HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | noja's commentslogin

I have a light with a controller on the cord: brightness up/down, power. I can't use a smart plug with it because it always defaults to off. Any ideas?

Cut the controller off and use the smart plug to control brightness. You might need to open it up and replace the power supply.

I'm going to guess that you will spend more money on this than just buying a light that has smart features compatible with your smart home ecosystem. You can't mix two smart systems on one cord - this has never worked. Where to put the smart is a tricky question as there are pros and cons to every answer, but in general the smarts need to be in exactly one place or things won't work.


How would one control brightness via a smart plug?!

Smart outlets that support dimming. You also need a dimmable bulb, but these are generic and cheap compared to a smart bulb.

turn it on/off really fast

The relay clicking is a feature so you can tell the brightness audibly :)


Because the news is in bed with them too.

Because most people don't give a shit until something negative happens to them from that direct source.

Yeah. This is exactly the problem. There is too much of a disconnect from the action to the impact in this case. I think if most people saw precisely what data is collected on them and how it is used (and how often it is part of data breaches from these identity resolution platforms and third parties), I think they'd care more.

But nearly everyone has more urgent and pressing concerns like making monthly rent or a medical bill or gas money. So ACR on a TV doesn't register.


> if most people saw precisely what data is collected on them and how it is used (and how often it is part of data breaches from these identity resolution platforms and third parties), I think they'd care more.

What are the chances of an individual being negatively affected in a serious way?

Intuitively, I expect it to be so negligible that it isn't worth losing sleep over.


I would say the chances of a negative impact is on par with the chances of negative impacts on most of the hottest debate topics such as guns and abortion. Identity theft, swatting/doxxing, and stalking can have serious impacts and are not that uncommon. They're just uncommon enough that most people don't care until it happens to them.

It's more profitable for LG to sell your data to advertisers than to build and sell the TV itself

The negative effect is the exact sky high prices that Americans keep complaining about. The point of all that advertising data is to nudge you towards accepting higher prices or buying things you otherwise wouldn't.

Every dollar of revenue in the advertising industry is money taken from consumers and spent on unproductive waste to get you to spend more money instead of anything like making a product better or investing in capacity or researching and developing new products.

Google makes money by making you spend more money. Facebook makes money by making you spend more money.


Still low, but people do register creepiness when they directly see the creepiness, even if nothing resulted from it yet.

This is one of those things that is hard to quantify. Although I'm sure someone has. It negatively impacts society overall, very slowly over time. It has the effect of eroding private life in subtle way that it's barely noticeable until we find ourselves in a surveillance state where corruption is everywhere. Let me know if that sounds familiar to you.

I did a presentation on surveillance capitalism awhile back[0]

[0]: https://www.scottrlarson.com/presentations/overcoming-survei...


> What are the chances of an individual being negatively affected in a serious way?

Perhaps if said individual is a politician and a television is compromised to record what happens in their home (or even bedroom).

Or perhaps compromise televisions in hotel rooms (politician or not).


I really don't think most people would care more when you show them examples of others. Some people would, but most would not. We see this all the time with legislation around rights in the US. Much of the voting population lack the capacity for deep critical thought and don't care to practice empathy from even a devil's advocate perspective. Stuff like tracking speech/identity online, abortion debate, gun debate, etc. Nobody cares unless they are directly affected.

Take guns for example. If you use guns, then you see a value to them and generally oppose mire restrictions. If you have been shot or robbed with a gun (or know people who have), then you dont see the value of guns and want more restrictions. If you are neither of these things then its easy to not care and say sure to more restrictions because they don't impact you and aound like they might provide some benefit, especially if just looking at the surfqce level stats. Same concept for abortion and online tracking/identity, especially once you mix in the think-of-the-children arguments in each of these.


And something negative hardly ever happens to them, or anyone, from that direct source, so why spend a brain cell on it.

Or because it's so secretive the people don't even know the source was from their device spying on them. "Oh, some hacker on the darknet stole my data" is the track that many non-tech people would see this.

The worst thing for privacy advocates is that there has yet to be a general public reckoning with the ad-economy of the last 20 years.

For all intents and purposes, the average person who has paid no mind to their privacy over that time period is really no better or worse off than the person who has devoted hours to combating all forms of invasion.

If there was a mass scale visible event of privacy loss, i.e. Meta somehow ends up in a shamelessly evil sociopaths hands who decides to start very publicly embarrassing random people with privately collected data, there would be very swift and immediate action (yes the parallels here are not lost on me, scale is the difference)

Just look at datacenters. The public didn't even know what a DC was 6 months ago, and now politicians are getting elected to ban them. What happened? AI gave the mass public a common sensation of fear. Privacy has still not had it's "AI fear" moment.


> Meta somehow ends up in a shamelessly evil sociopaths hands

It's not clear that it isn't already, but you know, lawful evil rather than chaotic evil.


You see that, Timmy? Every time someone complains about something, somenone says that it happens because no one cares. What’s the logical conclusion, then? To not care yourself. Because it would be too difficult to change anything if you’re completely alone. And so you have thousands of people each in their own bubble, each thinking that they are alone in caring about, well, anything, and that therefore nothing can be done.

they should portray the tv companies as child predators that spy and record children , cuz they are perverts and need this data feed their sick habits and csam training models. cuz atleast think of the children , while u fudge the adults.

Because they have other things to worry about. Certainly you realize how privileged a world you have to live in to be able to spend time worrying about whether your TV is spying on you, right?

Sure, but I would hope food, shelter, clothing, and not being spied on would be available to most citizens, and not just those who are privileged.

You put those things in the same sentence but they don't even remotely carry the same weight. People are sick and dying and have to weigh weather or not they want to declare bankruptcy or go to the doctor. Or buy their medication vs buying food. Their TV serving them directed ads isn't even in the same universe.

