HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | notpachet's commentslogin

"Concordantly, while your first question may be the most pertinent, you may or may not realize it is also the most irrelevant."

- The Architect


Haha, I didn't even realize that what I said was similar to that scene. Rather chilling and freaky...gives me goosebumps!

Greatly reduce the role of speculative derivatives

I'm thinking of the scene from Zoolander where Mugatu dresses up as Little Cletus to advocate for child labor.

This is not digital minimism. Digital minimism would be:

- Not using social media at all

- Not using your phone at all

- Not using AI at all


Actually if we take the phrase to refer to Cal Newport's book, no. What you're describing is digital abstinence. From the article,

> Explore ways of greatly decreasing or scoping your social media use ... Get the information benefits of the platform without getting sucked in to the vortex

This is more or less what Newport is recommending. Find ways to get the benefit of digital technology while refusing the manipulative aspects and other downsides.

EDIT: oops, TFA doesn't actually mention the book, I thought it did. I think this point still stands: "minimal" does not mean "none".


I am not describing digital abstinence. Note that I did not mention abstaining from:

- the web (I am posting on HN after all, although I recommend a very stripped down browsing experience)

- email

- general computer use

It's telling that you interpreted that (rather circumscribed) list as total digital abstinence. Social media, smartphones, and AI are all relatively recent appearances on the digital stage.


That's fair, though I was somewhat responding to the short list of topics from the article and discussion in this thread.

I still don't think minimalism inherently demands what you're suggesting. If you don't find social media has any beneficial uses for you, it makes sense to cut it out of your life completely. Someone else might find they need some specific things from it, and decide to keep some engagement - on their own carefully dictated terms.


Also fair.


I don’t have a phone, I don’t have an account on any AI (though google search gets me)

No AI is easy, I don’t want it.

No phone is inconvenient sometimes, but I’m well aware I don’t want my life to be more convenient, I want it to be more fulfilling. I do things that are inconvenient because I want to. Bake bread, chop wood to heat our house, hunt to fill the freezer. I talk to people face to face, I live basically the same as I did as an adult from 2000 onwards.

I spend my days outside where there is no cell service anyway, and have no interest in being contacted or contacting others. The people with me are who I want to spend time with.


It's virtue signaling with extra steps


> The central argument is that AIs, living inside datacenters, won't be able to evaluate the "coherence" of software "beyond the human ceiling"

Actually, the article states that AI will easily be able to handle increases beyond the human ceiling as long as those increases follow a linear curve, not an exponential curve.

So your whole critique dissolves. Sorry!


I think you maybe didn't read my comment carefully. The article says AI will have to talk to outside the datacenter to do this, I'm saying it won't.


> - Any (super)intelligence caches work > - Any (super)intelligence _wants to create stable abstractions_

This is a higher-order rephrasing of the "intelligence is compression" argument.


"What I cannot create, I do not understand"

- Feynman


> Let's be better please.

That rhetorical horse left the allegorical barn a long time ago.


> if you can do the worst “bad” thing possible, you can also do the best “good” thing possible

You say this like it's a truism, but I don't think it is. The bad things may be categorically easier than the good things. It's easier to destabilize a delicate system than to stabilize it. It's easier to break something than to fix it.


That's pretty good.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: