I'd take the most radical perspective here and say that it never ends.
People point out verification has been laborious to date because humans have to write all the proof and LLMs can write it instead.
But the bigger reason IMO is that verification right now is the equivalent of writing Rust applications with no crates besides stdlib
We're only going to get more and more lemmas as building blocks, CSlib is doing what Mathlib did for CS foundations like algos and data structures. I think there are many more opportunities to make building blocks and modules for formalism and have been working on a framework for formal spec with the intent of being able to encompass a much larger breadth of software within an algebraic model by default instead of hand-verifying from scratch
These are so insanely good. And unlike a lot of CS video channels they do a great job of bringing on the truly most interesting projects in the field like Datafusion, DuckDB, DBSP and tying them to the curriculum
This is exactly what I've been focused on. I think Lean is one of the few, maybe only programming language expressive and powerful enough to do it effectively
> No children were actually harmed by the use of AI deep fakes that use their likeness
Only in the most strict definition of "harm" is this accurate. One of the most emotionally damaging parts reported by victims of CSAM is the idea that these images of their abuse are constantly circulated and consumed years later
Do you really think it isn't further victimizing for their abuse have been directly used to remix and reproduce that experience to make hundreds of times more content based on them?
YOU are also making the same mistake as the article.
CSAM necessarily requires sexual abuse of a child. Reusing someone's face likeness does not qualify and should not qualify.
That's not to say deepfakes do no harm to the person whose likeness is stolen. But it's a categorical difference.
informed readers should not tolerate the blithe use of "think of the children!!!1!" When that particular abuse has nothing to do with them being children. It dilutes the seriousness of the crime that CSAM is.
A 20x employee is not making 80% less than a median 20x employee anywhere else. At that echelon the pay differences based on location, if they exist at all, are insignificant compared to base.
I'm glad you said this because it's exactly the problem I've been obsessed with
I think it's absolutely viable and arguably should become the standard approach in time
I think it's overwhelmingly due to very very few people developing new greenfield software who are comfortable working with formal models
The talent pool for ATP devs is very small and specialized and they've only been financially justifiable when working on an established mission-critical system, like Lean's creator working at MSFT to catch Windows 7 bugs with SMT solving
Ironically I think these cases where formal models are clumsiest: using FP langs to retroactively model to C/C++ legacy programs
The benefits of formal verification are 10x easier to achieve if they are the foundation vs shoehorned in after IMO
Old man yelling at cloud
reply