HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mspecter's commentslogin

In general, yes! We did some follow on work explaining how all of this works, depending on the provider: https://petsymposium.org/popets/2026/popets-2026-0113.pdf


Very cool! I only skimmed Section 4 a bit, but that's really cool!

I was going to ask how the web UIs possibly work if the location is indistinguishable, but I went to the Google Find Hub, and it appears you can't view the location for tags unless you enter your phone's pin code / pattern lock. This must either communicate with the phone or the keys are stored on Google's end.

EDIT: I turned my phone off, and I can still get the location of my keys... surely this doesn't mean the key is stored on their end? Wouldn't be very good E2EE in that case :)


The encryption key is derived from your PIN, it doesn't need to access the phone to do a new derivation.


Last author on the paper here (https://arxiv.org/pdf/2510.00350). Happy to answer any questions!


Also, I'm just the professor, the grad students on it are the real heroes: Akshaya Kumar [1] and Anna Raymaker [2].

[1] https://akumar805.github.io/

[2] https://annaraymaker.dad/


Thanks! Have you considered evaluating the “AppClose” platform in a similar fashion? It is used in family / civil cases to my knowledge. Perhaps another worthwhile avenue of study, perhaps not. Thank you for your time.


Interesting! Hadn't heard of it.


Coauthor here, somewhat surprised to see this on HN. Any thoughts, questions, or feedback welcome.


The paper says ghost protocol has never been implemented, but wasn't it widely used on trump administration version of the signal-custom-client, which sent messages to a ghost account responsible for indexing and backup of plain text copies?


Good point. Most of this was written before the signal-custom-client thing happened, so it wasn't top of mind. We also considered "serious" systems, deployed en masse. Perhaps we should've included this as well.


considering a system used by the white house and Pentagon among others not widely deployed is questionable :)

the timing mistake is on me. i still think this site is about "news". very interesting paper regardless.


Thanks for putting this together. Found via Schneier’s blog; I thought it was a good summary, and perhaps needed information in the face of attacks like Chat Control.


Oh, I didn't realize it'd made it to Schneier's blog, thanks for letting me know!

A goal of the work was to try to explain to a new audience (specifically nontechnical legal folks) the ongoing challenges with Going Dark. Hopefully it helps!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: