HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | partsch's commentslogin

I had a similar problem last week. My registrar suspended my account without further notice. Customer support told me to pay 90 euros per domain for recovery.

I got attention by creating a post on social media, some higher level people reached out to me and resolved the issue.

Is there anything one can do to prevent the entire company from going dark?

- What if my registrar suspends my account? => Use different registrars for different domains. - What if the whole TLD has an outage (DENIC had that before)? => Fallback tld?

Should I really setup all SaaS apps with fallback-domain support that is registered by a different registrar on a different tld?

What happens to my company mails?

I wanna be a plumber!


> Customer support told me to pay 90 euros per domain for recovery.

That's incredibly scammy.


It is scammy. But I would expect that they have it in terms and conditions.

Not everything a company writes in the terms and conditions is legal, not to mention morally defensible. For domains in particular, the registry and not the registrar sets the rules ultimately.

Trial court in the registrar's jurisdiction typically has a say...

Sure, doesn't make it less scammy. Where I live, you can't just add whatever to the T&C and be able to legally force people to follow it, has to be stuff reasonable people would expect. Such term isn't one of those, so to small claims court I'd go, tends to scare most companies into action in my experience.

1. Hosting and domain registrars should be two different companies. Every time.

All other points are useless if you don’t follow the first one and the shite hits the fan…


The only way to solve this is to be your own registrar. Domains are ultimately a rental. They can mess it up as they please, even if you weren't culpable about anything, and having unreachable data on your end won't help much in that situation.

How can you be your own registrar?

You would typically start being a reseller, and then (depending on the TLD) apply to get accredited, meet financial and technical requirements, pay a fee and go through technical testing.

I don't know, be Google or something. Not realistic, but otherwise the control of your domain is protected by trust only.

Indeed. You could always use an .eth domain which you own cryptographically, but that's a separate system, not compatible with DNS, so anyone that wants to resolve it needs a special resolver.

:shrug:, at one point the entire IPv4 atop Ethernet transport was implemented as extra packages in major operating systems. There's probably nothing inherently wrong with a system like that to be "nonstandard" if it would work.

> How can you be your own registrar?

As usual, the answer is "it depends".

It depends on the registry.

Some, e.g. UK TLD operated by Nominet are easy as pie, just pay the quite reasonable membership fee.

Others make you jump through hundreds of hoops.

For most people though, just pick a reliable company like INWX to register your domains – previously I would recommend OpenSRS as an alternative option but they've recently hiked their card processing fees to 4% or something horrific, meanwhile INWX do not charge any card processing fees. Also OpenSRS support for DNSSEC is, to put it politely, "patchy".


This story made me want to run my own registrar with a “no automated enforcement” policy as my differentiator. While other services streamline by using AI for all operations, I would guarantee to you that my admin named “Steve“ would personally call your phone or notify you by overnight delivery if we thought such an action was necessary. You, of course, would need to pay a $$ deposit to cover the postage.

Wouldn't all kind of scammers start using your service since it takes you time in human scale to stop them?

Damned if we do, damned if we don't.


Why would that hypothetical registrar accept such customers?

Even if you have to terminate later (scammer managed to hide its scammyness), you could differentiate by doing so in a more "civilized" manner (in case what you think is a scammer really isn't).

Coincidentally, I use a small registrar whose owner/operator I have as a Signal contact.


> a small registrar whose owner/operator I have as a Signal contact

This is the exact service I imagined I'd provide -- but I'd love to use yours. Can you refer this registrar?


What had happened? Which registrar was this? What did they ask you to pay that 90 euro for?

In my company we use accounts like firstname.lastname@company.tld for mail and therefore as usernames to sign in to different services.

My colleague had booked a hotel room some weeks ago, the booking system was hacked and his information leaked. Not sure if these events were connected, but after that somebody has created an account at our registrar (IONOS) and at PayPal using firstname_lastname@company.tld

The hacker started ordering random services in the name of my colleague.

I have no clue, how it was possible to open the accounts without the need to confirm the mail address.

Long story short, we asked PayPal and IONOS to block both accounts, they blocked them, but also - by accident - blocked the real IONOS account of my colleague. All domains were linked to his account, so all domains got blocked immediately.

The experience with the first level support was annoying and it felt like our company was gone… they wanted written (by letter) confirmation, that we are willing to pay the 90€ per domain unlock fee.

But we made the issue public, gained some visibility on social media and a lot of people from IONOS reached out to us and restored our domains - free of charge of course.

They apologized and promised, that they are going to adjust their first level support to prevent issues like that in the future. We have also received some kind of compensation for the trouble that was caused.

To be fair, it felt scary when all services went offline and we did not know what to do. Two options: write a letter, pay the money and try to get the money back afterwards or wait 30 days until the TLD provider - denic for .de will release the domains to the public and be fast enough to register them again.

After what happened, I am not sure how to proceed and how to secure against such issues.

Errors are human. I think IONOS can only be held accountable for the poor first level support experience, not for the whole accident.


In case somebody is wondering: all domains were recovered.

All domains are still at IONOS, I am going to move some to another registrar. Not because I am unhappy with the experience, but to reduce the risk.

The error happened once, I think it is fair to give them another chance.


For the sake of transparency: In the first comment I wrote “my account”, then I wrote about the account of a colleague.

It is his account but I wanted to keep the explanation simple, so I just used the term “my account”, since IMO it has no further relevance.


IONOS?

Just me ranting but: I had a domain with them that I ... had on a 3-year renewal + auto-renewal set up, and the system tried to charge the renewal at the end of the first year(why?) which failed for unrelated reason, then apparently perma-deleted my billing account after few automatic warnings but with the DNS running for 2 more years(why?), plus a week or two after full grace period after expiry with zero communication(why?), and btw they no longer accept chat or email(why?), and only option is to call, which goes to Philippines anyway(why?), which got hanged up(why?) likely by call screening AI for my weird likely Fable-triggering Gmail address read aloud, which caused the support person to call me back for the rest of the call that lasted an hour(umm), and I apparently have $17 outstanding invoice that I need to pay, which is such an old invoice that they only take payment through bank transfer(why?) which is not trivial or cheap for me, for what? A thing that never happened because it never went through 2 years ago?

Like, this could have been extremely cheap email and a Visa payment if they didn't permanently close the billing account tied to an active contract they were honoring.

They will never recover from financial losses on me for this since: 1) this is likely costing them more than I've paid cumulatively, 2) they are not going to make back from recovery fee total, 3) neither of me and them would want businesses with each other, 4) the support person said there's no one to escalate which means they are not L1 and they are not paid less than $0.005/hour, and 5) the support person promised to call me later but never did so I assume I they were fired and that costs them hiring and training, all considered likely totaling somewhere between $500 to $1k on their side, of which I'd be technically only obligated to pay for $17 that I consider debatable, which costs their time and money to even receive.

I guess it's on me and I'm sorry but are they ... is there something wrong with their billing department???


The registrar seems to be namesilo

At a corporate level, there are the registrars that charge absurd fees (relative to consumer providers) but won't do anything with checking with the client's lawyer first (MarkMonitor etc).

At a personal level, having a backup domain is a much cheaper and easier option.


it's crazy that codeberg isn't using MarkMonitor

Never use a provider you can't litigate in court for business. That means use local providers and your national TLD

Being legally right does not help. You need a lawyer, time and a lot of money.

I prefer fast solutions.


Don't even bother trying to be robust against your TLD failing.

Or do bother by having two domains at different registrars. Some websites that are at risk of TLD-level blocks do that proactively (mostly piracy related, but it's still something to learn from)

They'll just do a coordinated takedown

No, but all models should be open weight.

I can't walk :D


Stackoverflow had such a toxic and beginner-unfriendly community...


Did it really? It would be nice to see some concrete examples.


Thank you for bringing that up. Both got flagged, maybe due to incorrect calculation of the percentage?!


To attract users :)

--

The question is probably more: How can it be legal to offer a service without specifying exactly what you're getting?


Perhaps one should start by looking into how the providers of LLMs obtained the training data.


I think it's perfectly normal for errors to occur given the pace of development.

Retroactive refunds are certainly better, but I think OpenAI is much more customer-focused in this regard than Anthropic.


Sure, but also who asked? And that's because they have the compute to burn, which is conditional based on their need to use it to train the next one.

Anything else I've ever paid $200/mo for, advertised as being for professionals, had a markedly better customer experience. If you wanna be Patrick and tell your pet rock to take its time at that price, well then you're Patrick. Good job!

I'm having far more fun with Kimi and Deepseek, at lower prices, without these problems. And I don't have to follow a bunch of obnoxious shitposters to stay clued in on what the fuck is going on or what this week's excuse is.

They're especially cocky right now, they have to beat their chest and pretend like their only competition is Anthropic. They're in for a rough wake up call man. Playing it fast and loose with developer loyalty is a fantastic way to get burned when options like those exist. They are earnestly just as good and in some cases better, and check this out: nobody can take them away from you no matter where you live. If you want to rent 8 GPUs and run the open models yourself, you can do that! You can even be enterprising and sell your excess compute to your friends, or strangers. Best to figure this out before the regulatory capture starts


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: