HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mrmanner's commentslogin

It's a while since I used Airplay for anything other than Youtube videos, but here is how I thought it worked:

1. If I choose to Airplay from the control center, it mirrors the whole screen (or possibly also extends as a second screen). Whatever I open on the iPad (or drag to the second screen) is what the audience sees.

2. If I Airplay from inside an app with presentation mode, it works similar to Airplaying a video. That one app remains active even if I switch to another app.

3. To switch what gets presented, I simply start a new Airplay session: from control center if I want to switch to sharing the whole screen, or to another app if I want that app's presentation mode. This doesn't have to be automatic, but I shouldn't have to actively close the old session to start a new one.

4. To switch back to a previous presentation, I open that app back up and re-enable Airplay - there could be a button to "resume presentation".

Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't see how that is too complicated. It seems rather intuitive that if I'm sharing a specific app window, I didn't mean to share the whole thing. (And it's also intuitive that if I actively start a new share, that takes over from the old one. No need to actively close the old share first.)


which they have to be anyway, to support normal iphones and maybe ipads and in many cases a cackle of Android phones too. (but I still think this is brilliant design)


in this thread many people have clearly never developed for iOS

Here's just the screen sizes, not even taking into account actual resolution:

    iPhone (2007)     3.5" 74.0 × 49.3    36 cm²
    iPhone 5          4.0" 88.6 × 49.8    44 cm²
    iPhone 12 mini    5.4" 124.5 × 57.5   72 cm²
    iPhone Duo, cover 5.4" 113.4 × 77.2   88 cm²
    iPhone 6 Plus     5.5" 121.8 × 68.5   83 cm²
    iPhone X          5.8" 133.7 × 61.8   83 cm²
    iPhone Air        6.5" 150.0 × 69.1  104 cm²
    iPhone 18 Pro Max 6.9" 159.2 × 73.3  117 cm²
    iPhone Duo, inner 7.6" 157.6 × 111.5 176 cm²
Now, you can leave out a few of those as hopelessly obsolete like the OG iphone, 5, 12 mini, arguably the x, but it's still a pretty wide selection.


Good list. And if you support both portrait and landscape, you need to support twice that, and you need to be able to switch on the fly.

But for the apps that don't currently support both orientations, it's possible they don't have support for switching aspect ratio on the fly. This design might help with those apps not completely breaking when folding/unfolding.


Yeah to be fair I'm all for the 1/sqrt(2) aspect ratio, I just think it's funny that it's treated as some kind of holy design constraint when they're all over the map on phone sizing :)

And the extra irony is I'm currently shipping an app that doesn't deal well with different size phones (just pads the edges), heh, so do as I say, not as I do.


12 mini and 13 mini remain supported in iOS 27.


In this day and age it makes sense to amend Tim's statement to "canonical urls don't change". And cool web sites have a canonical URL for most pages.

That way we a) don't lose track of relevant content but b) can have nice things such as short URLs with good names.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: