HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | netsharc's commentslogin

Google did announce they were killing Assistant on the phone in September. I haven't updated my phone, and I still have it. I started vibe coding a replacement app (using Gemini-assisted Android Studio), but lost motivation. The speech recognition even happens on device

And I have a Lenovo Smart Clock, when they kill Assistant for this, it'll be my first manufacturer-induced e-waste. It'll make me hate Google even more, just telling the device what time to wake me up, or adding reminders for the next day as they come to my mind as I'm trying to sleep, has been very convenient the last ~4 years of my life.


I went on a backpacking tour. My aim was to take a lot of pictures, but I didn't want to carry a laptop. So my SD card backup setup was: a Raspberry Pi clone, a card reader, a 500G Sandisk USB3 external NVMe disk the size of a credit card and the thickness of maybe 3 credit cards and a power bank.

The backup routine was:

1. Plug the card to the card reader, plug it into one of the USB3 ports of the Pi.

2. Plug the NVMe disk into another USB3 port.

3. Power the contraption from my USB powerbank.

4. Plug the phone to the Pi on another USB port. Enable network sharing over USB.

5. Connect Bluetooth keyboard to the phone.

6. Open a terminal on the phone,

7. Find out the IP address of the Pi that the phone's DHCP server gave

8. SSH into the Pi.

9. Run rsync to copy files from the SD card to the NVMe disk (luckily the Linux distro auto-mounts the USB storage devices).

After all that's done I can plug the NVMe disk straight to my phone to browse the images...

I've been thinking of creating a Pi distro that creates a WiFi network, and use a Jenkins-like web UI so I can just plug everything in and control the procedure from the phone's browser. One day..!


I've looked into this kind of thing maybe 5 years ago, and there were some (expensive) devices meant for ingesting SD cards onto SSDs (either internal or USB). Some just had buttons, and some had small screens with status etc. I think there there were some with wifi portals for management. Now it looks like there are are more cheaper options that are for a more general audience.

Question: is there a reason that you couldn't skip the pi and just use a USB-C hub and your phone to copy from the reader to a SSD? pre USB-C I did this but it was kludgy using apple's "camera connection kit".


I wasn't sure how much power the whole copy process would take. Gemini tells me with the phone I had then even a powered USB hub would not be charging the phone when it's on USB OTG; and the killer argument is that the phone only had USB 2.0.

> I wasn't sure how much power the whole copy process would take.

It seems likely that whatever it is, it would be less than powering an entire additional computer like a Raspberry Pi. :)

> Gemini tells me with the phone I had then even a powered USB hub would not be charging the phone when it's on USB OTG

What phone are we talking about? There's always been lot of weird information out there about USB OTG capabilities; it always seems like it's more mystery than verified fact. This quagmire is all that Gemini has to work with.

To add my own anecdote: There's certainly a lot I that I haven't done, but every time I've attempted to power a phone or tablet while it was doing USB OTG, I've been successful. (I don't think I ever tried any of that prior to about 15 years ago, though.)

> the killer argument is that the phone only had USB 2.0

That's a limit. USB 2 only has one 480Mbps channel and it is shared for both TX and RX.

But still: It can copy from one device to another at around 15 or 20 megabytes per second.

That's enough to fill up a 500GB SSD in between about 7-9 hours of total runtime. Not great, but perhaps not terrible.

If a day's shooting generated (say) 10GB of new stuff to back up, then: That's only about 10 minutes per day for backups. Backups can happen while I fuss around with dinner or whatever.

---

Your solution is clever and I do like it, but I think if I were backpacking then I'd rather take an extra battery than a Raspberry Pi and a keyboard. The battery is a better multitasker, I think. :)

How was the trip?


Sheesh, people recommending how I solve problems I had 7 years ago...

Why not 512GB SD card? (honest question. I'm shooting with two CF Type A 512GB cards, and have 512GB SD card as a backup to offload stuff if I'm not in reach to my SSD drives. Seeing this complicated setup for... 500GB looks a bit strange to me.)

I would like to backup my photos as I go, just in case the camera was stolen/broken, or if the SD card gets damaged for whatever reason. Although I don't shoot so many, so I'm just dumping some photos into my phone via wifi each day.

Dump as you go?

Seems like dumping to Dropbox as final destination would be best. As long as you aren’t in some austere environment


Looked at this several years ago and came across these. Pretty close to your setup but NVMe is missing

1. https://github.com/bezineb5/PiBackup

2. https://github.com/nickelsound/little-backup-box


So, why not a USB hub and use the phone to copy from card reader to NVME? Or even simpler, just the NVME and put the card directly into the phone?

No powerbank, no Raspberry clone, no card reader, no networking, no ssh.


I am going exactly that all the time.

Got a 1TB SD card in my phone, and a USB-C card reader (you don't need a hub anymore).


Out of curiosity wouldn't it have been possible to do the same with a small four port USB-C hub plugged into an android phone? And then plug two things into the USB-C hub, a microsd-to-usb reader and the USB3 external NVME drive. This would allow for the full set of CLI file system manipulation tools and things like rsync to be run on the mounted filesystem of the SD card and/or the NVME drive, assuming installation of something like termux.

On a daily basis very easy to use an android GUI file management application to copy or move all the files from the microSD card to the NVME storage, doing a bulk select and then 'move' to mounted destination. Or write a tiny shell script that can run in termux that moves all new files that don't exist in the NVME drive destination.

If I were doing this and I had some reasonable level of confidence in the wifi where I was staying temporarily, I'd try to set up a script to periodically do an incremental back up from the mounted filesystem of the NVME drive to a small fileserver that lives in my home office, via VPN.


Not the same goal but I recently wanted to show a friend in a bar some photos I made that day - I didn't had a laptop or a tablet nor I wanted to show it on that small screen. So I plugged my P1100 into my phone and it worked flawlessly - especially considering how much the shitshow is the official Nikon app.

PirateBox was a project: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PirateBox , but their website is gone now. I even have a TP-Link "3G modem with access point" that I got it to run on.

https://well-it-wasnt-me.github.io/PirateBox/

https://www.instructables.com/Raspberry-Pi-PirateBox/



Typical terribly written content farm slop. (Some of the short sentences make me suspicious about AI slop, but nothing jumped out at me to indicate it). It's repetitive and as thin on information as the air is at 38000ft.

I did learn that if you're heavy and you try to cruise at much thinner air, it means a higher angle of attack which means more drag. It made me realize that airliner forward movement is a combination of jet thrust and gliding. And that like paper airliners, even airliners has a glide component.

Also I hated the moronic term "delete" in the sentence

> Depending on the mission, airlines could install or delete optional auxiliary center tanks in the belly hold


Delete actually is the industry term used for uninstalled optional equipment.

If only they moved to America, corruption and dishonesty can get you to the top of the richest list, and the top job in government! (Actually no, only American born corrupt twats can be president)

If you made a coherent point it escaped me

Add it to the long list of things you can't fathom...

Huh, I suppose LLMs should be clever enough to understand "money laundering", but that query seems to need a lot of education.

My guess is it's quite useful to see money movements (e.g. 43,200 Eur transferred to account $FOO, a few hours later the same amount moves from $FOO to $BAR, a few days later a bill of the same amount appears in someones's inbox, etc.


I still recall the ick I got when I saw this screen when I opened Firefox: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1791524

Oh you're really sensitive then. Even a benign "thank you" screen that can be closed in 1 second and forgotten eternally is intolerable to contemporary demanding users and causes extreme emotions. LOL!

I asked myself "Should I waste my time and energy engaging with a dismissive tool who doesn't get it, try to make him see my point; or do I just shut up and let him be the tool that he is?". You're reading this so I picked poorly...

It's not just a "thank you" screen. This has 58 kudos so that's 60 people "really sensitive": https://connect.mozilla.org/t5/discussions/mozilla-now-only-... . And it shows how much more crap some people working for Mozilla spent their time implementing.

Ah yeah, let's not be sensitive to emotions like what the word "love" evokes being used cheaply to try to win browser userbase. Maybe whoever made that has collective autism and doesn't know how human emotion works. The effect that screen has is that it's made me never want to donate to Firefox...


> IspName-AE32C

Hah, I wonder if people's been dissuaded from changing their ISP because they can't stand the hassle of modifying all their devices (although, actually, they just have to connect to the new AP whenever they spot that a device is offline).

But yeah, looking at the network list on the phone in a neighborhood will get you dozens of IspPrefix- networks.

On the flip side, imagine if more people knew UTF-8 is fine for SSIDs, including all the emojis.


The US has Amber, etc, Alert. I wonder if anyone's asked the GSM consortium for a new type of cell tower alert broadcast that would put phones in the area on silent, to prevent them beeping and be homing beacons for bullets.

What would be a good color for this alert? (although Amber Alert's name comes from a kidnapped child named Amber).

This comment written with a lot of tongue-in-cheek.


infrared alert.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: