HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | notthemessiah's commentslogin

You don't have to imagine it, it's already happened when a teenage son talking to Gemini on the family iPad managed to get his entire family and all their business accounts banned from all Google services:

https://www.pcworld.com/article/3104521/teenagers-gemini-mis...


April fools?!

"According to Google, the situation described by that Reddit poster simply isn’t how account bans work. If one account violates Google’s TOS, that particular account may be eligible for a ban, but the ban doesn’t “stick” to the hardware, and just because other people logged in on the same device wouldn’t mean they automatically get banned, too."

Maybe not on purpose but this is known to be not how it works (amazing that being said on HackerNews): https://jackyan.com/blog/2026/04/family-loses-all-their-acco... https://www.androidauthority.com/google-account-bans-3654171...


So all this time the China Social Credit Score meme was just a prophecy for the US.


No.

This article was about a family in the UK.

China social credit score is a government policy which comes with government punishments.

This incident is about Google enforcing contract terms on a Google account.

What we should learn from the story is that consolidation of all services into a single account with a single company means increased harm if any contract violations are enforced.

If you get banned from an airline for violating a company policy, your life isn't over. Flying is a little less easy or maybe a little more expensive / friction. But that's different from the government banning you from flying on any aircraft.


This is why I don’t ever voluntarily use my Google account for anything. Ever.

Well, other than YouTube. Because I can get banned from YouTube and then that’s all my account was ever used for. And maybe I would just sign up with a different account then.


I think this is the core learning of this issue: design your accounts such that if one of your accounts is banned, there is minimal blast damage.

In security / military, this concept is "resilience". Businesses call this "business continuity planning".


[flagged]

> It only makes Google look unprofessional and paranoid

Yet, the stock ticker kept on rising after the incident.


People who never had speech what? No one would agree with banning people for their private speech in Europe.


> we’re the guys who defeated them

Are you?

You personally were one of the guys that defeated the nazis?

How about the current leader of America, was he one of the guys that defeated them?

You shouldn't even coast on your own success, but you definitely can't coast on the success of people who are not you, much less do so nearly a century later.


It was of course Palantir's Project Maven which lead us to drop a $2.5M missile on over 120 schoolchildren:

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-iran-school-attack/


It's the same pattern we see in predictive policing where "AI" is being used to manufacture probable cause, but instead of just using it to harass minorities as cops do, the people doing the policing are people actively trying to start Armageddon and the end times because they believe they are doing God's work. So they spend our long-range missiles stockpile to blow up schools because AI told them to.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/sep/02/jd-vance-god...

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-iran-school-attack/


There's a big difference between "AI is creating misinformation and intelligence failures that could compound, especially given the fact that in a pre-AI world we came to the brink of nuclear warfare" vs the AI Doomerism of "Super-intelligent AI will kill us all in some mysterious way" of the AI "safety" TESCREAL cult, often used to hype up their own product capabilities.


In other cases, use of Palantir's AI-powered Project Maven lead to us using our long range $2.5M Tomahawk missiles to blow up an Iranian school along with over 100 schoolchildren, and humans in the loop did nothing to stop the accumulation of intelligence failures from the overreliance on AI. Palantir-funded politician JD Vance said he's doing God's work and "if that leads to the end times, OK".

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-iran-school-attack/


> the end times

This is a nod to the evangelicals, JD Vance says things people like to hear, he rarely believes them (imo) as he seems to lack any convictions, willing to "adjust" his view to whatever suits the times (and his political career). The guy called Trump "America's Hitler" and is now VP...

On the murder of Iranian school girls, that seems more a process failure than straight up Ai. The database had outdated information, which should have been a big flag to go get updated information (I assume our observation capabilities are much better than 10 years ago)

That being said, the Ai being around made those humans sloppy, they also have a boner for bombs


The only reason why Putin is there now is because we strongly backed Boris Yeltsin despite his unpopularity, we interfered with the 1996 election in order to prevent Communist Party challenger Gennady Zyuganov from winning re-election amidst disastrous liberalization policies and lowering life expectancy, and then Boris Yeltsin ended up appointing Putin, who did war crimes in Chechnya in an effort to appear tough as a strongman against the separatist threat. In 2001, the NYT had op-eds from Thomas Friedman that were "Rootin' for Putin". Had we not interfered, we probably would have had another Gorbachev.


Good:

The Open Web

Bad:

Insta requiring login Facebook requiring login Xitter requiring login


Yes, you want a space only for those who think the same as Elon Musk, with his thumb being pressed down on the algorithm which you have no choice but to use.

On Bluesky/ATProto, I am free to chose my own algorithm or my own client software and affiliate with the people I want to. My data is always my own because I can host it on my own PDS. On Mastodon, I have similar freedoms, and you can opt into bridging ATProto with ActivityPub through Bridgy Fed. I like the freedom of the open web, but I guess not everybody thinks the same as me.


Bluesky, like Mastodon, is built on an open network on open source code. Run your own data server and moderation services that cater to your needs. Many are already doing it: Northsky, Eurosky, Blacksky, etc. If you want to live in a safe space isolated from the mainnet and its allegedly toxic users, you can do that too: Roundabout is built on ATProto but run on its own network, also Truth Social and Threads are forked versions of Mastodon but federated with nobody (Threads used to have opt-in Mastodon federation before Facebook decided they no longer want users to be able to do that).


Meta also including CSAM in their ads, computer generated in the US and real abuse materials in South Asia:

https://www.wired.com/story/meta-failed-to-catch-hundreds-of...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: