You sound depressing. How did you loose all the joy of things you like?
The norm of 'becoming an adult' do you know what this looked like 50/100 years ago?
Being emotional disconnected, going to work, drinking.
Do you even realize how closed minded you are? How you follow norms of 'being an adulut' because thats the image of an Adult you hold up without knowing why?
I'm mature, I still have a few legosets around. Surprise you can be both. I would even argue that i'm more mature than you ever be if you don't break out of your closed mindedness.
Grow up and set yourself mentally free and decide for yourself what it means to be an adult.
You dont lose joy for what you love. You replace the love of building (legos) with the love of building (woodworking, smithing, stonemason, diy). You graduate to more sophisticated endeavors. You may love reading but you need to stop reading the box car kids and read infinite jest at some point.
Because it sounds like you're a valley girl. Just spell it out, seriously. It's only 4 more characters, a small fraction of the entire sentence you typed.
This article itself assumes that the same people advocating for Nvidia are the same people and is the same thing as Anthropics 'behaviour'.
Is it that you need to have a certain amount of intelligence to be able to keep two conflicting opinions in a reasonable fashion in. your head?
Why would a person throw away their OpenAI shares just because they quit OpenAI and are warning about the danger?
They are happily aware that they are in a construct in which this is not irrational, a model collapse or stupid.
I'm an idealistic person too and I advocate for helping everyone and I also don't throw away my money. I can do both I can advocate for it and be ready when i realize that we as a society are moving in the direction and i can keep my self preservation strategy too.
> Why would a person throw away their OpenAI shares just because they quit OpenAI and are warning about the danger?
Credibility for the most part, if I'm telling everyone that climate change will be the single worst driver of war, famine, and general misery we have ever visited on ourselves why would anyone believe me if I had Shell, BP, and Exxon shares? You would quite reasonably say 'he can't take climate change that seriously if he's invested in the sector instigating it' and I'd have no reply to that. Being invested in something isn't a morally neutral act, it's a declaration that you morally licence whatever it is you've invested in.
Anyone can have principles when it enriches them, but in my opinion a principle is only worth anything if you can stick to it despite it making you poorer.
> Credibility shoulud come from the logic itself, if people don't believe your logic and logic is not enough, you have lost already anyway
We are empirical beings far more than we are logical beings, and it's proper to judge a person based on the alignment of their actions and words. If someone gives me the best argument in the world in favour of vegetarianism and owns a chain of slaughterhouses, that is still a good reason for me to think they are untrustworthy because many times those whose actions and stated beliefs differ have caused harm to myself and others. In my view it's irrational to take any argument in isolation as a way to judge somebody's point, they should be considered wholistically as the moral and social being that they are.
Going on logic alone rather than including moral and social judgements in your overall picture is a weakness not a strength in my view, and a dangerous one too. In my view an excessive reliance on debate makes a person more vulnerable to sophistry versus someone who uses logic as one tool in a heterogenous toolbox. The most accomplished debaters aren't necessarily the most accomplished at finding logical truth, but they're usually the best at battering through people's defences with clever sophism.
But we see that this is not true. As soon as the distance to the mainstream group is too big, the mainstream group will label you and make you an enemy.
IIHHH vegetarian iIihhhhh. You know?
I think you have the best chance to be part of the mainstream but nudge it. "Oh yeah of course i eat meat but not always."
Also there are things which do not affect me and were i can easily accept that everyone wants to go the doomsday road.
Not every number they stated has to scale as much as they stated with it becoming very clear how much more intelligence we will have available through all the different possible angles there are.
Its not unrealistic at all that a high performance inference datacenter chip today can be owned by you in 10 years. Having Opus 5.5 at home and delivering 1000t/s basically guarantees that my job cariere will look very different than what it is today.
This is a big/huge thing. The generation before was able to stay at one company, buy a house and retire without much fluctuation.
This forces a lot more agency from people and this is exhaustive and its absolutly unclear today how it will be in 10 years.
And you don't need to spend expoential or linear, the spending today is not just a bit, its massive and from leaders like google, microsoft and co to a certain degree absolutly affordable.
They sit atop of one of the richest companies on our planet, with the most amount of resources available with a group of very very smart people.
You don't need to take everything they say as a ground truth but you are way to ignorant for not having any of their resources.
Do you just accept that we are now able to generate any image of everything we want? Video? 3D Models? This was unimagbinable a few years back, now you can generate live video 24/7.
YOu have a LLM which responds smarter then some humans on our planet.
A job no one thought you could just industrialize just happened.
What are you looking forward to? Being absolutly ignorant and being surprised that this stupidity is responsible for you loosing your job?
> Do you just accept that we are now able to generate any image of everything we want? Video? 3D Models?
From my personal experience the last 2 weeks I 100% reject all three of those. I'd love all three to be true, and for generating the animations for 3D models to be true as well, but it simply isn't true yet.
> Do you just accept that we are now able to generate any image of everything we want? Video? 3D Models? This was unimagbinable a few years back, now you can generate live video 24/7.
And its still kind of shit? AI video in particular is stuck in an uncanny valley, because the video models have no internal framework for how light transmission works...
I'm sure a human with artistic vision, applying authorial intent, can create AI video that doesn't fall victim to the uncanny valley.
But for the non-specialist, if you just prompt something from a frontier video model, it still comes out looking like shiny plastic and suffering from random physics glitches.
Is this the quality of discussion you want to have?
Throwing out some random sentence without adressing any argument I made?
Your statement is objectivly wrong. Look at the profiles of these people working at these companies. They have crazy impressive resumes. Its not proof but its an indication and I didn't state it as an absolute.
The original commentor, i responded too, wrote "These people are so full of shit" despite them deliverying better and better models every few month and clear progress.
So no I don't think people are aware of this and I would be happy to have a proper argument about these in a civil manner
There is no motivation for them to think this through.
As long as the emploeeys are needed, you have them. If it becomes apparent, that you really really reached an AGI level, a switch gets flipped and a new really appears.
While I still think its not unrealistic that we see this sooner than later, my timeframe is 5-15 years. 15 years is still a few years so why act on it today?
And i mean its a very rich company and a lot of people work in US America, they don't have laber laws right? so they can just fire them easily anyway.
But i have a simliar situation at work: Im pretty sure my job is gone in 2 years due to some change in how we are going to do things and they need me to transform this. Do i not do this? No i support it. It makes sense for the company and i'm getting paid for it.
Are you arguing on an esotheric level aka soul and god and believe?
Or on a technical note because certain brain structures etc. might not exist in an LLM and stuff like a default mode network and sensory input and a world to move in, is missing?
Yeah, maybe esoteric (depends on your point of view) but not soul or god or spirit etc
Basically, I'm not a materialist (a widely shared position in philosophy across millennia and across cultures up until just recently). I treat consciousness as fundamental, not the material universe . Thus 'conjuring intelligence' into machines is simply not possible.
BTW, machine learning is a totally valid (and powerful) concept & technology from where I stand. But it's "dumb" learning.
Idealism's various possible responses to this materialist challenge left as an exercise for the reader (either through their own thought process or by research)
The esoteric angle is that held by materialists, which is based on the blind faith that complexity transmutes quantities into qualities. That's shallow religion, it's alchemy in its trivial form. An ontology based on consciousness is way more rational, as it is the in-your-face pre-cognitive given of existence.
I am pretty sure you are making a logical error here (strawman). Materialism is not in any way at odds with taking the existence of consciousness as a given.
Ever heard of eliminative physicalism or even illusionism? Those are materialists metaphysics, and they are _very much_ at odds with the existence of consciousness.
At any rate, sure, not being at odds with the existence of consciousness might be a trait of the more reasonable strands of materialism (if there's even such a thing), but they will always see it as emergent/derivative and often even epiphenomenal, otherwise they wouldn't be materialist stances.
So am not sure where you see the logical misstep here, but am happy to hear. The point of the previous comment is that framing an ontology whose primitive is C, is in no way "esoteric", term that is usually used in contraposition with "rational". Taking C as epistemologically or even ontologically prior is the rational stance, not only on accounts of parsimony.
I agree that while AI has some understanding, it doesn’t feel like it’s full understanding, the way we know it in humans. For that very reason I disagree that current AI can do the same job as a human. Regarding intelligence, it surpasses humans in some aspects of intelligence, but is lacking in others. In that sense, we haven’t reached AGI yet.
If you configure it and don't need it, it doesn't cost you anythning.
If you need it, it allows you to choose what to kill or gives you time to save.
It also allows you to utilize your available memory better (which didn't matter for a long time, fair enough but it matters on cloud were memory was always expensive and it might matter today again).
Plenty of things are loaded into memroy and are never touched again. Plenty of daemons doing something in the background but just not eveyr second of it.
You are not running a real time system with calculated memory usage. You run a bunch of random stuff.
It was introduced in MS-DOS 6.0 -- in fact it was the major feature.
It rivalled DR-DOS 6 which bundled a 3rd party disk compression program called SuperStore, which DR licensed in.
Microsoft invited other disk-compression vendors to send in their code for MS to look at and maybe license. STAC gave them the source code to the industry #1, Stacker.
(Stacker even worked on OS/2 2, a major technological feat. I ran Stacker in DOS + OS/2 dual-boot. I really recommend nobody ever tries this -- it was a nightmare.)
MS being MS it just stole the code. It took some of the core Stacker algorithm, and the driver architecture from another rival product ("DoubleDisk" from Vertisoft), and built it into MS-DOS 6 and called it DoubleSpace.
Never trust Microsoft. I don't care what your SLA says.
MS-DOS 6 was buggy AF. MS issued an update, MS-DOS 6.20, with a much better disk-repair tool called SCANDISK.
Stac noticed the stolen code in Doublespace. It sued. It won.
It something like $250M or so in damages. Knowing that bigger disks would soon make disk compression irrelevant -- and as the tech was now built in, there would be no more sales -- it got into remote control tech-support apps instead by acquiring a R/C vendor, "Reachout." It also bought a vendor of server image-based backups, "Replica". The dot-com crash nearly killed it, and everyone was bundling this tech by 2002, so the management sold up and wound up the company and returned the cash to shareholders. A rare honourable company in the PC industry, screwed over by Microsoft.
Do not trust Microsoft.
Microsoft issued another "update" to DOS called MS-DOS 6.21 without DoubleSpace.
It rewrote the offending code and issued MS-DOS 6.22 with DriveSpace instead.
It's the same system with some lines changed.
Reminder: Never trust Microsoft.
Windows 95 and 98 just inherited DriveSpace from MS-DOS 6.22.
That's disk compression, not RAM compression. It's been variously demonized over the years but it can be pretty great to have.
I was using transparent disk compression ~35 years ago on an 8088 running MS-DOS and Stacker, to eek a bit more storage into a 20-megabyte MFM ST-225 hard drive.
It's been a built-in for many systems for decades. Windows can do it. I'm using it today with ZFS, where it's essentially free on modern-ish hardware.
The norm of 'becoming an adult' do you know what this looked like 50/100 years ago?
Being emotional disconnected, going to work, drinking.
Do you even realize how closed minded you are? How you follow norms of 'being an adulut' because thats the image of an Adult you hold up without knowing why?
I'm mature, I still have a few legosets around. Surprise you can be both. I would even argue that i'm more mature than you ever be if you don't break out of your closed mindedness.
Grow up and set yourself mentally free and decide for yourself what it means to be an adult.
reply