Thanks! Yes almost all claude, with me focused on gameplay, art direction, mechanics, and storytelling. Keep at it - Claude makes some things possible and other times it only helps you realize sooner your idea was too fuzzy!
I fixed some of these road issues in the latest release, and added those zone overlays that were missing. Still ironing out bugs in both these systems, but thanks so much for writing this up!
Thank you! Can't wait to play again. I feel like a lot of thought went into what you built.
I find the election timer & promises mechanic to be fun and unique. Although it's easy to trick out by dropping taxes six months before an election, it also creates a great secondary goal and tension in the game.
There's another weird thing... I assume it's not a bug, but at times, the budget will suddenly drop by $300k and I have no idea what caused it. The charts on the budget page can be hard to line up with mayoral choices or events, especially if the events are older than a year or off the list already. The first few times it happened, I thought maybe some consultant fees or rezoning had caused it, but it would be nice to know. Some sort of ledger you could go back and look at, maybe?
Once into the meat and potatoes of city management, the game is great and really playable. For a new game, it's got a surprisingly good balance of complicated decisions to maintain growth and equilibrium. I think Will Wright would give a thumbs up.
Thanks - I obviously didn’t get the balance right for everyone, and honestly it’s partly because I started with a maximalist position of “don’t hide the complexity that’s the point”, spent a bunch of time getting those details right…and then quickly realized during playtesting the same thing you and many others pointed out: progressively layering/revealing the depth works better to establish the contrast, while also being significantly easier for players to actually engage with.
Thanks for taking the time to take a look and give thoughtful feedback!
I took some perverse pleasure from the wall of complexity-- as you said, "that's the point". That really came through in my play experience, and I think that adds to it.
I wouldn’t necessarily fault the maximalist starting point, we’re in a new era of software where subtractive building (rather than additive) is starting to be a real approach to building. I’ve gone through the same process on a few projects - build to learn by laying all the ideas out and reacting to the ones that draw you in most, and then either chisel away the rest or start with a new project and swipe the gems from the last.
Thanks so much for your feedback! I originally started with a pretty diverse corpus of prewritten story arcs for diversity, and went back to retrofit them into the engine once I started customizing stories and details for the city. It looks like I missed a few spots, sorry about that!
And yes, I did sketch a version that is even more procedurally generated, but it’s taking longer to get right than I thought
I'm a huge fan of city builders and a politics nerd... I can't wait to try this. But I hope it really is procedural in the details too!
To the parent post: I have actually seen public interest groups bring petitions to a small city council with more signatures than there are residents of the city... but hopefully there's some countervailing force in this game too where local residents reject petitions that are driven by outside parties. In other words, not every signatory to a petition is a resident, and there's local resistance to regional causes. I guess this happens quite a bit more in the exurbs of major metropolitan areas.
Usually the local petitions for city matters are spread through WhatsApp groups of friends and family of everyone directly involved, so they usually get a lot of signatures from people outside the city (valid more or less for any size of city)
I’m sorry you ran into this! It looks like the game tried to allocate too much memory. I got claude to fall back to lower resolution textures when this happens, thanks for reporting.