HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | pera's commentslogin

I thought Dropbear was pretty much the defacto SSH server for embedded applications, is OpenSSH+musl actually a common combination for these scenarios?

Well, OpenWrt is OpenSSH + musl.


We don’t know that dropbear isn’t vulnerable. The bug here is in musl and OpenSSH is just being a bro by working around it

I wouldn't say the bug is only in musl. Musl is probably the "worst" offender here (at least choose something other than "*"!), but the change in sshd was also a little suspect. i.e. the "let's find a user and take their salt (and hashing algorithm) and use it to compute and compare the hash to avoid timing attacks" change.

I haven't thought it through, but I suspect in an ideal world, sshd shouldn't have accepted the user password regardless of the outcome of crypt() if the user did not exist and it only pretended to go through the motions to avoid a timing attack.

Did look into their patch yesterday(?) which seemed to mitigate this issue which they (rightfully IMHO) consider caused by musl. But it seems their fix is to do a sanity check on the supposed hashed password char length, and thus still theoretically still allowing the possibility of those "!!!INVALID_PASSWORD!!!" suggestions to fall through....


Tried it, doesn't work.

Some use Dropbear, some use openssh.

This vulnerability clearly is not one that affects everyone like the PHP vulnerability did. But it's exposure is still significant and very easy to exploit. As easy as it gets.


Maybe because the picture you have in your mind is for the classic maze. There is a very famous AI course from UC Berkeley, CS 188, that uses Pac-Man with variable grid size to introduce Q-learning:

https://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs188/textbook/rl/mfl.html

(material: https://inst.eecs.berkeley.edu/~cs188/sp26/projects/proj1/)

I think that after seeing that layout, plus the fact that the prompt mentions game and neural network training, you would have answered that the most likely game was Pac-Man :)


Of course, Astra would have seen all of this, but I haven't. :)

I think this other submission from yesterday that visualised the examples was quite helpful:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50344861


Thank you for sharing that, it's a shame that the overhyped paper received this much attention while this one ended up burrowed beyond eyesight.

Thanks for sharing. I was also onboard the hype train ready to share this widely and get others onboard, but now I'll be sharing this article instead.

It is the combination of several facts what makes this unprecedented, junk rating being one of these


Alphabet was -12% yesterday and still in red today, can someone explain what's going on? Why is this happening now?


They had their earnings report yesterday. Same for Intel today.


I know but the earnings were not bad at all? It's confusing


Investors drop stock after report when earning didn't reach predicted level, but confusing part is that sometimes the results are exactly as predicted (and in theory priced in) but some investors are still disappointed and start the sell-off.


Good and bad are relative. If I bought stock with the expectation that Google would make $100B in profit and they "only" made $80B then the earnings were bad from my perspective and I'd be inclined to sell my position.


Previously the stock price was based on expectations, and if those expectations were not met the price could be expected to decline to reflect the actual performance.


Taking profits at the top

Perhaps large investors are moving towards the distribution part of the cycle. (Longer time scales sure look like it on the index charts.) Time will tell


Valuation doesn't come from what's happening now, it comes from what is expected in the future. The whole point is to put in money to make more money later.

The earning report doesn't need to be bad for investors to see the projected outcomes for future quarters and say "hm... my money is best put somewhere else, whose earnings report showed more potential for growth".


search revenue was finally lower than expected.


Is that true? I'm actually asking because all the ones that I have seen mentioned from the arena were generated with Claude and I just checked a few random ones and they all have commits by Claude.

I don't know how much was created by LLMs but can you still call these independent implementations?


Yes? Very little about Claude is deterministic. If given the same sufficiently complicated problem, but via slightly different input prompts, it can generate entirely different code. It would be shocking if they all had a single shared bug.


If it's a complicated but narrow problem then regardless of the prompt its possible that Claude will always converge to the same solution type from its training data. So it will generate different version of the same code that have the different implementations of the same procedure that 'works' but is incorrect in some subtle way.


I don't think it would be that shocking, if it's a conceptual confusion that's easy to make.


> I am optimistic about the future of AI at Amazon

It's scary to think that any answer but "Strongly Agree" will very likely flag you as a risk.

Is this really the society we want?


Its the society ~1k companies want, and if you don't play along you wont have a job or healthcare.

Capitalism as a practice or an idea needs to be destroyed.




This has nothing to do with capitalism, as these practices antagonise paying customers and quality employees and will lose money to the company in the long run.

This has all to do with people wanting control over other people, which may me classified under authoritarism, totalitarism and the such.


> as these practices antagonise paying customers and quality employees and will lose money to the company in the long run

I've been hearing this for too many years, and so far it hasn't been true.

Maybe next year some of Amazon's customers will somehow become willing to pay more and get less convenience at other retailers, but I wouldn't bet on it.


Oh you can't answer strongly agree to everything, that flags that you're obviously not actually answering, which makes you a risk.


"just accept that bad things will happen to you peasant"


Wow those examples are full of verbatim copies of FOSS code (e.g. react-dom) but without any copyright/licensing notice

It's seriously mind-blowing that this is allowed and most people seem okay with it


Can some explain why would a billionaire like Altman care about the opinions expressed on HN?

Given the political power they have, particularly now with the Trump administration, whatever "optics" exist on this forum seems completely insignificant


That's what they want, but do not yet have.

It's easier to take over a resigned population. And stating "resistance is futile" is cheap and it might weaken opposition.


You forget how many influential tech professionals are present here (especially those in Silicon Valley) and that Altman was president of Y Combinator for several years.


Elon Musk seems to care a great deal about a lot of stuff that frankly isn't any of his concern, not really. Trump care immensely about shallow stuff that's really below what the president of the United States of America should spend time on.

Altman has some reason to worry, because developers and the users of HN are then ones he needs to promote/hype his products. OpenAI still needs customers and they need to sell tokens and a large number of users on HN are not only not buying, but are becoming increasingly hostile towards the product Altman is selling. My guess would be that he'd assume that the users on HN are in some sense his peers, and they are currently extremely divided in the question about the value and dangers of LLMs, and are increasingly critical of the business practises of OpenAI (and other AI companies).


That makes sense, but at the same time Altman has been famously called a "sociopath" by Aaron Swartz and a rapist by her own sister and yet he kept his position after the revolt a couple of years ago.

It's hard to imagine anything worse than bombing an elementary school and yet people are still using Anthropic products as if nothing has happened.

Optics don't seem to matter much?


How many people are aware of those accusations? It’s takes a very long time for things like that to permeate a culture to the point where there is actual consequences. Look at Elon, people who have followed his work have known for a very long time the guy is a pathological liar, sociopathic white nationalist. He’s still praised by many in the tech industry


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: