HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mrandish's commentslogin

Normally, I'd agree but they are well aware of both software and devices attempting to work around their cloud lockdown and very aggressively trying to block any local control.

It's also important to understand they are backed by a private equity firm spending a lot money buying up the other leading garage door companies. This isn't just a preference to keep people in their cloud if possible, it's a long-term plan to corner the market and distribution channels and then start locking all remote features behind $ubscription pay walls and all their non-Chamberlain brands will do it too.

They've already shown they're willing to increase BOM costs on stuff that only locks out local-only use.


If right to repair laws having a teeth at all, you just throw a legal letter at tgem and demand the protocols for your own thing and then implement the fix you need.

Who's going to be first to test if the laws actually work?


Looks like the perfect time for a disruption of that business model.

I just don't believe that "the market will fix it" is a good or right way to approach this. The problem is that our products are fully-remote controlled by the vendor. This was never the case before, say, 50 years ago. Frankly, there should be a law that requires every purchase of a physical object to require a minimum of connectivity to work. My robot vacuum doesn't need the cloud. The impose that on me because it's convenient for them - instead of 1 purchase once, they can get N purchases on every use. It gives them leverage over me for the lifetime of the product. The solution to bad meat is not to buy different meat. We need to regulate products such that coercive, fraudulent, manipulative, anti-privacy, anti-consumer practices are illegal. People who think regulation is for suckers who aren't as smart as them, well, they work 40 hour work-weeks in buildings that have fire exits and eat food that is FDA inspected.

My thoughts exactly. Worst case, you get bought out by them.

So as usual all you need to know is "purchased by private equity" the amount of times this results in anything other than enshittification is probably less than 0.1%

The OAI deal was a transitional alliance of convenience to quickly accelerate. Investing / loaning ~$10B into Open AI (much of it in compute credits) was MSFT playing catch up when they realized they were behind in the LLM race. They weren't so much worried about OAI / Ant, this was more about Google who had DeepMind and Google Brain plus significant advantage in custom TPU compute at a time when MSFT still lacked an internal frontier foundation model team.

MSFT got an IP license and a frontier model to white label along with an anchor tenant as they scaled Azure's AI compute. OAI got investment at a high valuation (good optics) and scale compute. In the meantime, MSFT quickly got to work recruiting their own frontier foundation model team in MAI.


> The initial news reports were not from officials but "people familiar with the matter"

Anytime that's the case, always ask "Who wants this headline to be in the media and why?" Note that a credible media outlet won't run a story unless they can confirm the "people" leaking are in an official capacity to actually know the leaked info.

For example, per later reporting in NYT & WSJ, the "Jensen's sleeping with alleged Chinese asset" leak was from the China AI Hawk faction in the White House (Defense, State and Treasure Depts) trying to undermine the AI Trade Pragmatist faction (Commerce Dept, AI advisors and NVidia) just before this week's summit. That matters because the summit will determine whether Trump extends the H200 card waiver past January. Jensen was effective in swaying Trump at the last minute to get the waiver last year. The well-timed leak of the 6-month old Alice report ensured he wouldn't be on Air Force One going to this summit like he was last year. The reporters who wrote the original story certainly knew this was why it was being leaked but the 'rules of the game' are that the reporter doesn't include the obvious purpose behind a leak in the story (or they won't get the next leak).

Today's leak may be as mundane as NSA / Homeland Security budget squabbles. When you can't get your infrastructure budget approved, highlighting an infrastructure failure can change that.


> inference is not being subsidized

Inference doesn't have to be sold below direct compute cost to be subsidized. If inference pricing doesn't cover amortized capex and the cost of capital it's still using investor money to buy market share.


Recently, I've complained about OpenAI (and other tech company's) product landing pages communicating virtually no useful information about what the product is or why it might useful. So, I have to concede this is at least a step in the right direction.

I guess it's sign of the times that upon seeing the headline "Strengthening the fight against online child sexual abuse", my first reflexive thought wasn't positive. Instead it was a jaded assumption this would be another perhaps well-intended effort likely to either go awry, further undermine the privacy and workflows of law-abiding users, or be largely ineffective - and quite possibly all three.

I just assumed it was another cry to create a regulatory moat by banning any open models so everyone has to rent AI access from them. That's basically the only thing Altman ever has to say and he repeats it with a different angle every week.

Thank you for posting the relevant facts the company chose to not mention in their long blog post nor its tl;dr header.

To the company: We all understand that ePaper displays are a set of trade-offs, but hiding those specs doesn't make them go away, it just wastes the time of those who want to know what they are.


> specifically because I'm a generalist type and I can sort of quickly cut through the space of possibilities.

I too have thought a lot about this because I've been able to get a lot of value out of lengthy, deep LLM sessions which bridge between domain exploration, research and ideation. A lot of the net value from the session isn't in the LLM's responses but in the notes I make as I'm spelunking different 'nodes in the knowledge graph' that I'm constructing, which is my own knowledge and understanding of a new, adjacent domain.

Working this way immediately felt comfortable to me because it mirrors the patterns I developed over a couple decades as a serial tech entrepreneur focused on identifying high-value customer problems which had been overlooked or insufficiently explored by others and then matching them to new technologies and processes to create a novel solution. Over the years, one pattern I found especially useful was hiring a university professor or grad student for a few hours of "Deep Q&A." My well-paid new academic friends often reported being exhausted afterward, with one describing it as "a high G-force, intensely non-linear Mr. Toad's Wild Ride" through his domain. Over years of doing this, I got pretty good at intuiting what I need to know, don't need to know and how to surface, then hone in on the boundaries and edge cases likely to yield whatever discontinuity I was intuitively sniffing out.

An entrepreneurship professor once asked to do a couple 'ride-alongs' to understand my "process" (though I've never called it that). His case study described it as "akin to an ADHD truffle pig unearthing raw, unrefined nuggets of economic opportunity". A key take-away was that nearly the entire value from the "process" was successively approximating down to the exact right "interesting question", far more than in any particular answer.

The nice thing about LLMs vs PhDs and grad students, is they're not unsettled when I hard-stop and reverse direction like an NFL running back or stall out retracing over the same seemingly barren patch until I 'pick up the signal' again and then go rocketing off in a different direction. To be clear, LLMs are not anywhere close to being a full replacement for the unique value my best human spelunking guides provide and I haven't yet seen any sign LLMs are improving in ways that will close that particular gap anytime soon (though they are improving in many other ways). I think the difference is the human domain experts have a degree of deep understanding with unbroken conceptual continuity from first principles all the way up the stack combined with a complete World Model. They can make insightful connections between concepts more than one or two degrees of separation apart (both vertically within a domain's 'abstraction stack' and horizontally across domains) in ways LLMs don't, except by widening their randomness thresholds which I've never found to be productive.

While an LLM's near-perfect recall of a vast web of statistically weighted, taxonomically-related facts along with incredible speed and infinite patience are super valuable, they're not a replacement for my domain expert human guides. For my needs, LLMs do provide around half the value of humans in this role, while being much cheaper with no vetting, introductions, appointments or breaks required. So, I'm using both in separate sessions - though an LLM able to fully track and engage both visually and verbally in a high-velocity, collaborative human brainstorm without being a 'third-wheel' would be an interesting design target for enterprising AI startup.

In short, I don't think you're wrong. There's real skill and unique value in being able to do, whatever it is I'm describing, consistently well - whether with a human or with an LLM.


Yeah, and I don't think it's just about being a generalist - obviously we know that programming "specialists" can do things with LLM-assisted coding that other people can't do.

But this:

>While an LLM's near-perfect recall of a vast web of statistically weighted, taxonomically-related facts along with incredible speed and infinite patience are super valuable, they're not a replacement for my domain expert human guides.

Really reads true to me - LLMs don't have a filter, they "know everything". So the value in the human is exactly the filter - they can kinda sieve through the mass of knowledge, weight what's important in context, and thereby extract something interesting from an LLM.

If I can get weird for a sec, there's something almost divinatory to LLMs when you're using them in this particular way - it's like a Tarot deck or I Ching or something, where you have this big collection of vague symbols (tarot) or "phrase" (i ching) that could almost mean anything. The human in that loop has to collate what subset of the symbols are interesting to the given situation. Without that filtering you just have this morass of information that doesn't necessarily get you anywhere, but when you're able to direct your attention to what's currently germane, you can get uncanny results!

(to be clear, I don't really think there's anything "magical" in any of these cases, but there's something to the metaphor!)


> where you have this big collection of vague symbols

I don't think this is unique to LLMs but rather a serendipitous duplication of a well-studied idea in creativity and innovation research called bounded randomization or semi-arbitrary constraints. You can see the idea used as a creativity tool in various ideation frameworks like "Innovation Games." An LLM's "Temperature" essentially controls how a kind of randomization function is applied to its conceptual weight-space in a similar way to how 'Innovation Games' toolboxes include dice and even Tarot-inspired cards containing vague directional prompts. It's the same underlying concept as Rorschach's random inkblots.

> So the value in the human is exactly the filter

This is true not only in the case of my domain expert human guides but also in the case of a uniquely skilled human driving an LLM session. A good example is famous mathematician Terence Tao sharing his deep LLM sessions online which PhD mathematicians find immense value in. Obviously, those mathematicians can simply boot up the same LLM themselves, so the unique value isn't in the LLM's answers, it’s in how Terence steers the session: how he frames his prompts, interrogates the outputs, and curates which branches to pursue or prune.

Before I'd heard on HN about Terry sharing his sessions, I'd shared some of my 3 to 7 hour, 100+ round deep dive LLM sessions with a few experienced peers who asked to see them. The shocked responses I got from two out of the three were my first clue that maybe I was "driving the LLM" in a very different way than they'd ever considered. One described the vibe as more akin to Socratic dialog than Q&A. Early in the sessions, my prompts tended to be short and much of the value was in the LLM's longer answers. But as the sessions went on that gradually began to shift with my prompts growing more detailed and introducing new ideas, while the LLM's answers generally got shorter. By the end, as I curated away many of the possible directions and then developed the individual threads I'd teased out, almost all the interesting and valuable content was in my prompts, with final rounds focusing on weaving the remaining threads together into a new actionable thesis.

While I don't find even today's most advanced LLMs to yet be half-replacements for humans in filling this role, I do think LLMs can be incredibly valuable in other ways the best human 'guide / sparring partners' cannot. Unfortunately, the current single-threaded, chat-style interfaces are actually pretty terrible for these kinds of multi-branching, layered learning/ideation workflows.

While I'm getting significant value out of LLMs as a cognitive prosthetic that's part robot researcher, part fact-checker, part note-taker and part extrapolating mirror that restates and expands on my directional ideas (for better and worse), I've found struggling with LLM chat interfaces so annoying that a few months ago I spent several hours sketching out a feature set and UX that isn't a struggle to use in this way. Then the next week someone posted a 'Show HN' with their take on a tool for a similar workflow and several posters immediately chimed in with links to others - so we're definitely not alone in seeing the value. Show HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49307700


That's really interesting, and I'll have to check it out. I've definitely had this experience too where the single-threaded nature of an LLM conversation gets frustrating.

I get a ton of value out of agentic dev stuff - arguably much more economic value from that side of things - but I get more enjoyment and edification from the same "sparring partner / smart journal / digital tarot deck" thing we're both circling around above. And the most interesting of those conversations definitely do have that branching nature you're referring to, and I'll find myself writing almost little essays back, trying to respond to various points, steer the discussion, etc. it feels like this kind of probing and winnowing of the space of the model, and the LLM is not really in the same role as it is when I'm using it for coding. It's this weird kind of jammy, vibey thing where you're kind of updating in real time and you're not necessarily looking for a specific answer or result but rather using the model as a sort of tool for thinking. It's really interesting! I can definitely see the value in being able to gain a little more control over the "graph" of the conversation.

Anyway - you ever feel like playing that game with a human, my email's in my profile. Always game for a good email pal. Thanks for taking the time to think out loud with me.


> do you think this is a good idea?

LLMs can be quite good at that... sometimes, and maybe most times. Where they can fall short is when "good idea" is comprised of inter-locking conditional definitions and variable evaluation thresholds denominated in differently weighted currencies.


> and no tool is in development for it

The more cost effective approach is now repair-in-place. Startups in early orbital testing include Starfish Space (autonomous satellite life extension, orbital repositioning/inclination changes, and active debris disposal) and Katalyst (Multi-arm robotic capture, hardware upgrades, and orbital repositioning).


The question on my mind is; does repair-in-place make economical sense for commercial satellites?

Old-space satellites are expensive, so on-orbit repair theoretically makes sense here. The largest obstacle to cost-effective repair in that domain is the one-off nature of these vehicles. This means each repair mission requires R&D, manufacturing, and testing before launch. So for this method to be effective, the repair mission needs time before any faults become lethal. I'm not super confident about resuscitation either; off-nominal thermal/power can cook electronics beyond repair. Plus, any RPO mission risks accidental damage.

And on the other hand, new-age satellites like Starlink are build cheap(er) and designed for replacement. Why bother with repair when you can just build and launch another?

It seems like you're also a satellite repair nerd, so I'd love to hear any thoughts you might have :D


the satellites are life limited whether they have noticeable faults or not (mostly by the remaining propellant, but also by TID radiation and payload obsolescence), and any sensible repair-in-place mission aims to proactively repair satellites near the end of their practical life rather than reactively responding to issues. The robotics (and fluid transfer for refuelling) are basically there, you just need satellites with an architecture that enables repair/replacement/refuelling to move beyond demonstrators. And most satellites are not built in that way.

As for whether it's worth it, it depends a lot on the satellite and the orbit. Starlink: probably not worth upgrading. Geostationary satellites: there's a reason why what goes up there commands oldspace prices (long way up, intensive radiation environment) and that reason also justifies serviceability. Hypothetical LEO datacentre with most of the mass being solar panels and radiators that last a lot longer than the chips are commercially relevant: yeah, probably makes sense to have the chip payload swappable and the thrusters refuellable.

A mission for one satellite to repair a lot of others is complex (it's basically an extra-hard version of the travelling salesman problem) but when the alternative is inserting many entirely new satellites into n orbits, sending a tiny fraction of the mass to n orbits via a reusable servicer starts to make a lot of sense...


Exactly, the scale and scope of payloads is increasing as launch costs are decreasing.

If starship launches ever get anywhere near the 2m-10m claim.. Suddenly fixing or retrieving that 500m-2bn satellite. Or rotating the compute modules on that 150bn space datacenter constellation..

Honestly I could envision regulation requiring it at some point.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: