HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mr_toad's commentslogin

LLMs are mostly trained on works that are not open source, by your own argument any LLM generated work couldn’t be open sourced.

Couldn't be used at all, rather

Your first cited article doesn’t necessarily support the idea that agentic code generation is copyrightable.

“A Single Piece of American Cheese sits between those contrasting poles: the initial image was created entirely by the AI program based on a brief text prompt, then the user repeatedly selected elements of the image and used additional prompts to add/alter elements.”

Agentic development is steadily reducing the necessity for human involvement in the final output.


Unless you only use the code in-house and never distribute I don’t see how you could argue that it’s a secret?

Would you argue that the output of a zero or one shot prompt was sufficiently influenced by human creativity to qualify for copyright?

With the caveat that this is my own extrapolation of the rules - and what I think is reasonable: How creative was the prompt?

"Translate my very detailed pseudocode into Ruby: ": probably.

"Write me a game about a horse. Don't stop until it's finished. Make no mistakes.": probably not.

And unfortunately for us engineers, there's a very big, fuzzy, not-precisely-definable range in between of "I'll know it when I see it".


NASA human rating requirements don’t apply to a private flight. There aren’t as yet any specific regulations governing private crewed space flights.

Ah, TIL. But still, even private company (or their high paying customers) wouldn't want to take the risk. And using proven design for humans might be easier than to solve all safety issues with the whole Starship. Also, they still have to solve non-starlink cargo deployment too I think?

Unsold Cybertrucks?

> Is that... a lot?

11 million won’t even get you two racks of their latest GPUs. NVL72 racks (72 Blackwell GPUs a piece) sell for several million each.


> When a bubble pops, the pop typically takes years to happen. It's more of a slow deflation in most cases.

That’s just a bear market. Bubbles pop, otherwise we wouldn’t call them bubbles. If you call every downturn a bubble it ceases to be meaningful, and we’d have to come up with a better term for actual bubbles.


> This scheme had pissed off bankers that a company muscled in on their turf

Weird if true, because businesses having a side-line in financing their customers is extremely common. Most large retailers, car dealers etc all do it. Sometimes they outsource to a third party, but sometimes they do it all in house. In a few cases they end up making more money as a finance company than the business they started in.


I remember hearing about a large US company that had a financing arm that was way bigger than the primary business they were known for.

GE Capital during the 2008 financial crisis?

That's the one I was think of.

Might have been IBM at some points in the past, unsure these days.

It's fun to point out in these cases, that these ginormous companies were worth billions (possibly double digits even!) of $$$ back then adjusted for inflation - which was regarded as the height of excess back then, but is the kind of money that wouldn't be noticed if it fell of the back of a truck at Nvidia.

Yeah, but at this scale, it's mostly banks and private equity and other finance companies, right? Like, taking on enormous data center type debt? And especially on the bank side, we are highly regulated. These sorts of deals between the AI companies are red flags to us.

I've seen it be done with consumers and small B2B but not big giant business finance like this before. I could see how it could irk banks. I mostly work as a programmer in finance and I will say the mood has not been nearly as...idk...jubilant about the whole AI situation as it seems to be amongst friends in the startup scene.

It's mostly not helped our productivity and projects to implement (except for the very small local models that can run on mainframes and the like) have mostly failed, so I could see how bankers and others working in finance might be MORE willing to believ that there was a bunch of conspiratorial stuff going on than the average Hacker News patron who can get away with letting it rip with Claude on the job.

I won't disclose what company I'm at, but it seems the general opinion amongst big bankers and programmers for big banks is that we are in a bubble and that we don't intend to be the ones that get in trouble for it this time and have stayed pretty clean.


> It's not good risk management

Making a large number of very risky bets on small startups is how venture capital works. Most will fail, hopefully a few will make up for that.


Yes but normally you would want these to be uncorrelated bets.

Ding ding ding. One bet might work, but if it's debt and not equity the upside of a one success is just getting paid back.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: