While the page is publicly accessible, I think this is still meant to be under embargo and not shared broadly. From their newsletter: “Contents of this campaign page are under embargo. They are not to be publicly shared prior to our official launch on November 17th.”
Thanks for pointing that out. My apologies. I did not and do not see that notice on the website.
I received an email regarding the announcement. It didn't include any specifications so I searched "Librem 5 v2" and found this page.
After looking again at the unsolicited email I received - I see the disclaimer at the bottom in italicized text which I've been trained to ignore. It's regrettable the embargo notice was not the first paragraph of the email.
I'm not really sure what to do now. It doesn't appear I can delete a post.
I also received this email, presumably because I bought the original Librem 5.
Recipients aren't under any obligation to respect their request for an embargo if they're just cold-emailing people like this, and it's newsworthy for HN, so I don't see the problem?
Yeah I agree it's not a big problem, and OP shouldn't feel bad.
I only call it out to note this page shouldn't be taken as reflecting the level of polish Purism would want in a broadly shared release. Especially given the lack of a video and narrative launch announcement.
For what it’s worth, the latest status updates from Microsoft address this concern: “At this time, we have no evidence of malicious activity associated with this incident.”
Abscence of evidence vs evidence of absence notwithstanding, it’s probably best not to overly speculate.
I think the "at this time" is important, they were probably more focused on bringing everything back rather than doing a full investigation. I'm curious about the post mortem.
Microsoft employs enough people that they can afford to have one team scan for unusual ingress/egress traffic patterns while others work on troubleshooting. If not, they should not be shedding 60k employees right now.
I think a lot of the loss of shame is a result of multiculturalism. The more cultures you accept, the fewer behaviors you can openly shame.
As a benign example, eating food with your hands rather than utensils. In some cultures this is rarely ever tolerated, in others it depends on the food item, and in others still you might always eat with your hands. These will be at odds and you have to decide what is OK to shame and what isn’t.
I think we as a society bias against shaming in seeking inclusivity, but some things can be lost along the way as well. To use the eating example again, eating with your hands instead of utensils may be more likely to spread disease (or maybe it needs to be coupled with a stronger shame against _not_ washing hands). I don’t know what the right approach is to strike a balance here in a multicultural society.
That is an interesting possibility, and seems plausible. When in Rome… becomes not so much about getting along, and more about maintaining social coherence, fostering prosperity and security.
> As a benign example, eating food with your hands rather than utensils. In some cultures this is rarely ever tolerated, in others it depends on the food item, and in others still you might always eat with your hands.
I know there are some strange people who eat pizza with a fork, but is there actually anyone who does that with say hamburgers?
Yes, there are people who eat burgers with utensils. It's more common in quasi-formal settings like business-organized dinners where people don't want to appear messy from my experience.
I see a lot of people below arguing that this isn’t the fault of the EU policy but the companies. I think that’s being overly charitable to the policy. While you can be rightly upset with the companies behavior, ultimately policy has to work with the incentives it creates. The policy in its current form allows for meeting requirements with annoying cookie banner opt-outs while keeping the lucrative business of tracking. If we don’t want that, the policy should be changed. Don’t expect companies to go against their interests here, even if some will actually be thoughtful and find a way to do so. The “Purpose Of a System Is What It Does” principle applies, and the purpose of the EU policy seems to be cookie banners for most sites.
I’ve long believed that making companies liable for paying damages if PII is leaked in a data breach would be the best way to stop excessive tracking. If you force them to have to manage user data like they’re handling radioactive waste then the expense and overhead involved is a natural drag on the business logic that drives the bottomless appetite for data collection. They’ll collect it if they actually need it, and they’ll take great pains to secure it.
The most valuable data breach content isn’t your advertising tracking data, though.
It would be your payment information, which is orthogonal to most of the tracking data.
The black market demand for leaked advertising-related tracking data is basically nil, except maybe in cases where it’s related to something else exploitable or usable for blackmail like if someone frequents cryptocurrency exchanges or porn sites. Nobody cares to pay for black market data about you shopping for towels on Amazon or things like that.
Payment data doesn't live in a vacuum though. Every payment is authorised by your bank, who runs an AI looking for "suspicious transactions" and has a legal obligation to refund you if you lose money because any part of their payment network got hacked.
99% percent of them intentionally turn the "decline" choice into a 5 - 10 step game of dark patterns even though the EU policy says it should be equally easy to decline. They know its bullshit but they also know the chance that someone will drag them through court is low.
I got strong feelings of Vernor Vinge’s work here. I’m not sure how managed to come up with such a close picture to where it now seems programming and security is headed.
reply