You're arguing the same thing, just from a different perspective.

Ah yes, because there are people who are hungry in the world, nobody should be concerned about anything until world hunger is solved.

I just said they aren't in the same universe and it's unrealistic to think TV ads are on the radar for the average person struggling to pay bills.

Ok sure, but if you're going to play that card, then you have to also say that they can and should recognize that those "other" things are often also symptoms of the same disease.

People are capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time (and they are capable of placing appropriate energy towards the walking to not trip because they were too focused on the gum chewing...)


I'n not "playing that card", i'm explaining that the "because the news is in bed with them" is not even close to a major reason why they don't care. You are correct they can walk and chew gum, but maybe not spin 1000 plates in the air at once.

When people have tons of things to deal with, this falls by the wayside, news or not.

When they don't, sure, maybe the news would matter more.


On the flipside, how fucked up the world is that TVs spying on you had become normalized.

The problem isn't with people being too busy, it shouldn't be up to the people, it should be a government regulation problem. There's a lot of 'todo' around potential breaches of PII, so why not do something about the ridiculously large and seemingly increasing trade in exactly that from almost anything you purchase nowadays, including the place you purchase it from. And they're all selling it to aggregators and advertisers and any other shady c*nt with enough cash to buy it.

... and now it's all going to be fed into AI for additional pattern matching and de-aggregation and re-identification, because that's where the return on investment is. And once it's in there, there ain't no cleaning it out again. You're in the corpus, all your personality fingerprints, forever.

Gross governmental negligence across the entire West.


And how privileged a world the _other_ people live in where someone else is worrying about it _for_ them.

The news? Or the underprivileged? The news doesn’t cater to the underprivileged in general, and might well be “in bed with” companies on this point.

It’s curious this ritual of relatively well-off individuals—and your bio supports that theory—pointing fingers at each other for having privilege. Certainly when they are talking about a topic that affects everyone with a TV, not whatever people of their means get up to that the underprivilged don’t.

People who care could do the work for all of us. It’s not like everyone needs to care about surveillance in television gadgets in order to make a difference.

Or, you know, not necessarily that focused. The comment you are replying to just said that the news are in bed with companies. That often generalizes beyond tech gadgets.


Can you extend it to find out which of my neighbors has a low battery in their smoke alarm?

Will the insurance pay out on this? It would be negligent to have this exposed to the internet - was it?


Especially given the recent precedence of hacked freezers.


That's an interesting angle, that would explain why some bothered to hack fridges and waste food.


How do they have the money for this?


Binance makes a lot of money. Most obviously from things like trading fees, also by trading currency itself (FTX-style) and by lending all the assets that are "on" their own blockchain BSC


Peter pays Paul, works until Peter wants his money.


Signal is not good for normies: compare sending a message with Signal to WhatsApp. Didn’t go through? WhatsApp will try try try to resend. Signal tries far less then shows the dreaded red exclamation point. Not great while travelling or with poor reception.


Signal developer here: we should retry with reasonable backoff for 24 hours before showing a delivery failure. If that's not your experience, please file a bug if you get the time!


Thank you for all you do. All of my grandparents joined Signal to message me and they have no issues for the most part. Although, one of them didn't know to press the download icon on photos I sent. I'm not sure why they weren't downloaded automatically.

Also please accept cryptocurrency for buying username-based accounts. The overlap between people that want to buy an account and those that want to use a fully identified payment method is not a lot.


I spend about half of every year traveling the mountains and deserts of the world, often ones with poor infrastructure. I use Signal more than any other messenger app, and I have never had the deliverability issues you complain about; messages do all get through eventually.


It’s a nice idea, but isn’t it a bit pointless if the law is not being applied?


Is git pointless for code that is not run?


Claude will/did set the UA to your email on a GET


Yeah but that was because it was gently asked to please not. I mean running a firewall/proxy that actually does it.


What is the CT log for then, if not to log that?


CT is for logging certificates from trusted CAs. Logging certificates from untrusted CAs is out of scope, and can be harmful as untrusted certificates could be used to spam the log until it's unavailable.

Of course, the notion of "trusted" is complicated. These CAs are no longer trusted by up-to-date clients, but out-of-date clients may continue to trust them. The needs of up-to-date clients take priority over the needs of out-of-date clients.


Alice User goes to Bob's Website on the wifi at Eve's Coffeeshop. Can Eve read or inject sensitive information into Alice's browsing session?

Normally Eve's attempts fail because Alice requires a message to be signed with the private key matching the public key in a certificate for bob.example.com signed by a legitimate CA.

Unfortunately Bob bought his CA from Mal's Domains, and Mal is working with Eve for some reason (for example, Mal has been bribed, hacked, intimidated, legally pressured, etc.)

So in addition to Bob's regular on-the-books cert, Mal issues a second off-the-books cert for bob.example.com and gives it to Eve.

With CT, Alice's browser doesn't just require the cert's pubkey, it requires the server to provide a Merkle proof it was included in a CT log.

The CT log puts Eve and Mal on the horns of a dilemma: If they keep their new cert out of the CT logs, Alice's browser won't accept it. If they put it in the CT logs, Bob can read the log himself (it's public) and Bob can say "Hold it! I didn't order this!"

Bob will switch away from Mal as a TLS provider and complain "Hey everybody, Mal issued this cert I didn't order, customers should stop using him and the people who create CA lists for browsers and OS's should closely investigate whether Mal's CA activities are legitimate." Mal can't deny issuing the questionable certificate, the evidence is in public append-only CT logs for everyone to see.


Note the positioning for this is different: imperfect family, non-pristine home, dirty clothes.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: