HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mrshadowgoose's commentslogin

Hey dude, I don't get the sense you're being malicious, but you might want to consider the following...

I'm a Home Assistant user because I don't like my devices reaching out to random cloud services more than they need to. I suspect quite a number of fellow HA users feel similarly.

Although your intent was probably good, this feature certainly falls into the "more than they need to" bucket and feels hella icky. And yes, I'm very familiar with HIBP and cryptography in general. This simply isn't an opt-out feature I expect in a privacy positioned home automation product.


Proactive public sentiment management to lessen the chance of reactive policies.

In Canada, it's currently vogue to hate on all things American. (I'm making this observation as a Canadian resident)


Nope. This is exactly the same way they fucked up when they had the model quality lead with Gemini 2.5 pro.

They made using it so hard/unclear that myself and every other dev I knew gave up.

It's clear that they still haven't done any organizational self-reflection.


This was my conclusion when I saw the feature for the first time.

One of the open problems at the frontier, as we climb the levels of abstraction towards longer task horizons, is "what's the next step that makes the most sense?". This feedback seems like a frictionless way to gather those yes/no feedback signals in a natural manner to feed into future training runs.


It's tragic to see, and they already made this very same mistake with Gemini 2.5.

They made their model so hard for people to drop into workflows, that people just... didn't.

Lack of adoption caused them to lose out on usage-based training data needed to smooth out their model's rough edges and progress the frontier.


I have said this before here, but. I don't think they care.

Google gains very little by having us use their models for coding. It doesn't help them in their core mission ("to organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful ^W^W^W^W^W^W[and turn it into ad revenue]"), nor would it be anything close to substantial revenue compared to the ads revenue firehose they already have.

They will push AI in a direction that serves their existing goals and service the coding agent model only as is necessary.


Then why don’t they just do that? I read this constantly, that Google has different goals (world models, ad rev, recursive looping, quantum computing AI, magic, whatever weekly hype words go around, etc.), but they continue to try competing with model releases focused on coding performance, benchmark results and agentic harnesses.

If Googles goal was something other than those, why expend Billions in time and effort? Alternatively, they want a part of the regular model use pie, they just struggle to compete. QED, there is no secrete alternate goal here.


Well, I worked there for 10 years and I can tell you that they're incapable of making a singular focused decision and executing on almost anything.

There's likely all kinds of internal competition and disagreements and dysfunctions.

So there's that.

But in the last instance, revenues win. OpenAI and Anthropic have to fight for new revenue sources while Google already has a firehose. The motivations are fundamentally different.


On the off chance there are Google execs going through this thread:

Google, if you've actually managed to catch up again, please don't fuck this up (again).

You made Gemini 2.5 Pro so difficult to use that myself and everyone else I know (who even bothered to try) just gave up and used something else. If you make this hard to access, you're going to miss out on rich usage-based training data that you need to progress your capability frontier. Again.


"lighter" is the revolutionary bit.

A huge impediment to VR uptake is having to go through the process of strapping a brick to one's face.

This isn't quite the "just putting on a pair of glasses" experience, but it's much closer to that than the former.


Its lighter form factor is more evolutionary than revolutionary. The AVP has some unnecessary extras such as the outward-facing display. If Apple wanted, it could make an Apple Vision Air with the latest A-series chip, a much lighter form factor and a much lower price - just like Meta VR Glasses.


More compact lenses are a constant improvement, but one of the main things here is just moving compute and power off of your head. Which many have done before.

Honestly I don't know why that's not more common. I've used puck-based ones, they're great - far less heat and mass on your face is a major benefit. They're also usually easier to plan upgrades for, as the two most costly pieces (which do very different things and have very different progress cycles) are separated.


I frequently have speculative conversations about what (good-leaning) post-AGI societies might look like.

When asked about how one might attain social mobility in such a society, where the intrinsic value of our intelligence and ability to do labor is gone, I unironically respond with "be hot".


some people think that's how humans got so intelligent. actually if you think about it, it's the only way humans could have got so intelligent. brains were our tail feathers for a while.


The arms race is an intrinsic game theoretical property of a multi-adversarial-actor scenario involving exponential growth of a universally potent technology. It's almost certainly winner-take-all, on a global scale, which behooves everyone to participate.

And no, I don't think it will end well.


The actors here are states or corporations embedded in societies that risk growing popular backlash against the technology.

The other factor is that if it is truly an "alien mind", racing incurs risks to all players. In game-theoretic terms it may be more like a stag hunt than a prisoner's dilemma. In which case cooperation is an equilibrium.


No previous technological arms race has ever concluded with a single winner.


This is not an impulse reaction, as I've thought deeply about this for many years, and I'm quite resolute in holding the following view:

Quibbling over the academic nature/definition of "true intelligence" is a terrifically useless endeavor from the lens of evaluating "practical impact to the world".

Regardless of whether or not one academically disagrees that these systems are intelligent, they are clearly already capable of permanently displacing a portion of human-based economic value. A small portion currently, but it's very clear that most computer-bound domains are imminently at-risk.

And that will profoundly affect the world, regardless of whether or not they're "truly intelligent" as per your personal definition.


> Regardless of whether or not one academically disagrees that these systems are intelligent, they are clearly already capable of permanently displacing a portion of human-based economic value.

You say that as if the intelligence con trick were not a major driver of that displacement.

A dimwitted bot does not need intelligence to convince a dimwitted human beings it is intelligent.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: