HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | nnx's commentslogin

> No LLMs for brainstorming and then sharing the results of that brainstorming, even if you create the prose.

I can understand the no automated AI contribution point of view, but going overboard with the above that is also completely unenforceable makes the policy look dumb.


Unenforceable - sure, but it's interesting and I see the logic. While LLMs are extremely useful, I find they homongenise things. Claude text is instantly identifiable and now all my co-workers presentations and docs sound like it. I'm sure that extra effort helps differentiate things (so many LLM generated sites look the same so not many people put in the effort).

A project without everyone putting the same filter between them and the work they submit might help a project evolve in interesting and different ways.


I kinda wish I could identify it like you guys. Then again, I might be more depressed if I could.


> ...is also completely unenforceable...

It's exactly as enforceable as when projects require you to swear that you can legally assign copyright of your submissions to the entity that runs the project, and/or swear that your submissions don't infringe on anyone's patents, and/or -as the ReactOS project does- swear that you've never seen the code that the project is reimplementing.

If someone swears that they're conforming to the rules and you later find out that they lied, then you ban them forever, publicly announce why, and -if needed- purge their contributions and do your best to alert affected users about the tainted versions. These sorts of policies work for the same reason ordinary doors and door locks work: most folks aren't profoundly antisocial shitbags.


it is enforceable, just the wrong rule.

the rule is ultimately "dont submit stuff where only your llm session knows whats going on"

if you brainstorm with an llm, then rewrite the llm prose but have no understanding, youve still broken the rule.

if you understand what it suggested, why, and so on, then you do know whats up, and thats unenforceable, but who cares


It's not enforceable, because the people in charge don't have any knowledge of whether I consulted an LLM while writing this comment.

You said it yourself - the enforceable policy is a a different, and much more reasonable policy. If the rule is "ultimately" something else, you can in fact just make that the rule. Or include a parenthetical explanation.

Rules are the ideal place for being pedantic and detailed! That's the whole point of rules - ultimately, the rule is the rule that was actually written down. Not anything else.


A rule doesn't have to be perfectly enforceable in order to serve a useful purpose. The rule assumes good intent on the participants, and it communicates what kind of behavior is welcome vs unwelcome. The submitter knows whether they used an LLM or not. If they want to lie about it, that's on them - I'm sure they can come up with whatever justification they want for that, but it's ultimately antisocial and gross behavior.


The pricing is surprising, Data Produced at $0.04/GB seems reasonable (when compared to other clouds event streams) but Data Consumed being at the same $0.04/GB is rather steep...

This means actual usage is $0.08/GB in the simplest case (one consumer) but fan-out consumer strategies get very expensive very fast.


> Some days, I would seriously rather work at Wendy's.

Narrator: He would not.


If such a job paid even half as much, I would quit today. I can continue to program computers as a hobby. Occupational programming has essentially eroded my passion over the years.

Money is not important to me insofar as I have enough to live an average life. I don't need anymore than that.


is flickering fully fixed yet?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: