HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | patall's commentslogin

But that is not dying of old age.

Probably really just brain decline, if you can grow new cells and organs without having to care about cancer. And even there, technology may be able to replace senescent cells at some point. But nobody really knows as even (multicellular, animal) model organisms cannot be kept alive forever today.

> Probably really just brain decline

So, dementia?


Not sure. Dementia to me is mostly a pathology but if you compare brain plasticity of a 50yo with a 30yo, you will already detect a decline that I suppose few would classify as dementia. But as long as we do not know what that is or how it relates (compared to cancer where we know a lot about i.e somatic mutations, epigenetic priming etc.), I would not classify that as the same.

I don't understand what you're saying. Dementia is a nonspecific name for the overall, progressive decline in cognitive function. The only other common type of "brain decline" we can imagine may be some localized trauma, like stroke. But I don't think we call these "brain decline", it's more of a "brain injury".

You may not be wrong but the authors were just picking an example in the headline. In the analysis they calculate t0 as 2026.87 plus/minus 5.50 years. They clearly state what assumptions that is based on do not take it as absolute fact but as providing thought for discussion.

If the law is worth its money, than you can start working in this position, wait for the trial period to end (or until they let you go) and then sue for the compensation stated in the job ad (well, in a country with some level of work place protection you could).

Or play their game, sign the contract, keep your original job, not show up and later tell them why they did waste their time themselves. If they then threaten you, you can point at the law.


Ice roads would be one application. Once it freezes, usual ferry services can often no longer be upheld. Then, one has to wait until the ice is thick enough to drive a car over the ice. If there was an easily applicable material to drive on ice less than usual 15-20cm of ice, that would decrease that waiting time quite a bit (and make ice roads/bridges possible in locations that would previously be unsuitable). And since it is ice, you can grow it somewhere else and transport in place with a barge.

Another is underground tunnel building. In sandy places, there are cases where they freeze the ground when building a concrete structure. If that could be reinforced with stronger ice, it might make working easier.

Similar, you can use ice as an temporary scaffold when e.g building a spanning bridge in winter. Stronger ice => easier application of said scaffold.


It always sounds/looks like a trap to me when I hear about/see people driving whole-ass cars over 15cm ~= half a foot of ice. That's just wrong, and I would barely consider walking on ice that thick (thin).

(I'm telling you I'm from southern California without telling you I'm from southern California)


It’s not safe to drive a car on 6 inches of ice. It’s enough for a snowmobile or single-person ATV. I wouldn’t drive a car onto a frozen lake without 12 inches of ice, 16 inches if it’s a typical half-ton pickup.

I live in MN and have slept overnight on the ice (inside of a heated trailer) before.

https://www.dnr.state.mn.us/safety/ice/thickness.html


Obviously depends on the weight / load per area. Here in Stockholm, our skating club starts organizing trips from 5 cm (=2inch), but black ice should hold you from 3.2 or so cm. And you can hear from the sound of the ice approximately which thickness you are on. But this is done with security equipment and in a group, so more general rules apply to anyone without experience and acting on their own. Ice is dangerous, like the outdoors is always dangerous when taken without necessary precaution.


> 5cm

Obviously you know better than I do, but I'm literally uncomfortable here in bed just reading about skating over ice that thin. I'm going to go think about something else now...


So is everyone else in Sweden.

Ask them how big and how many stones they have to skate by that are clearly thrown by people from land who are unsure if the ice is thick enough despite a stone larger having already been thrown.


You can listen to some ASMR here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v3O9vNi-dkA

(one of, if not the most experienced ice skater in the world having a blast)


I have similar prejudices until I was dragged to a Minnesotan winter activity where everyone drives into the middle of a frozen lake and park in a large circle while a bunch of drivers race their cars in circles in the middle. It was surreal.


Minecraft iceboat racing coming true?


This sounds like a Rube Goldberg machine if I've ever heard one, for the nichest of niche applications.


I am pretty sure that 99.9% of material science covers very niche applications


I wonder (no access to full text here) how they control for patients no longer able to do the exercise? Do those remain in the cohort, or are they removed (would bias the end result, so unlikely to get past review or into NEJM)? Or is that why they screened so long and so hard as selection criteria are super rigorous?


It's an issue. Reading through it though, physical functioning was actually a bit higher in the control group at baseline, and there wasn't much difference in completion of the assigned protocols.

They did note that the treatment-exercise group seemed to be healthier than expected in the sense that their survival was relatively high compared to typical nonstudy rates.


But you can walk to your neighbor 200m down the road. That feels (and actually may be) illegal on other continents.


yeah, the world is crazy


European cities are wastly more accessible as a pedestrian than australian or north american cities. And I count northern, southern, central, western and easterneuropenan cities in that.Thre other continents have some examples where the inner cities are also okayish from a pedestrian or cyclist POV, but a lot and especially suburbia is so much worse in pretty much all regions. A mining town in northern Sweden is better than suburbia on Long Island!


Outside France people don't live in big clusters. Take a look at the night satellite view. All those small/continuous towns do not have (functional) public transport. In my 12k-people town we don't have buses other than school buses and long-distance ones. And unfortunately people don't really walk other than for leisure.

As far as I know the closest city with public transport counts 100k residents, but there are 60 smaller towns in my province alone.


And what do people outside of Europe do when they want to walk for leisure? They drive to the park, because they are often not allowed to walk there!

People forget that European history before cars has lead to so many small accessible paths that simply do not exist in many American or Australian places. I know what rural Europe looks like. But you seem to have no idea what rural on other continents looks like.


Yes - car is a bit of a luxury in Europe if you don't do any of those things - live in the rural parts of the country, leave the urban core, have kids, visit parents, friends and grandparents, go to your rural property, go the mountains, the beach, buy bulky things, buy things in bulk, go to any other city just for exploration and fun, go outside the city to watch the milky way, do anything spontaneous, have job in the trades or have girlfriend.

You may not need car daily, but you definitely need it at least weekly.


I have transported 2x4s with a bike, I have moved houses with a bike, I have send a bike across countries to a place I had never been before via standard mail. I have transported 40kg of gear with a bike trailer. I cycle in -15°C to go ice-skating. All with the same one bike while I have never owned an electric bike.

I am not working in trades, don't live rural and I dont have kids. In that case I would get an electric bike. The rest I do. Heck, I have transported my SUP and a week of resources over 4km of rural road to get around rapids in a Swedish National Park. In one go in an hour because it was getting close to sun set and I had fallen in at the rapid before. My partner would like me less if I had a car.


I do ¾ of those things, including two children and a wife, without a car.


From experience, a lot of older people do not understand how hard it is to get an in-demand apartment, especially if rent controlled. They get the price/rent and they know that they personally dont want to pay for more housing (by having said housing built in their backyard). So this aligns with their personal preferance.


Can someone explain why the old books could really be relevant. I get the pre-nuclear steel analogy, but why is this relevant given how much more modern texts exist. A few years ago, millions of yahoo groups were erased but now a few thousand books are what is needed to run a successful AI company? I mean, it can barely be about the information in those books (that would be very often outdated), but just for a little more text (with ever less marginal gain), what is the benefit?


It sounds like it is about the information in the books. The titles they're looking for are all nonfiction. Not everything is on the internet, and just because it's a few years old doesn't mean it's outdated.

Speaking from experience, the information density of published books is a lot higher than most internet text. It's very high quality training data.

The goal here is to have all human knowledge in a single file, which is pretty neat IMO.


The internet basically never delivered on the promise of replacing textbooks or even education as a whole. Wikipedia sucks on many topics, has insane internal politics, and is a tertiary source by design (redigesting blogs and books), whereas textbooks are generally secondary.


> the information density of published books is a lot higher than most internet text

I'm not convinced. I think you are under-weighing the massive volumes of stuff like self-help books, romance novels, etc.


They're targeting non-fiction books, so romance novels would be out.


Booksellers noticed a huge uptick in non-fiction purchases, that is not the same thing as them not targeting fiction at all.

Edit: Actually, I have real evidence, the Bartz in "Bartz v Anthropic" is Andrea Bartz, a novelist, and the complaint specifically lists four of her novels as infringed works.


Is that a policy change after o4 got a little out of hand?


I see. So it is much less about 150 year old fiction books, but more about 1980s science literature that was only ever printed five times. That makes a lot more sense than what the public debate seems to be about.


Also the ability to set the training input limit in the past could be useful.


> but now a few thousand books are what is needed to run a successful AI company?

They're scanning millions of books.

It's the diversity of text that helps. One of the lessons we've learned is that more training data leads to better models. Even old books have different mixes of word sequences that will improve the model. The returns are diminishing, but when you have the pipeline set up to ingest it you might as well keep adding to the dataset.


They are the memories of the productive part of society. You can leaf through them and get the feel of what it was like. You don’t need most of your memories, personality, or core ideals to be productive to the State.


Diversity. Modern books with modern content and in modern styles are overrepresented, old ones underrepresented.


> why the old books could really be relevant > it can barely be about the information in those books (that would be very often outdated),

LOL, not being rude: have you ever read a book outside of what they forced you to read in school? Most old books are not O'reilly's manuals for Visual Studio 2014, they don't go out of date.

They are interesting to human beings for the same reason they are interesting to the labs. If it was just about quantity of text then the labs could generate text with the prev. gen model and use that alone to scale to the next model, there is something of immeasurable value contained in books (hint: it starts with an i and rhymes with bin formation).


The information density is a lot less for millions of yahoo groups. They are far more likely to cover the same topics and not have new information in them.

Books are more likely to be about a specific topic or story or time or setting and be more information dense


I'm guessing the more integration tables they consume, the better they become at integration.

I also guess that they're targeting languages that aren't tier one for them yet. Like, Japanese is probably a relatively small corpus for them.


Because Yahoo in particular was very good at destroying goldmines shortly before they became ultra valuable.

There's a number of places that destroyed vast amounts of data in the wind down of ZIRP that probably regret it now.


Cognition is encoded in language, they weren't brain-damaged yet. There's better (real, not token-exchange) thinking, which LLMs can copy and reproduce in novel arrangements.


I also wonder if it’s used for text generation in image models! Awful lot of typefaces, sizes, orientations, and words in those books.


> Can someone explain why the old books could really be relevant.

Lots and lots of information is not online. You'd be surprised.


I think a book is like one completion of the mind behind it, so in a way, this is just distillation.


They aren't but these companies have more money than sense.


Well, most of the old books are much easier to read than the new ones. Back then people were much more educated and had a much wider vocabulary....


Writing style maybe?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: