Older mixers you could argue could kind of be traced but even then there’d still be difficulty and deniability.
There’s a newer class of privacy mixer though that basically is untraceable. On privacy chains you can’t see the transactions so from an outside perspective it looks like the money just went into a black hole and it wouldn’t show up until it got converted to public again. When it gets converted to public though, it has no connection to the original transaction and could be literally anyone else’s money who used the chain converting to public.
It could take a long time but you could basically just slowly do this and withdraw small enough amounts of money to not raise suspicion. Or do something like start your own coin and pump the price with the stolen funds then cash out the coin. There’s new privacy smart contract chains where this could be done without even signing slightly the stolen funds were used.
Glassbreakers: Champions of Moss (same people who made Moss and Moss 2) based a lot of their design on Brass Tactics. I would say check it out but unfortunately the studio (Polyarc) went under shortly after publishing it so probably won't be seeing many updates and I'm not sure if it is even playable anymore.
It did suffer from player base problems you were basically always against bots or very high level players, but I never felt a VR UX (or any UX almost) feel so good and intuitive. It's a bit sad I feel like there is some alternate reality where a game like this would have been huge but there just doesn't seem to be the market there anymore.
I’ve actually seen this be the biggest advantage of AI in the corpo world: it is helping people realize their ideas are stupid or their busywork doesn’t matter way faster.
I’ve seen so many “dream” projects finally realized recently that organizations had been chasing for years only for them to realize it provides no value. Easily could have wasted years of time and tortured dozens of people but instead only took a relatively small amount of time due to AI.
I know some people will say this kills jobs but I really don’t think these are the jobs humans should be doing. It shouldn’t take someone’s entire life to realize people don’t actually want to “gamify their credit card application process” or whatever dumb thing product comes up with. Also when you spend so much time on a dumb idea a lot of people will try to justify it which is why I think we see so many obviously bad ideas go to market.
The amount of requests I get to help “make the next Facebook” or “make an application to predict the stock market” have gone down substantially and I think this is a good thing.
> it is helping people realize their ideas are stupid or their busywork doesn’t matter way faster.
While this is a possible explanation, it seems far more likely that people are finding more private/solo ways to pursue whatever their equivalent of “make the next Facebook” or “predict the stock market”.
I would be very surprised if the was a reduction in total duration of pursuit of these type of ideas. I think there’s just a reduction in them asking you as a dev to help.
It's a cool demo and all but I can't help but feel like it's not that impressive considering these companies control such an absurd amount of capital and this is all they can do with it. A stunt for a launch showing off features that obviously won't be in any real product.
A lot of public funds go into these companies and it just feels like they are playing around with toys instead advancing humanity. I sometimes wonder if we are not allocating resources very efficiently.
I mean if I saw this at a monster truck derby I would think it was cool. When it's companies that represent trillions of dollars it feels a little underwhelming I was expecting more. It's also clearly a gimmick it's not like this is a real product. Even from their own marketing it's obvious.
If it was like "we figured out this technology and it will be available to the public and we will be working with regulators to usher in a new age of flying cars!" I would be pretty stoked. But it's pretty obviously just a stunt for the launch.
I don't know I just...I feel crazy but I feel like these resources could be doing something amazing and we getting like stunt tricks.
I mean Chinese EVs have already surpassed Tesla in global volume sales and their CEO helped elect the man who gut the EV industry in America. But I guess it's cool we are doing cool tricks while that happens?
Would you the same thing if it wasn't Elon Musk at the helm of this company? I'm not a big fan of him either, but I get the feeling some don't want to like this demo.
Also the public government funds being received are in the form of contracts. It's not like they can just use the money anywhere. Both Tesla and SpaceX are likely using private money (that is to say, funds not from the government) to fund this.
If it was a smaller scrappier company I would think it was neat, but this company and associated companies represents so much of the market and so many resources. And I don't know it just seems like they are doing like...monster truck derby stunts?? It's just kind of underwhelming to see this is what they are spending their time on for me. I was expecting a lot more.
> It's not like they can just use the money anywhere
I mean SpaceX was literally caught buying Cybertrucks it's clear there's some corruption. But aside from that, they also just represent such a large chunk of the market that it's hard to argue that they aren't just siphoning funds from other ventures somewhat even outside of public misappropriation. I wouldn't even mind that if I felt like they earned it, but it just feels like the stock was pumped as a meme or something. The engineering is impressive but not impressive IMO for what they are worth.
> I mean SpaceX was literally caught buying Cybertrucks it's clear there's some corruption.
SpaceX doesn't exclusively fund itself through government money. They have plenty of private investors, and they used private money to buy those Cybertrucks. This purcahse is not the clear sign of corruption you present it to be; there is zero evidence that money from government contracts was used.
Government contracts are not grants. There are specific appropriations for where that money is allowed to be used.
And as for your point about the funds going to other ventures, sure I guess. You're free to think whatever you want about which private companies deserve funding, but it's not like it's unfair to anyone when two private agents get together and agree to do something. That is the case even if the private investor funds the private company to do something considered phony and pointless.
> it just feels like they are playing around with toys instead advancing humanity
You don't think electric vehicles and battery storage advance humanity?
On the contrary I would rather my big companies didn't try so hard to advance humanity. Elon has a lot of takes around creating a Utopian society which do not sit right with me. Really it's not the advancement that's the problem, it's the requisite power and resources necessary to achieve the elaborate visions. Humanity should be advanced by a collective, not by a few gifted individuals, even if that means more bureaucracy and less efficiency.
Hah! It sounds exactly like that, except that's not what I meant at all. I see all of humanity as a collective. We work together to achieve things without any single power dictating our decisions. So in my mind I'm actually thinking more libertarian. And maybe a more accurate replacement for "bureaucracy" would be logistical friction or something like that. The lure of highly concentrated leadership is the elimination of this friction, at whatever cost the leadership decides, irrespective of your wishes. When all power is concentrated in the hands of the few, personal liberty doesn't stand much of a chance.
I would agree with you but this is what it was like with search engines as well. Search engines got so good it felt like anyone could just Google anything instead of paying someone.
I think the surprising part is that, no matter how easy it gets, the majority of he population would still rather pay someone else to do it for them.
Honestly the first ten years of my career was just me being baffled I was getting paid to Google stuff. I get worried about AI in the same way but continue to be baffled that I am getting paid to just prompt AI now.
Maybe this time is different but honestly the world is so ridiculous sometimes that I honestly don’t think it will be different.
That's all true when you're working in a space where people have already solved and written about similar problems, for instance with web dev, or simple enterprise application dev. When you work in a problem space that is novel and tricky, googling or AI doesn't answer your questions (correctly).
Google wasn't a magic answer box, it was a collection of things people had written about the problems they faced. AI isn't a magic answer box either, it's trained to spit out the best guesses based on things people have written about the problems they faced. But all this is based on actual humans who are exploring, wrestling with problems, and writing things down. I don't think people can assume that AI will take all that over and push things forward.
I would argue that all of the problems we have to solve are novel and tricky. The rest we've already solved but constantly reinvent (not novel) or already solved and just need to piece together like Legos (not tricky).
Search engines were very interesting and had a lot of myths surrounding them. People claiming that typing out full sentences worked better, vs others entering just keywords. A lot of people learned to utilize the special operators.
I thought I got really good at googling right before the engine started becoming really bad around Covid years.
About 80% of my career could be generously described as typing what someone asked me into Google and giving them the answer back in a way they can understand. I don't even mean my interactions with non-technical folk. It's far too common with my "peers" as well.
Search engines couldn’t analyze your local files and give you a specific root cause and fix it. Agents can. I don’t think the two are comparable, really, other than at the most superficial surface level.
They’re comparable in an exponential view. I remember the librarian teaching us how to look through boxes of cards. Then Google came out a few years later. For a couple decades, Google-fu was a superpower that most people didn’t know they needed.
It is in the sense that you performed tasks for people, and knew which tasks needed to be performed. The advent of agentic programs now means those same tasks can be deduced by the agent and also performed by it. There's a very thin moat between you and that, now.
some people, most people i'd say, don't really enjoy working with computers. if you ask anyone on the street they know chatgpt of course but ask them what an agent is and they will have no idea.
That's okay, though. Agents are an abstraction no one will really need to understand. They will still benefit from it when they press a button to 'do the thing' which previously required a human.
Yes, I just think there is a huge mental barrier that will gradually have to disappear through slow diffusion of information. People think it's too complicated, it must be hard to use since it's a complex technology etc. etc. So even when we reach the stage that it would be easy to use, many will just not even try or know about it.
I mean I would think that, but I've literally tried to train product owners on contracts I am on to use AI and not pay me anymore and they still get overwhelmed by the idea of a terminal and ask me to do it. So I really don't know.
GUIs exist for AI and will exist even more widely soon. If even that is too overwhelming, there will be AI avatars (controllable video generation and speech synthesis) that just talk to you and you can talk to them. If even looking at a screen is too overwhelming, there will be robots.
But I think the key is none of this, but the responsibility. That's what they want to offload on you. They don't want to worry, they want it off their own shoulders, they want someone else to take care of it. AI cannot take on legal and social responsibility, since it doesn't have the same kind of social reputation at stake in a community or in a professional network or in law.
> Search engines got so good it felt like anyone could just Google anything instead of paying someone.
I mean this is probably true enough to have had real economic impact! I've made a whole lot of fixes via YouTube & Google that I would have had to pay someone for otherwise.
> Licensing/copyrighting encouraged people to think up of new things, and new ways of doing something.
I don't think this has been true since the copyright acts extended copyright from a max of 28 years to a minimum of 70 years + life of the author (or 95 years for corporations). I think this is kind of the inevitable conclusion of such absurd length copyright.
Copyright is no longer used as a grace period and reward for innovation, it's a tool for corporations to hoard and restrict IP. A core aspect of human creativity is building off other things and things you grew up with, but now people have zero chance of seeing ANYTHING created in their lifetime entering the public domain.
This is an inevitable rebellion to the situation these laws put us in.
Yeah it was already really hard to find good games before AI due to a massive influx of indie devs, easier to use engines, review gaming, and asset flipping.
I worry how this will impact finding quality games.
I know people keep saying “we’ve had slop factories before AI” but this really feels different.
I think scanning is worth it. There's a lot of cheap services out there that do it but it's also not too hard to find relatively cheap scanners that will process stacks of pages if you are willing to destroy the binding.
I scanned quite a few documents many years ago and it's been fun trying new tools every couple of years to see how good they are getting. I would say it's still not 100% there, but if you have them scanned you can basically just just keep trying and compare the results.
I think the only disappointment in recent years has been that storage has gotten more expensive instead of cheaper. I was waiting for SSDs to get cheap enough to justify moving all my documents to a fast flash array to process and search through them faster, but that doesn't seem like it will happen anytime soon.
>I was waiting for SSDs to get cheap enough to justify moving all my documents to a fast flash array to process and search through them faster, but that doesn't seem like it will happen anytime soon.
How much data are you working with? lol
Seems like you're doing something professional-grade if this is the case. I imagine most people, like the OP, can basically use whatever machine they have laying around and never be concerned with storage size/speed.
I'm also curious if you've tapped into cloud computing. Not that using the cloud is cheap, but I suppose if I was in a position where I'm concerned with the cost of SSDs for a processing task, then I'd be exploring all of my options and I'd be surprised if the cloud wouldn't be an "easy" solution.
I wouldn’t say people are perfectly aware. It seems obvious I should be able to at least back up my save files but that was disabled on the PS5 and instead you need to purchase a separate subscription. A lot of basic features that were available in the past are going away.
Not sure on the methodology here, but could this also just because people's projects mature on the new model which results in less thinking?
I've personally seen people complain about new models getting slow after a week or so but I think it's mostly because the new model is able to briefly overcome the context collapse of their poorly managed project before it starts to collapse again from all the new work.
There’s a newer class of privacy mixer though that basically is untraceable. On privacy chains you can’t see the transactions so from an outside perspective it looks like the money just went into a black hole and it wouldn’t show up until it got converted to public again. When it gets converted to public though, it has no connection to the original transaction and could be literally anyone else’s money who used the chain converting to public.
It could take a long time but you could basically just slowly do this and withdraw small enough amounts of money to not raise suspicion. Or do something like start your own coin and pump the price with the stolen funds then cash out the coin. There’s new privacy smart contract chains where this could be done without even signing slightly the stolen funds were used.
It’s kind of a mess.