

EU has much bigger brain drain problems to the US that will not be solved anytime soon. Even just recently Heart Aerospace announced that they were relocating completely to California after several years of warning the EU that the regulatory and economic environment was impossible to navigate for emerging technology companies.

https://www.heartaerospace.com/newsroom/mastering-the-shift-...

A month later they moved to USA

https://www.heartaerospace.com/newsroom/heart-aerospace-relo...


>As part of this transition and to better focus its resources, Heart has decided to close its operations in Sweden to enable a bigger scale up of the U.S based team.

This is morbid.


Crypto blockchains are useless for these kinds of transactions because in the real world people make mistakes, get scammed, or myriad other things that requires a transaction to be reversed.

No different to a bank transfer. You understand that they cannot be reversed either?

There's nothing technically requiring a bank transfer not to be reversed. I can appeal to my bank, legally, and to the receiving bank.

This happens all the time.


Suppose you transfer $1000 to me on Monday via ACH (the old thing - pardon my American terminology). If I'm lucky, I can wire that money out of my account, or pull it out in cash, on Wednesday. Maybe Thursday. During that time it's definitely possible you can get the banks to reverse this transfer.

If payment is instant, what that has to mean is that the funds are actually made available to me right away. If you transfer $1000 to me on Monday, and 10 minutes later I've drained my account of funds and disappeared, how can that be "reversed"? Is one of our banks going to just eat it?

If payment is "instant, but the funds are held for several days and can't be spent or transferred" then the payment isn't instant in any meaningful way.


There's a clear reason why they don't want to waste their time chasing other banks in recovering your $100 that you sent by mistake and instead warn you to check everything.

The point is they know a transfer cannot be reversed, especially when the money has been spent already.

Even a bank who sent out £130M [0] in error to multiple people still cannot recover all of it after 4 years.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/dec/30/santander-b...


Pix has a reversal mechanism precisely for errors, fraud, etc

Will be curious to see if this ends up requiring Google/Apple accounts and mobile device attestation in order to work.

Real-time Rail is for financial institutions to settle transactions not for direct consumer use.

> This new national payment system will transform day-to-day payments for Canadian businesses and consumers by enabling instant speed and settlement.

It does sound like it's for consumers as well


It will _eventually_ be exposed to consumers through their banks, but it is financial infrastructure for now.

This mostly is referencing ETF tranfers that are relevant to consumers - e.g. bill payments and employer pay deposits that currently take several days.

In the same way that PAD is for consumers as well.

if its like SEPA in europe then you dont need google or apple, its seperate network that you get access through your regular or digital bank

Of course, if you want to do it through your mobile then your bank can require attestation. No different from now.

The cars are actually a way to drive yourself around town. Yes they also contain batteries.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: