HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ndiddy's commentslogin

> At the minimum, getting money out of politics and electoral reform feels like a good start.

One of the incoming Democratic representatives who flipped a Republican district said that he wouldn't support Hakeem Jeffries for speaker unless he committed to votes on a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United and on ending the war in Iran. In response the Democratic leadership threatened to make his life hell for the next two years, then try to primary him in 2030. https://www.wosu.org/politics-government/2026-11-11/rep-elec...

I'm not sure how you could accomplish any sort of meaningful reform electorally when party leadership behaves like this.


I think it's important to make the public aware that if your threat model involves keeping your activities private from the government of your country, sending anything sensitive over the internet is risky. This is regardless of how much a provider claims to care about your privacy, or how much they brag about encryption technology etc.

Doing anything that you want kept private from the government is risky. This is true whether you use the internet, snail mail, or vocal cords.

AFAIK Github voluntarily chooses to process 1201 claims as a risk mitigation strategy. The DMCA prohibits trafficking in circumvention mechanisms and doesn't include a "safe harbor" provision for them, so Github could conceivably also be named in a lawsuit if they chose to wait for a court order to take them down.

I found a helpful one yesterday. I had to look at something on an iBook G3. When I turned on the laptop, the trackpad wasn't working. A post on the support forum said that it was because the settings on the trackpad management IC got hosed, and you could fix it by holding down the power button until you heard a beep. Sure enough, this got the trackpad working.

The last time I looked at the support forum (a few months ago when I was trying to force an iTunes Match sync) I also got a useful solution.


IIRC part of that was because Maxis were having a hard time getting publishers to understand that people would want to play a game with no win/lose state or scoring. The scenarios were another concession to this.

Yeah I read a good article a couple months ago ( https://archive.is/OzTYO ) about how Taiwan was growing closer to China as they viewed any hypothetical conflict with them as unwinnable. I particularly like this anecdote about a couple of neocons who went to Taiwan to try to convince them to fight:

> In the southern city of Kaohsiung, a group of retired Taiwanese naval officers invited the Americans to an ice-cream parlor and, over a round of sundaes, told them to stop preparing for war. They said that Taiwan possessed neither the determination nor the means to fight, and that the U.S. would never intervene to help. The defeatist attitude angered the two Americans, for what it said about Taiwan’s morale and for a more personal reason: Heginbotham’s son, who serves on a U.S. submarine in the Pacific, could be sent to fight in a war with China. “Sorry for my language, but what the fuck?” he recalled saying. “My son’s life is on the line to defend you guys.”

His complaint is that a hypothetical peaceful reunification would somehow be more dangerous to his active duty son than the war that he's advocating for.


Seems more like "We're so committed to your defense that we're risking our children's lives for you, so don't surrender in advance assuming we won't fight."

Some people find this confusing. Section 1201 of the DMCA has two parts. One part bans circumventing DRM, and the other part bans distributing devices that can circumvent DRM. The Section 1201 exemptions published by the Copyright Office only apply to the first part, not the second. I imagine it works this way because the companies lobbying for the DMCA to be passed didn't want to make it legal to sell or distribute circumvention devices as long as someone has a legal right to break the DRM, as that would defeat the purpose of the law.

As far as I understand it, the way it works is that section 1201 of the DMCA has two parts. One part prohibits breaking DRM, and one part prohibits trafficking in devices or software intended to circumvent DRM. The part that prohibits breaking DRM has tons of exceptions so previously legal behavior doesn't become illegal just because something has a digital lock. However, the part that prohibits trafficking in circumvention devices has none of these exceptions. That's the part that Nintendo uses to go after emulators.

Emulators have neither "breaking DRM", "circumvention devices" nor circumvention code though.

That's why Nintendo usually tries to avoid going to court for emulators unlike when they sued for the R4 cartridge for example, they are afraid of the result.


Nintendo Switch games are stored as encrypted data, and then decrypted at runtime by the console. Nintendo's legal position is that because the emulator will only run Switch games if the user provides decryption keys dumped from a Switch, it counts as a circumvention device and is therefore illegal to distribute. Nintendo sued Yuzu, one of the most popular Switch emulators, and the Yuzu authors chose to settle rather than going to trial.

That seems like a weak argument, but the courts make all sorts of surprising decisions these days.

In the past, Nintendo tried using their trademark as a watchdog -- the console would reboot if the game did not display it at startup -- then sued unlicensed games for trademark violation. The courts ruled the trademark was purely functional in that use case, and not a trademark, then ruled against Nintendo.

I imagine a similar ruling, if the defense is: The user has a valid key, and a copy of the media. Any circumvention happened before that point in time. We're simply building a compatible device.

Of course, I'm not a lawyer, and the DMCA is a terribly designed law.


> In the past, Nintendo tried using their trademark as a watchdog

That was Sega v Accolade [1]. Although Nintendo also uses boot time trademarks, I don't think they sued over them.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade


That case was before DMCA made it generally illegal to break any copyright protection measure.

It also wasn't protecting the games from being copied. It was protecting Nintendo (actually Sega) from competition from other people making their own games. The Nintendo Game Boy uses the same technique.


Rather than a value judgment of whether or not Nintendo is rightly applying the law, Yuzu settling must be viewed as a fundamental inability for a small group of independent devs to defend themselves against the deep pockets of a famously litigious major global corporation in the modern court system.

Not necessarily, powerful counterparties settle all the time if it's cheaper for both. Yuzu chose not to fight in court, but so did Nintendo.

Wasn't this same thing a huge deal back with the DVD DRM keys? The keys were leaked, but it's technically illegal to distribute software that uses them in unlicensed ways, even if you don't distribute the keys.

> Nintendo's legal position is that because the emulator will only run Switch games if the user provides decryption keys dumped from a Switch

This is not true, Switch emulators can also run unencrypted games / programs if you provide one.

Games are usually shared encrypted, that's true, but that's just a custom, not something required by the emulator.


if you just dump the decrypted memory, you're not "picking the lock" so you should be safe. (don't believe me: IANAL)

Sounds like someone should take them to court.

Apple used nVidia GPUs in most of its computers. Around 2008-2009, nVidia produced a line of faulty GPUs that were used in the Macbook Pro. This led to widespread hardware failures, and was known as "Bumpgate" because the problem was caused by faulty solder bumps inside the GPU chip. nVidia refused to fully reimburse Apple for repairs because it wasn't contractually obligated to do so. In response, Apple switched away entirely from nVidia GPUs.

I think it was well into 2013 because both the 2011 and 2013 MBPs I had suffered from it. but I thought that was an apple issue (ie not soldering the dicrete gpu well enough to save money on it)

after the 2 faulty products in a row, I haven't bought an apple product since.


You are missing out, the M series laptops are insanely good. Now wondering how the field of ML would have developed if Apple had had Nvidia chips all the way...

This is not 2020 and nobody is missing out not having to deal with macOS in 2026.

This is truly the year of the Linux pcs and you’re missing out running anything else.


> the year of the Linux pcs

How so?


No, it was Nvidia because of the way the BGA solder was done. The problem was across manufacturers.

The infamous early 2011 MBPs had AMD GPUs that basically crapped out the entire logic board. That was what got me to switch back to Windows.

And that's kidna funny because now Apple Sillicon has pretty great graphics on their own.

Maybe that's the lesson he learned and why he _supposedly_ was making sure his GPUs were still getting to China. Because he knows that the alternative would lead to good Nvidia Chinese competitor later on


Reminds me of how some of the dev versions of Snow Leopard still boot on PowerPC.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: