HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | munificent's commentslogin

There is a thing where once a certain topic catches the public interest, journalists are incentivized to report other articles on that same topic and it forms a sort of self-reinforcing zeitgeist.

It's not quite Baader-Meinhof because there is deliberate action involved, but it can also make a trend appear out of what is actually random noise.


I mean, that's true of like most things. People buy things so that they don't have to make them themselves. This is the fundamental premise of markets.

Maybe an important thing to take away from this is that part of life is being forced to sit with uncertainty.


I work on Dart.

A fundamental choice you have to make with a new programming language is how compatible you want it to be with existing languages and their ecosystems. Hewing closely to another language allows you to reuse and build on top of all of the code already written in that language. But it also means that you can be forced to recapitulate features from that language that aren't great. Building a new language and ecosystem from scratch lets you make a clean break from those but at the very large expense of having to build a universe from scratch.

TypeScript took the former approach. All of the world's existing JavaScript code is TypeScript too. You can freely interoperate between TypeScript and JavaScript, keep using your existing JavaScript libraries, and incrementally migrate your JS codebase to TS one file at a time.

At the same time, TypeScript inherits much of the dumb stuff about JavaScript. No real integer type, funny scoping semantics (though strict mode mostly addresses this), extreme dynamism that is hard to fit into static types. The latter is particularly important. TypeScript's type system is deliberately not sound in order to be able to mostly statically type JavaScript while allowing many of the weird and complex design patterns from that language. That in turn means that even fully typed TypeScript programs don't get the fully performance benefits of static types. That's the main reason that the TypeScript compiler itself is no longer written in TypeScript: JS is simply too slow because of dynamic typing.

Dart took a much larger step away from JavaScript. It has its own object model and runtime semantics. With Dart 2.0, it has a fully sound static type system and in 2.12 we shipped sound handling of null. Because these static semantics are fully sound, the compiler can take advantage of types to generate smaller, faster code. Performance is complex, but Dart's runtime performance is in the same bucket as Java and C#, which is about as good as a GC language can get.

The cost is that migrating an existing web application to Dart is pretty much a rewrite. It was really hard for us to get any real traction until Flutter came out. With Flutter, users are already accepting that they are writing a new app for that framework, so the hop to a new language was more manageable.

I don't know how AI affects this calculus. AI can make it much faster to automatically migrate a program from one language to another. But I think it also makes human users more conservative about which language they use. Since they aren't writing as much of the code anyway, they may have less incentive to care about using a "better" language.

I agree completely that Hejlsberg is a star and very tough to compete with. I've always thought of programming languages more as offering different ways to solve problems and less about one trying to win at the expense of another. I don't want Dart to beat TypeScript, I just want Dart to be the best it can be for what it is.


> Since they aren't writing as much of the code anyway, they may have less incentive to care about using a "better" language.

I wonder if it's the opposite (in fact blog posts to that tune were posted here more than once): if LLMs are supposed to be writing most of the code, and taking away the friction of actually writing the code, I guess it means one should pick the language based on project requirements and performance since any language is the exact same to work with.


> There's something to be said for doing things because they are enjoyable. People cook for themselves because they enjoy the process, not just the meal. I climb mountains because it makes me feel good -- I wouldn't take a gondola to the top even if it existed. The 100m race is not run by motorcycles.

Respectfully, but I think you are not introspecting deeply enough here.

Why is cooking enjoyable? Some of it may be purely the tactile sensation of stirring spoons in goop. I suspect that for most people, much of it is a feeling of accomplishment from performing a difficult skill that creates something of value for other people. It's the joy of being known as a good cook, and the satisfaction of making something for people that they might otherwise have trouble getting. How much fun would cooking be if every street corner had a Michelin-starred restaurant giving food away for free? How much would you cook if none of your friends really cared about the results because they can get better food elsewhere, cheaper?

You wouldn't take a gondola to the top of a mountain because you want to be a person who can climb mountains. How much of that desire comes from purely internal accomplishment versus wanting to be seen as a person who can do that hard thing? And what happens to that drive when no one around you cares?

Anthony Gatto was arguably the world's best numbers juggler for many years. Now he runs a concrete company, because it turns out most people just don't really give a shit about juggling. It's not enough for a task to be hard, it needs to be esteemed too.

> Perhaps we will value eachother on an even more* human level, based on how kind and interesting someone is, rather than their economically useful skills and their bank account.*

How is kindness demonstrated in a world where no one wants for anything? How can someone be more interesting than synthetically generated content created specifically attuned to our personal interests?

I would like to believe that many people will still choose reality and real relationships. But given that candy companies are some of the largest private companies in the world, I know that human nature means many people really will just check out and turn into vegetables.

Humans are like border collies. We need some amount of work and struggle to be psychologically healthy. If AI really does deliver us a post-scarcity life (unlikely, given the infinite greed of many of the elites), then I think a whole lot of people are going to lose their minds.


I climb the mountains because I am proud of myself, and I am proud of my own development. Not because I want someone to pat me on the back.

My outlook on life is that it is an experiment where you see how you can develop yourself throughout it. This growth is difficult and beautiful.

I am proud of myself, and the person I have become. I surround myself with people on the same mission.

This article describes a future like WALL-E. It sounds very lonely. I'll be sure to be in the pocket of people who are like minded, and set on their own pursuits.

I am actively choosing an existence where I don't get everything I want. It's the effort that makes it mean something to me, and it's the restrictions that make life worth living.

It might be useful to know that I programmed for >50% of my life, starting when I was 12. It was a huge part of my identity for most of my life. I was known to be extremely good at it. Think: newspaper articles, CEOs flying me out, etc.

Overcoming this entanglement of identity, ego, and competence was one of my proudest achievements in the past 5 years.

I am mostly at peace now, always trying to go further. I hope people like the author can find peace as well.


Today people have basically unlimited access to images of masterful works of art spanning hundreds of years. But they still hang up their kids inferior drawings at their cubicles instead.


Someone that gets it. Lots of odd out of touch takes in this thread. Folks here seem to think we're robots or something, I can't believe the wild things that are said in this thread. Strong believer that "humanity" always wins.


Some people have spent so much time min/maxing their lives that they forget most people don't treat every facet of their existence as something to optimize.


> Why is cooking enjoyable?

Maybe it's about the joy of learning something new every time you cook. Having Michelin star restaurants in your neighborhood would add to that joy, not take away from it.

> I would like to believe that many people will still choose reality and real relationships.

Why would you like to believe that?


The joy of learning something new is very much tied to said thing being meaningful or useful. You could spend the rest of your life memorizing digits of pi and you'd be spending all of it "learning something new" but you wouldn't enjoy it very much.


I only watch the last 30 seconds of every movie because that's where you find out what happened.


Intrinsic motivation exists and is where most creativity comes from


> I suspect that for most people, much of it is a feeling of accomplishment from performing a difficult skill that creates something of value for other people. It's the joy of being known as a good cook, and the satisfaction of making something for people that they might otherwise have trouble getting. How much fun would cooking be if every street corner had a Michelin-starred restaurant giving food away for free? How much would you cook if none of your friends really cared about the results because they can get better food elsewhere, cheaper?

I think it's paradoxical to suggest Michelin-starred restaurants could be everywhere, given the whole point is the travel-worthiness i.e. a scarcity that justified effort.

That aside, to take the strongest form of the argument, I think even if every human being could get their ideal meal, no matter what it is, at any time and for free - and even if the cook in question is only doing it for social reasons - cooking would still be valued. It's the effort put in by a person which is scarce and precious. Even if people were immortal, that time in the present would still be valuable in itself.

> How is kindness demonstrated in a world where no one wants for anything?

Post-scarcity of material things won't sedate humans. Kindness is a thing wanted in and of itself, but more importantly, internal struggles and desires can't all be resolved through material gain.

> How can someone be more interesting than synthetically generated content created specifically attuned to our personal interests?

The answer is apparently, pretty easily? By and large it seems the consensus is social media and digital content are exploiting a niche of providing a low-effort, highly-addictive pastime.


Last I checked chess is still quite popular.


My cynical take is that architecture has been fully captured by the wealthy elite.

The elites like things the masses dislike as a way to signal their social distances from the masses. By designing a building that conforms to their elite taste at the expense of nearly everyone else who has to look at the thing, it reinforces their power and control over the space.

It's the moral equivalent of buying a beachfront property and blasting noise every morning from a giant PA system just so that everyone trying to just relax on the beach knows who is really in charge.


The whole point of architects from the get-go is to have somebody design something different from what the masses have !


Maybe the engine and the wind is an important part of the sonic experience.


You would also probably like this old post of mine:

https://journal.stuffwithstuff.com/2014/12/21/rooms-and-maze...


I REMEMBER THIS! Oh man, I haven't read this in forever. It was one of the blog posts that kicked off what became Iron Arachne, my own procgen project.

Thank you for writing it! I'm going to re-read this.


Oh man, I'd forgotten about this one. Thanks for sharing it again! (And thanks for having done it in the first place!)


damn, I 2015 I used this as a reference for my procedural dungeon crawler. fun flashback.


> Even using a 6|8 would be interesting.

There is a decent amount of pop music in 6/8. I always joke that it's like a hack to making a song better because 6/8 is rare enough that it makes the song sound interesting but common enough to not alienate the listener. It ends up sounding mostly like a hard swung 4/4 but then fills and some melodic lines are just a little bit more rhythmically spicy.

Some examples:

* The Doors - People are Strange

* T. Rex - Hot Love

* Fleetwood Mac - Don't Stop

* Depeche Mode - Personal Jesus

* Marilyn Manson - The Beautiful People

* Green Day - Longview

* Oasis - Lyla

* Blur - Parklife

* Living Things - Bom Bom Bom

* Britney Spears - Womanizer

* Goldfrapp - Strict Machine

* Feist - My Moon My Man

* Gotye - Heart's a Mess

* The Black Keys - Gold on the Ceiling

* Paul Kalkbrenner - The Grouch


Pretty much all of those tracks are 20+ years old though. This discussion is more about modern music


> hot patching will need to itself become fully automated.

Great, even less control over the things we use and more power ceded to corporations.


Due to the small nature of hot patching (eg. bump this dependency, rotate these keys, turn off that config, follow the runbook) it will unlikely need to be a frontier model and is likely able to be done LocalLLM/Jev style decision making rather than having to hand all the keys to frontier model operators.


One more step to just turning it all over to Skynet. It's hilarious how prophetic that movie was.


Do you want your shit hacked? Better patch.


And where does that leave the tenet of auditing patches?


Do you want to get hacked or audit the patch?

The barbarians are at the gates and they're interested in laundering your compute and network for other attacks, scams, and things like transferring CSAM.

How much time do you need to audit? You might have an hour - for now.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: