HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | moobsen's commentslogin

> it was being the only one in your city to be able to solve a complicated math problem, it was immortalizing yourself because you discovered a proof and added to the ever expanding human knowledge

I think if that is what one builds an ego on, being better in a discipline than most others, that is a good way to go into isolation and depression. With or without AI.

As Grant lays out in parts of his video, teaching, helping others, socializing etc. will always be valuable skills and much more likely to lead towards happiness.

And while I don't know how the specialized problem solving roles in a future with an actual capable AI will look like, I am sure it will continue to be a useful and needed skill as well. Without everyone having to take on a manager role.


> I think if that is what one builds an ego on, being better in a discipline than most others, that is a good way to go into isolation and depression.

What do you think why guilds were created? Most of the professions are about doing something not everybody can do. That’s not the way to depression that’s human nature. Find something where you are good at and get paid for it.


There is a difference between taking joy in doing what you are good at and taking pride in being better than others.

Just as a guild can be helpful to find like minded people who enjoy doing what you do and elevate the profession as a whole, but also as an institution to keep outsiders out.

I am not saying I don't understand the fears. Imagining this machine that can do everything faster and cheaper than me, making me completely obsolete is of course scary. But really to me that is all that is, imagination. At least for now.

Also, even if my job gets completely automated away, I could see myself enjoying trying to understand how that magical thinking machine works and teaching that to others. Even if it is just at the frontier of my limited understanding and not the frontier of human/machine knowledge.


> teaching, helping others, socializing etc. will always be valuable skills and much more likely to lead towards happiness.

I think you misinterpreted the writer's intention. Adding to the ever expanding human knowledge is teaching the whole humanity including people that aren't born yet.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: