HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | monideas's commentslogin

Are you claiming these additional women were involved in the Singaporean shell company issue?

Let me help you out here: You are motivated by envy and animus and these other things are rationalizations.


US elites get off on destroying people who do good for the country. This also benefits China so the Chinese government works with them to do this occasionally which they did in this case.

He’s no longer CEO which is what China wanted, but US elites can still destroy him even more and the people around him.


This is a Chinese government operation to impede US progress on AI while they catch up.

Impede US progress by smuggling GPUs into China? Isn't the more likely answer that they are business people trying to make money?

> smuggling GPUs into China

the Chinese stopped the leaking faucet in favor of local hardware, these kind of embargo never works anywany, we've seen this with nuclear weapons, how naive would we be to think any different

smartest way would be going for the addiction route and nip the local hardware production, which is harder than it sounds


China is ousting their own spy? the opposite.

Its an actor that wants to stop the US sending chips to China -- it seems that all this was going on with the knowlegde of high ranking US officials. Now that the story is out, they cant pretend anymore that they dont see it


Its likely the Chinese were using spies to get secrets, blackmail, etc. but it seems less like one grand conspiracy than an opportunistic power grab once the sharks smelled blood in the water, or a confluence of many smaller conspiracies.

Or they just felt their asset was expended and why not get one last bit of value in the process of throwing it away? Though I suppose that could fall into either category, depending how you wanted to look at it.

Possibly. (I wish my) money is on investors high up in the tree earning money off of nvidia and other tech stonks collapsing. It could be both even, what do I know.

You’re not meant to keep up with it, it’s a means of control.

This isn’t a case of being punished for doing the right thing. The right thing is retaining control of your own company and doing so is not “authoritarian”.

why do you believe this is true?

The idea of a board of directors is one that actually has to be defended on first principles.

What is the actual value add of a “board of directors” except to basically be weak willed PMC/non founder-type people with a lot to lose reputationally and financially who can be cowed and/or blackmailed very easily.

The typical person on the board of a public company would fold to pressure as soon as they saw a NY Times reporter called their phone.


I'm not sure if you're being facetious. The board of directors role is to look after the shareholders' interests. A good board is exactly that - the representatives of the shareholders.

And in this case they fired a CEO who created more shareholder value than almost any person in human history and they didn’t fire him for declining performance.

So this just proves my point.


Shareholder interests are not solely financial, and the board does not need to justify their actions to anyone except the shareholders.

Sorry but IMO this sort of company structure should not be allowed. Private companies should not be able to issue stocks the way Zuck & Elon have. Pull Meta’s charter and redistribute their assets. Let that serve as a notice to Elon that he’s next.

[flagged]

Care to explain why?

Because it will demoralise people from founding companies. Control is one of the highest priorities that founders have. Throttle that (or throttle personal wealth incentives) and you won't have more companies under control, you'll have less innovators.

Why? Because most innovators have an experience of trying in vain to make contributions within a company/authority structure that directly undermined their capacity to make these contributions.


This argument makes no sense. You're basically saying that a company controlled by one person will be innovative, but a company controlled by more than one person will not. Why? I have seen plenty of examples to the contrary.

If you want to have a more innovative company, just focus on taking your most talented individual contributors seriously. That doesn't have anything to do with who owns the company, or how much of the company they own. Just trust the people you hire! And maybe give them some control of the company while they're at it so that THEY are more motivated to innovate in a way that benfits the company.


ah, well, I'll just have to take your word for it, since you've articulated no form of case whatsoever

Under that standard why not just strip you of all your wealth and property and redistribute it? You’re not deserving of anything at all.

The argument is that the shareholders who own the majority of a company's stock (by value, not voting rights) should be able to control the company, not a minority owner. It is the corporate structure that allows guaranteed minority control (e.g. Zuckerberg owns something like 13% of Meta, but controls 60% of the voting power). In a free market, why should publicly traded companies be allowed to sell "shares" that are not ownership in the traditional sense?

In an actual free market the distinction between “public” and “private” company would be really just some transparency/accounting standard or set of standards set by the particular exchange(s) that the shares were traded on.

And just to be clear in practice, stocks are not priced based on their voting rights but rather expectations of their future cash flows (dividends) or simply how much the stock is expected to go up or down by. A lot of modern financial activity is nonsense.

If you really want to actually understand what a company is you should go look up when corporations became a thing and why. It had to do with various legal protections to stimulate economic activity and tax revenues.

All of these modern notions and principles that you’re invoking or basing your arguments on about ownership are most likely just contrived nonsense. These aren’t necessarily eternal principles of anything.


Same reason people should be permitted to buy those same non-voting shares. Because nobody is forcing anyone to.

Ask almost anyone here and they'll tell you that the C-suite are mostly a bunch of morons who don't know anything about technology, and now you want to ensure that businesses can only ever be run by such technologically illiterate morons, not founders? Insanity!

So if you don't want to to happen just don't issue shares on the stock market ?

Sorry but making laws retroactive is authoritarian. We should make it illegal to propose such things and put you in prison.

It's entirely fair to think that, given what I said, that I would mean to do this without some form of legal basis. Not so!

Is it my view that Meta has engaged in a sustained course of unlawful conduct that persists despite the judgements the law has already applied, and will persist into the future. As a corporation who is consistently in court, and based in Delaware, it surely seems to me the bar has been passed -- the AG of the state would be well within their rights to revoke their charter. Meta's entire basis of being at this point is to control public discourse. That's direct harm to the state and the public at large.

What happens to their assets afterwards is a job for the courts. Applying existing law is "retroactive authoritarian". Pfft, please. Ignorance of the law is not a defense against it.


No, it's a case of consequences for making incredibly poor personal decisions while being in a very visible position in a very visible company.

The man is smart enough to know he was playing with fire, and he got burned. The literal definition of FAFO.


Having a libido is fairly normal for most non-castrated men, at least historically speaking. In modern times, men are in seemingly depressed and in general need of various pills to help with erectile dysfunction, which perhaps in part explains the low birth rates.

What is it that you’re actually trying to say here.

What did he do that was “playing with fire” specifically? Having long term sexual relationships with women?

The thing he did that was actually wrong was that the NVIDIA executive he was in a sexual relationship with was herself married. That is actually wrong, that’s not “playing with fire”, that’s simply wrong.


To be honest, I don't know how to succinctly tell you that this is a bad take. For starters, that company has hoovered enough tax money that we should all be on the board. Secondly, encouraging family feudalism is crazy if you even claim to be a supporter of capitalism and the free market. Thirdly, you're not a tech baron and never will be, especially if you can't trust that your investments are concerned with your interests and goals due to CEO exceptionalism. Just saying. If he was a judge, he would be disbarred. This company wants to be a stupid percentage of our GDP, so they're gonna have to suck it up and hold themselves to the standards of a public office.

He’s not a judge, he’s a private citizen, he holds no office. Your thinking is very confused.

I think you’re confused on the essence of what he was trying to say.

The comparison was drawn because when you are such a position of power, your actions have such a monumental sway. Thousands, millions of people’s of lives are impacted, for better or for worse. In Jensen’s case, that’s up to the court of public opinion.

However the thinking is that when you are in that position, a just and fair society would probably want to keep just and fair and morally tact people in those positions.

IMHO I don’t care what way you want to spin it, when you have that level of influence over one of the major drivers of the AI boom, you have INCREDIBLE power compared to what most people think of when you say “private citizen”.


The court of public opinion is steered by the media, which is entirely orchestrated. You can't pander to the mindless masses, that's a suckers game.

Not the primary point of what I was trying to say.

These tech CEOs hold a lot of influence and power. Thus they hold a lot of responsibility and must be held accountable. Point blank.


Agreed. The fact that he gets this perception while Musk has repeatedly betrayed the US's best interests shows that things like rationality and merit have gone out the window. However, don't mistake this for me excusing either of their behavior. Neither are not suited for that level of responsibility.

I don’t entirely follow this comparison. Maybe we spend time in different circles, but Musk in the current day is nearly universally s*t on by everybody I know. Even the people I know that still praise his work remain with a bad taste in their mouth.

My buddies and I were just talking about how Jensen is probably one of the MOST liked amongst all the leading big tech CEO/Owners. I feel like the amount of grace this thread is giving him is proof of that.

I don’t understand how that’s comparable to the perception of Musk.

Are you sure you are not over reacting?


> For starters, that company has hoovered enough tax money that we should all be on the board.

How did they get that tax money? Why do you think that should give anyone an ownership stake?

Do you think buying a McDonald’s hamburger should grant you partial control of McDonald’s?


tl;dr "Polysemantics" are just a unisemantics you don't understand.

If you want to learn more about this, this is what depth psychology is about (Carl Jung, et al).

This is also essentially the idea behind monotheism vs polytheism. It's about engaging with and trying to understand the profound underlying unity of the myriad phenomena.


One of the things the Bible does particularly well is express ideas succinctly. Yes I know you can pull out exceptions but classically this was interpreted as itself having significance.


Are we reading the same bible? The bible is a super meandering document that repeats itself a bunch and also contradicts itself. (which is to be expected if you assume its some sort attempt at writing down and standardizing an oral myth tradition that came before it)


I don’t think that’s what the GP meant.

The Bible is fundamentally a collection of different works. Within those works, I generally agree that the ideas are fairly succinct. But because there are multiple documents in the Bible which cover roughly the same events, it kind of necessarily isn’t succinct as a single cohesive document.

In other words, if you rewrote the Bible as a single document, yeah, it’d be like 10% as long. But that isn’t how it was made.


I’m guessing you haven’t read it in Hebrew because the Hebrew is pretty succinct.

As for meandering, the narrative follows people who travel around to different places so I don’t know what you mean. The canon of the Bible doesn’t arrange all the books chronologically. You can read them in chronological order if you want.


The canon doesn't even arrange all the books. It's a somewhat arbitrary selection.


If we start with Genesis, we get the creation story twice. We get two instances of dude pretending his wife is his sister.


You just used the word “we” 3 times which is even more than 2. Why be so redundant?


> pierces the AirTag’s speaker

> also disables an anti-stalking feature that audibly alerts people

It sounds like piercing the speaker is the thing that disables the audible alert and the intent was not to help stalkers.


This is precisely because you are a foreigner of minority ethnicity (the minority ethnicity points towards hailing from a more traditional culture compared to if you were white and therefore you would be from Europe which does not have a traditional culture, it has a modern culture).

To clarify the idea: you have a healthy social matrix but if you marry and settle in the US, your grandchildren won't.


The term "Senate" comes from the Latin word "senex" meaning "old man", and obviously the US inherited the term "Senate" from ancient Rome. This is a basic structure of society.

The issue is that this particular group of people older than 65 at this particular time in world history (which you happen to be living in) are Boomers who are probably the most child-like, foolish, and ignorant generation of people in world history, due to the circumstances of their upbringing (post-WW2, high technology, opulence, drug use, sexual revolution, peace in the developed world).

This isn't ageism, since normally old people do tend to have more wisdom and knowledge than young people.

There is something that really went wrong with the Boomer generation. The goal of every society is basically to survive their Boomer generation which many are not really seeming to manage.


Notice that Senate wasn't the only governing party in ancient Rome. Also "old" is relative. It meant "too old to serve in military", with Sulla's reforms the minimum age was 31 and even before that most influential senators were 40-50.

For emperors: out of 80 only 14 were over 65. 2 resigned/died at 66, 1 at 67, 2 ruled only few months, so really 9 out of 80. Rome is not the place to look for old rulers


Right you have to distinguish between the executive and legislative/judicial.

The executive being young and legislative/judicial being old was pretty typical across the ancient world.

Also people tended to not live as long in old age as they do now, we have lots of advanced medical interventions we can do to keep our old people alive and accumulating power and wealth.

Also Rome had a much healthier triangle-shaped demographic/population pyramid so they had more youngish people to draw on for elite qualities. They also had an active military culture so young people could actually prove themselves in leadership positions and make a name for themself. In the developed world in the current period that is not the case.


> ...Boomers who are probably the most child-like, foolish, and ignorant generation of people in world history...

So are they the worst ever, or, like, just probably? If you are going to say something, don't weasel.


First paragraph, interesting.

The rest, off the rails.

2/5 stars.


In general, insightful social commentary have this sort of quality i.e. "I'm with you on this but where you've taken this idea seems out there", like by definition, but it does require a level of humility.

I'm not necessarily declaring what I'm saying to be insightful but what you're describing is what a typical reaction to insightful social commentary looks like.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: