HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mountain_peak's commentslogin

Bought our home almost 20 years ago, and the former owner (apparently) owned a now-defunct home automation business. The upside was 100% X10/Insteon power and light controls, top alarm panel, environmental controls and so on running off of a wall-mounted "SmartLinc" touch panel. I expanded the system with Axis cameras and a Mac Server running Indigo and SecuritySpy (non-subscription), which enabled remote monitoring and control, but it all operates locally.

In a moment of weakness, I bought a D-Link wireless (wifi) water detector for the sump pit (it was on clearance for $30); it relied on a D-Link Home cloud service (free) that was closed down a few years ago.

Not wanting to toss it, I repurposed a spare Chromebook 14 that I was going to recycle and turned it into a Alpine monitor for the water detector, which I'm powering from the Chromebook's USB port (if power is lost in a rainstorm, I need to know about it before the sump pit fills up).

An immediate issue was that the D-Link firmware tried to "phone home" every 24 hours and would drop from the local network, since the server was kaput, and I had no clue what response it was expecting from the server to keep it alive. Solution; "reboot" the unit by interrupting USB power (with a Pico and MOSFET) every 23 hours. There's no question that home automation should work without the internet.


> Solution; "reboot" the unit by interrupting USB power (with a Pico and MOSFET) every 23 hours

Reminds me of a possible apocryphal anecdote I heard about Alan Turing. He loved going on long bike rides, but one day his bike developed a distressing habit of slipping the chain. After the third time it happened, he realized it was due to a broken tooth on both the front and the back gear. He went back home and calculated how many revolutions of the pedals it would take for both broken teeth to line up when they were at the critical part of the rotation, and he built a little mechanical counter that would click on each link in the bike chain, and at the calculated time, a little arm would reach down and clasp the chain, holding it in place long enough for the teeth to re-engage.

He showed the device to his friend, who said "Why didn't you just buy new gears? You could have gotten both for a dime." And Alan replied "Oh, that's clever, I didn't think of that."


A similar anecdote about Turing appears in Neal Stephenson's "Cryptonomicon", except without the clever solution or the "absent-minded professor" stereotype.

A joke told abut Von Neumann:

A student came up to Von Neumann on campus and decided to prank the great scientist. "Two trains are on the same track 50 miles apart and they hurtle towards each other at 50 mph. As they start, a really fast fly on the nose of one train flies towards th eother at 60mph. When it reaches the other train it immediately flies back to the first, then back to the second, and so on until the fly is crushed in the crash. How far will the fly fly?

Von Neumann thought for a moment, and then replied, "30 miles!" The student grinned. "I thought you'd know this one! The trains take half an hour to hit each other, therefore the fly will fly 30 miles."

Von Neumann started. "I didn't think of that, I summed the series."

———

Source: "The Prisoner's Dilemma" by William Poundstone

https://archive.org/details/prisonersdilemma0000poun


A tennis match between two players, A and B, has finished. You are given the complete sequence of points played, in order. Each point is recorded as the letter of the player who won it.

Write a program that reads this sequence and works out which player won the match.

there are multiple ways to compute this but not obvious way is to look at the end of the list and see who scored last point.


Sadly, even if you know who won, You still have to read the sequence or the question won't be fullfilled

Does this require knowing how tennis is scored? Because that solution is not obvious to me at all.

Yes, and this (knowing a priori how tennis in particular is scored being useful for solving a problem) is the exact example that gets used as to why the SAT used to be somewhat biased in favor of people with the "right" background/upbringing/culture.

Tennis is a point-limited game, so yes.

I had this riddle in my math book when I was preparing to the Maths Challenge. However I was unable to sum the series.

Also one train was a boy coming home (stative) and the dog was running


wow, that's great. And since I've convinced myself the Turing story is more fable than truth, I'll start using this one instead.

I read it more as sarcasm than absentmindedness. Those dry Brits!


At one time, Standard Windows IT guidance was daily server reboots. Many sysadmins would write scripts to do that.

Selection bias. People become Turings who enjoy riddles.


I recently had a similar issue. But instead I decided to go with industrial controls. I bought a Contactor with a NC and NO connections. I put a float switch in series with the activator coil circuit. So when the float triggers: NC->O and NO-C, which turns off the water and turns on the pump.

Contactors are built to run giant industrial motors for years, nevermind my little 1/4hp pump.

The way I built it lets my mother bypass it by unplugging the pump from the control box and plugging it right into the wall outlet.

So, hopefully it lasts years. If it doesnt, anyone can bypass it


Every sump pump I've seen has a built-in float switch that works.

I need an alarm because I've had a few pumps wear out, and also because I've had the power go out long enough to flood.

Your solution automates something that shouldn't have a computer involved in automating.


Every cloud service will eventually get shut down. The problem is that nobody wants to put the effort into reverse engineering the product to fake out the cloud service until after the cloud service is gone and the reverse engineering is much more difficult.

Reverse engineer anything with agents, from app behavior down to native binaries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50058850 - October 2026

https://github.com/morluto/rea

https://rea.tools

https://github.com/AI4AIResearch/Awesome-REA

https://awesomerea.org/

Do we just need to establish bounties per cloud service target to reverse engineer and publish a spec, copyleft code, and reference architecture? Maybe https://www.fulu.org/ could host the results? Like OpenAI and Anthropic brute forcing math proofs, we can brute force interoperability (imho). Closed systems and tokens go in to the reverse engineering factory, out comes open systems that remain open to all.

https://bounties.fulu.org/bounties

(think in systems)


What we need is to ditch stupid proprietary platforms for standards, protocols and interoperability. If AI helps us do that, so be it.

The moat building behavior of western industry has always been harmful and is now obsolete. It's time to give it up.


Sounds like you would need to connect a network sniffer into its inputs and somehow figure out how to make it figure out what responses are needed on what ports just to make a "shutup pi" type system that catches smart appliances attempts to phone home and blocks them.

https://github.com/alufers/mitmproxy2swagger ("A tool for automatically converting mitmproxy captures to OpenAPI 3.0 specifications. This means that you can automatically reverse-engineer REST APIs by just running the apps and capturing the traffic.")

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42572662 - January 2025 (71 comments)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31354130 - May 2022 (85 comments)


amazing how HN still hasn't internalized that RE is cheap now just like net new code, perhaps cheaper since the oracle is right there. there are tricky bits if firmwares are signed and encrypted, but devices are so full of bugs you can expect to find some just by having agents poke for long enough

agree a lot of it Is encrypted in home automation...garage doors, locks, security etc

mitmproxy adds --emudhra option - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50189232 - October 2026 (149 comments)

(there's always an exploit, you just have to find it)


Oh indeed I didn’t realize this emudhra kerfufle might be useful in some way.

HN isn’t a person. Knowledge like this takes awhile to saturate through a community. It’s ok that some people aren’t tracking llm capabilities. I think it’s probably healthy.

If user can use LLM to RE devices, manufactures can use LLM to reinforce it. It will be cat-mouse game.

You'll also need a trust, for inevitable lawsuits. Even if everything is clean room.

Host the code and leverage compute outside of the reach of the US legal framework. A 501c3 can still be used to enable favorable tax treatment of donations used for expenses, but the entity would be kept as lean as possible to allow for evaporation if targeted legally.

Repos could be hosted on https://tangled.org/ on AT Proto infra hosted outside of the US, with snapshots of repos served as torrents with magnet links like https://huggingbay.xyz/

It is an exercise in a distributed code evolution and distribution platform, fueled by LLMs and volunteers. "Build the machine that builds the machine."


"Outside the US" would also need to be "Outside the Commonwealth" and "Outside the EU", if that's the approach you want to take - as all of those nations have trade agreements that allow such lawsuits to cross borders.

I acknowledge this, as someone who pays infra service providers outside of all that you mention, to be outside of their reach.

The cheap insurance is to capture the traffic while the cloud is still alive. Put the device on its own SSID, route it through mitmproxy (or plain tcpdump if it talks HTTP), and keep a few days of request/response pairs. When the service shuts down you already know what the device expects back, which is most of the work for a fake local server. That would have answered the "what does it want every 24 hours" question upthread.

Won't help with devices that pin certificates, but a lot of the cheap ones don't, or never bothered with TLS at all =)


--emudhra these days

The good news is the fine friends at eMudhra have decided to help us!

Insteon remains incredibly solid. The new company is super slow with new product because it's tiny, but the hardware remains incredibly good long-term. It doesn't clutter common wireless bands and by nature of being stupid, Insteon devices cannot really be hacked.

My rules for home automation are largely the same as the article, first and foremost the existing physical UX of switches and stuff should always work, and ideally automations should be nearly invisible: They should subtly be convenient and monitoring should be useful, but nobody should be confronted with a weird change of lifestyle because a house has automation. And nobody should ever need an app to use their house.


They can also develop 1 to 1 relationships before a controller is even introduced. If I turn on my kitchen lights, the living room turns on to 50% without any controller, they talk amongst themselves over PowerLine and RF. Great 20 year old tech that's still relevant IMO.

"nobody should ever need an app to use their house" is a better rule 1 than mine alas i still like having a single app to do the harder problems

Yeah app access can be handy, it just shouldn't be foundational to everyday use. If I want to change something remotely I wouldn't normally, apps are great. Each time my parents get their phone app out to turn on a light in the room they are in, I die a little inside.

I’m all about reducing e-waste but that sounds like insanity when you can get a sensor that’s better in every way for $25 without wasting electricity powering an entire laptop.

https://www.thesmartesthouse.com/collections/water-sensors/p...


IKEA sells one that’s even cheaper and uses matter over thread.

https://www.ikea.com/us/en/p/klippbok-water-leak-sensor-smar...

I have a few of Ikea's other Matter over Thread devices and have had spotty results with them so far using Google devices as thread border routers. Planning to move to a border router from SMLight which I hope will provide a more reliable connection.


I don't like the idea of a Chromebook sitting between me and knowing my cellar is flooding.

It's better than nothing sitting between you and knowing your cellar is flooding, and I could think of worse solutions than a device with a built-in UPS that's capable of powering a sensor.

It’s not gonna be an internet response, but there are already water alarms. You’re typically meant to put them under your sink.

B-hyve has them. They talk to a hub over low power Bluetooth. The hub connects to my VPC-siloed WiFi AP on its own subnet with no routes to anything else in the house. But I still get phone alerts because it connects to its cloud service.

> its cloud service

Good luck hoping it will be existing in a few years. No service - no alerts. The whole thing becomes trash then.


Couldn't you conjure something up with esphome and home assistant pretty darn quickly?

A leak sensor is the simplest home automation sensor possible. Its literally just a bare wire connected to ground, another connecting to a digital IO. You put the two bare wires on the floor a little distance apart and write some code to fire off an alert if the IO ever reports being connected, because if it is that means something conductive is sitting between the two wires.

Right. Like a door open circuit, but not even requiring a reed switch, etc.

The leak detectors are probably $5 a piece and work for a decade - maybe there are other solutions, but this one is pretty good!

Do older Chromebooks not carry the spicy pillow risk MacBooks have when plugged in 24/7?

Time to put it on a smart plug and cycle it off on an based on battery level.

My macbook pro with m1 max has been plugged-in nearly 24/7 for the past 5+ years.

No issues whatsoever so far, and it holds the battery charge totally fine (which I get to test 2-3 times a year when i travel with it).


It's a risk, not a guarantee, but there's nothing about macbooks that make them more susceptible to it than any other laptop with a li-ion battery. The batteries age. If they're in a machine that runs hot they age a bit faster (and my 2020 Intel MBP runs hot and is plugged in near 24/7), if they're charged to 100% all the time they age a bit faster (but battery management software like Apple has had for years nearly eliminates this risk factor).

There was, however, a batch of macbooks in 2019 that got recalled for a defect that increased the chance significantly, and perhaps that's what the parent poster has in mind.


I was referencing my own experience with 2010-2016 Intel Airs and Pros ending up in the Hazardous Materials bin with bloated batteries, but good to know my current M1 Max will be up to the task whenever I can afford to upgrade.

Consider using Al Dente if you care about your battery.

That isn't a thing anymore. Macbooks that notice they live plugged in will also limit their charge to 80%.

I guess I was thinking of Intel MacBooks that otherwise serve no purpose and aren't "compatible" with that feature.

Looking into it more, there are ways to limit charging via third-party tools that modify the SMC. I should have done that.


What? What macbooks is this? My mac book air has been plugged in most of the time since 2013... I've replaced the battery once I think, but only because the battery life had decreased to 10 minutes.

my 2017 macbook pro got pretty bad spicy-pillowitis from being plugged in all the time. It got so bad that it wouldn’t sit flat on the desk, and I thought the trackpad was broken, but it was actually just unable to depress since it was right above the battery.

I just got rid of a 2013 MacBook Air earlier this year because I discovered two of the battery pockets inflated. But I never did a battery replacement, which I probably should have when I stopped using it as a laptop.

I installed a water siphon backup for the sump pump. It creates a water siphon if the level gets above the electric sump and drains the pit. Is basic plumbing to install. Other than wasting a half gallon for every 20 gallons pumped out, it doesn't rely on any technology nonsense.

To where does it drain?

Same place the sump does. It's plumbed into the exit line on a baffle so that if it backs up, the water to the siphon shuts off, killing the whole system.

It's meant for power outage not plumbing failure. But I'm more likely to see a plumbing failure ahead of time, so it meets the need.


Are you sure siphon is the right term? It sounds like a pumping scheme utilizing the venturi effect where a pressurized flow of water induces suction on a second pipe. Am I right?

Sure. Honestly I don't know.

And yet the words siphoning out the water is much easier to explain a simple concept to humans in a situation where the science doesn't actually matter. I'm not trying to be hateful, but HN slays me with this kind of needless pedantry sometimes.


It seems directly relevant in this case as you were detailing a technical solution to a problem in a thread about tradeoffs thus the implementation details were the entire point of the conversation.

It was confusing because you spoke of efficiency (doesn't apply to a siphon) and another commenter asked to where it drained, presumably because a sump will typically be well below grade meaning you can't siphon anything.

Your solution is a form of active pumping that doesn't require any electronics. A useful option and probably not something that will occur to most people to consider.


I did in fact ask because a sump pump is often at a lowest point, and siphoning requires a lower point to work.

One persons pedantry is another persons precision. It is a discussion about home mechanical systems, automation and failure modes. Siphon is only one letter shorter than eductor.

I was trying to picture this setup to understand how it works, so the details definitely made a difference to me.

Words mean things. You can’t just grape a word in honeysuckle of another word especially if their smurfiness is squanch.

I have a Dell Chromebook that's been running (Debian) without issue (battery removed) in a similar capacity for over a decade, and four more that have been up for the last five years. The former I bought new, the latter are all second-hand survivors from some public school program. They're solid.

My personal preferred infra there would be for all devices to be meshed together, and a smart water shutoff valve able to cut off automatically if a water leak sensor trips.

especially if you keep your Chromebook in the cellar ;)

but isn't the alternative to have some third party on the Internet sitting between you and knowing that your cellar is flooding? third party services in the cloud have downtimes (not necessarily less than your Chromebook), tend to shut down entirely over time, tend to give up on you if you're not on a premium plan, tend to stop supporting the version of your device, etc


> I had no clue what response it was expecting from the server to keep it alive

That is the worst part: being explicitly designed to fail un-safe. You should be able to declare the unit unfit for the purpose it was sold for and get a full refund unless they open the specs so you can keep the device running as intended using your own resources.


Point your AI of choice at it for a bit, I wouldn't be surprised if you could write some custom firmware for it pretty simply. Or at least mock D-Link Home well enough to resolve the phone home problem.

If it's of the correct vintage, maybe eMudhra can help too. It probably hasn't managed to revoke the root CA yet.

My water heater sits on top of a rubber pan and has a standalone battery operated water detector sitting on the edge. It will sound an alarm if water is detected. It's about $12 for two in Amazon. Low tech and it works.

My washing machine sits on the floor in the bathroom, but Danish apartment building regulations require there to be a floor drain (which is just the shower drain in this case) in case of a leak.

Even lower tech!


The water heater is in garage with plenty of drain for run-off. The water alarm is needed because of building code. Blame overzealous regulation.

sure but you can't move to denmark for $12

I wonder how hard it would have been to find out what info the device wanted and set up a server on the lan to just give it the pings or whatever

Here's what you do. Skip the detector, Just put the whole laptop in there. when it goes offline, You have water in the sump.

Very much in the spirit of the "weather stone": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_rock

I haven't figured out how to recieve pings from my weather stone, I've always got to get up and look out the window, which, then I can just see the weather.

Anyone made any progress on rooting it?


You don’t need to root your weather stone. You’ll want to root your weather tree. Rooted weather trees give you better long term data (if the tree is flourishing, the weather was nice all season). Unrooted weather trees just let you know if it was raining in the last couple days (still an upgrade over a weather stone, but not by much).

My family tried that when I was a kid, and I'd love to see the data, but I'm told I'd have to kill the tree to get the earliest logs which is bogus.

You could try coring the tree. (I cannot think of a good joke for this though.

I have a weather cat. She will go out in all weather, then want to camp on my chest for cuddles. If the cat's wet, it is likely raining out.

Just shine a laser on it?

To root it you need the special USB version, called USB pet stone.

You can then flash new firmware over USB.


This sounds stupid but as a belt and suspenders approach I put a $65 2560x1440 resolution, H265 capable PoE IP camera on a piece of cheap cat5e utp literally aimed at my sump. Camera is joined to the same frigate server that runs the rest of the house security cameras including doorbell. If the sump alarm goes off while I'm away from the house for vacation or work, I can easily login and check if there's really a flood condition going on.

Frigate supports training states and classifications.

Perhaps you could train it on some of the images and set up notifications for a state you don't want?

For example, I have my doorbell camera trained for gate open/closed and car present/not present.

You select a few of the pre-captured images in the UI of gate open, gate closed, and then our car, no car, someone else's car, and it'll publish an event to MQTT or whatever (don't want to assume you use Home Assistant), then you can send out notifications on it.


Yes, if I wanted to put more work into it I could certainly train it on what it looks like with the sump mostly dry (the default state, 99.999% of the time) and then have it alert me if it diverges from that. Right now I keep an eye on weather alerts for $home and glance at the cameras at least once a day when I'm away, which is good enough to catch a failed sump pump and then dispatch professional repair services.

Anyone can build a working sump flood detector. But it takes a real engineer to build one that can detect two floods.

"...And so that's how I ended up with a $14,000 basement repair. Yup, those damn chromebooks are more waterproof than you'd think! I mean it makes sense, they're designed to be vomited on by children all day at school."

every single sentence was a level of jank that i could never imagine subjecting my parents to. could you code custom firmware for the dlink btw? your fix sounds like good ol' redneck engineering but for the smart home :p

The neat thing about X10 and Insteon is that everything acts "normally" at the device level, but you can program everything (remotely?) via the Indigo server. Your parents wouldn't even have to know that their house was running schedules (except for lights turning on an off).

If you're referring to the water sensor, it's definitely not parent-friendly, but I sometimes have to bail water during power outages from thunderstorms. It has to work during a power outage and an old Chromebook was cheaper than a UPS.

I kind of ran out of time for messing around with the sensor, but I did think of either dumping the Winbond chip on my reader, or using a .bin file that was used for OTA updates and pushing a modified version down locally.

That likely would have been "cleaner" vs. a 23-hour reboot cycle. I likely would have wanted a dump first in case I borked the firmware. The Python monitoring script just uses standard HNAP to read status codes from the sensor in 30 second intervals - I think there's some way to push updates via HNAP as well.

Thanks for the reminder - may be a good project for winter, when there's no chance of needing the sump.


Any sota llm of today can basically reverse engineer and fix any issue on such devices with a one-shot prompt. Recent emudhra CA leak makes interception traffic from most IoT devices trivial too

Again, bulk of the blame goes to the techie hipsters who made coffee makers with cloud subscriptions and DRM popular. So did the BMW owners who paid $xx a month to get access to hardware THEY ALREADY OWNED.

    "hey man, have u seen my coffee machine..it connects to the internet..so cool"

Yeah, no

https://www.thedrive.com/news/bmw-commits-to-subscriptions-e...

https://www.tastingtable.com/2264769/customer-tricks-keurig-...


If you bought a GPU anytime in the last 20 years, the difference between a workstation GPU and a consumer GPU is only the driver. The hardware is the same with at most single contact changed so they can refuse to run the workstation driver on the consumer GPU. Similarly, many printer models use (used to use) the same head and the only difference in quality was the driver.

Yeah, I remember this back in the day, trying to convert an old Nvidia card to Quadro. Good 'ole days.


I vaguely remember this stuff and wondering at the time why I'm driving a BMW and have no subscriptions I'm aware of and the only one offered is the map of road conditions that relies upon all BMWs with radar mapping the roads and sending the data back to BMW servers you then load the map from. That seemed entirely reasonable as a subscription. I realized at some point this probably means I opted into paying more upfront at purchase to just have every feature turned on, so I never got offered a subscription after the fact to turn it on later.

I'm imagining now responses telling me I'm a slave to capitalism because I probably got upsold by ten grand or something I wasn't paying attention to when I signed everything. This recalls a discussion last night about grocery prices and everyone at the table talking about the comparison shopping they do and I blurted out I have no idea what anything costs. I just buy the same stuff every week and scan my card. I don't look at the stickers. I don't look at the receipt. I just look at whether I'm hitting my desired savings rate every year and remain on track for retirement goals, which I do, and that's all I actually care about, not whether I'm getting the absolute best deal possible on every transaction I ever make.

It brings my mind back to the article from the Atlantic posted here yesterday about anxiety rates going through the roof in spite of the modern western world being by far the safest it's ever been. It seems the difference now is people are so acutely aware of any and every risk, alerts to which are constantly being shoved in your face, that it overwhelms our ancestral ape brains as if dying with ten grand less in the bank is equal to having a tiger stalking you through the bush 10 meters to your right.

I'm tired. There's a podcast I listen to hosted by exercise scientists debunking stupid press headlines about the latest study or TikTok trend, with one of the hosts always pointing out how exhausted she is by all of these articles telling here she's doing something wrong. "Everything you knew about X is wrong." "You've been doing X wrong your entire life." It exhausts me too, Lauren. I bought the wrong car. I bought the wrong TV. I guess I should be living in fear that my appliances will stop working if I lose network. I should be worried that LG is telling every data broker in the world that I've spent the past year watching nothing but Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Sabrina the Teenage Witch. Shit, some agent probably just scraped Hacker News, correlated my user name with my real identity using stylometry, and now I'm going to be double-triple served nothing but ads for whatever consumer segment that puts me in. I'm going to die even poorer when some cleverly placed sponsored link in a search result makes me impulse buy some whimsigoth living room art I didn't really need.

The world of 30 years ago was a world in which six of my friends from school were killed, the National Guard occupied my city for half a week, 55 people were killed in a riot, a man dragged from his truck and beaten half to death on live television, a shootout with the LAPD that lasted three hours also live televised. We weren't allowed to wear red or blue for fear of kids getting shot by the crips and bloods. My middle school had three drive-bys while I was there. We regularly had recess and any other outdoor activities canceled because of dangerously unhealthy air quality, called "smog days." My little sister's best friend's mom lived under an assumed identity because she survived an attack by the nightstalker Richard Ramirez. My older sister's best friend was murdered in her sleep by her deadbeat mom's boyfriend.

But the world of 30 years ago still felt full of wonder and possibility. I saw a television and wanted to tear it apart to learn how it worked, to understand the miracle of how such a thing was possible. I see a television today and all I can think of is Hacker News telling me every six hours how stupid I am for plugging it into the Internet. I've never experienced any tangible harm from advertisers knowing a man who was a teenager in the 90s watches television shows from the 90s, but it feels like a massive acute threat anyway.


hmmm.

I have none of that stuff. My home was purchased new with some 10baseT wired to 5 spots in the home and to every portal (window, door). we have a solar power system with enough battery backup watt hours for backup even if it rains for two weeks

But I DO have wildlife like bobcats and hares and raccoons that are autonomous and require remediation occasionally. Luckily, their activity is limited to the out of doors.

are you sure you are getting what you want?


Shameless self promotion, check out my Raspi-Sump app. Released it 12 years ago. Free and opensource and no phone home bs.

https://github.com/alaudet/raspi-sump

https://raspisumpdocs.linuxnorth.org/


I don't know what a "Chromebook 14" is. Perhaps you mean HP's so-named 14-inch model.

In the year 2000, I lost all my possessions, especially the computers and storage media. Subsequently, I enjoyed NPR and Coast-to-Coast on a radio, including the Hurricane Katrina coverage. I had no idea what New Orleans looked like in 2005.

By that time, I was living across the street from a large thrift store. Eventually in 2006, I was weak-willed enough to begin building a home network again, and the thrift store provided two essential products: keyboards and WiFi routers.

The WiFi router was probably obsolete and EOL when I purchased it, but it definitely worked 100%, especially because I took care at the thrift store, to select a compatible AC adapter brick for it. It was a basic Netgear model, with 4 Ethernet ports, original firmware, probably 802.11n; even though an acquaintance said he would hack into it, he was inebriated most of the time, and I would never know if the router or network was hacked. You wouldn't know either, in 2026. Most consumers don't know, and could never find out, if their edge equipment is compromised. But anyway, even while running Ubuntu 6.04, I accepted the router's default firmware, and that Netgear thing lasted at least 5 years while I had an ADSL connection, and one and a half computers.

  ---
In the mid-1980s when I hung out at Radio Shack after church, I snapped up a lot of basic X10 kit. I collected the Dimmer Modules, the Appliance Modules, and later there was an RF remote unit available! The crown jewel for 12-year-old me was a central control unit that looked like a clock radio.

The control unit had cyan fluorescent display, simply the current time and alarm settings. And there were a bunch of control buttons where you could select an addressable Module, dim the lights, on/off, set timers, etc. And it was kind of amazing that everything plugged into mains outlets, and no other installation necessary!

My parents were constantly annoyed when I would sneak one of the modules onto a living-room floor lamp, or my favorite trick was cueing up a record on the turntable and then activating the Appliance Module to wake me up for school with Siouxsie and the Banshees or something. I was not allowed to persistently wire the entire house. I did not get into the journeyman electrician's job of replacing wall switches with X10 modules (those were slick). So, not even my shared bedroom was totally automated, but it was fun to experiment. It hopefully did not affect any neighbors. The pulse signals were said to stop at junction boxes, but there was still a House Code to set, in case all your flat neighbors wanted independent X10 networks.

I also never purchased the PC Interface that came with software. I believe I didn't yet have a compatible PC, anyway, and it seemed not in the spirit of a robust, predictable home automation. So yeah, my smart home devices worked without the Internet. How smart do you wanna get? My television set didn't spy on me, but everyone else does!


In high school, one of my friends had a VW (air cooled) with a torpedo heater installed that would heat the interior to 30 degrees C in a matter of minutes - no matter how cold it was outside.

Likewise, in university, my friend's army jeep had a gas heater that would melt snow off his canvas roof.

People are consuming 30% of their battery power to heat the vehicle and batteries - and that's with reduced battery range. It only makes sense to add a container for gas/diesel and a heater - really can't understand why manufacturers are against instant and very low cost heat as an option to protect range and increase safety (in case you're stranded in the winter with a depleted battery).

Best of luck adapting one to your vehicle.


It spends some battery, but my electric car heats much faster than my diesel cars ever did. Why on earth would I use a diesel heater that’s more expensive to run and slower?


Manufacturers don't do torpedo heaters outside of campers because they are a PITA. You need to find a place for the fuel tank and the fuel receptacle, for the heater itself, and you need an exhaust that requires clearance. And for a heater integrated into regular airflow routing it gets even more complex.


Indeed - both heaters (torpedo and whatever the jeep had) blew hot air "around" and were not integrated into the vents. I think the jeep unit just drew from the gas can - not sure about the torpedo heater, but they were very economical for the amount of heat they produced.

-40 (air temperature - not windchill) is nothing to mess with. The instant heat from a battery pack is great if you're always close to charging, but there's absolutely no way I'd head into the wilderness in winter with just an EV.


Sounds like a stock EV is not for you, or the very close to 0% of the world's population with similar needs.

That's ok.


Certainly it uses some battery energy to do that battery heating. If you have a plugin at. home, even a 120v one, you can just use your home power.


just a caveat - some EVs, like Hyundai models, require using an app and the internet to enable this. If you use only the key fob, the heat pump compressor does not run.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: